Hi all,
.-- My secret spy satellite informs me that at Thu, 13 Nov 2008, Todd Underwood
wrote:
that's why i recommend that prefix hijacking detection systems do
thresholding of
peers to prevent a single, rogue, unrepresentative peer from reporting
a hijacking when none is really
With this last hijack, we see the comparison between PHAS and BGPmon. Does
anyone use other hijack tools who would be willing to compare to these two
tools wrt time to alert, number of alerts, etc. during this event?
How do folks find the extent of the damage? Using BGPlay only or are
At 10:28 AM 13-11-08 -0800, Scott Weeks wrote:
With this last hijack, we see the comparison between PHAS and
BGPmon. Does anyone use other hijack tools who would be willing to
compare to these two tools wrt time to alert, number of alerts, etc.
during this event?
How do folks find the
hank, all,
On Thu, Nov 13, 2008 at 08:57:35PM +0200, Hank Nussbacher wrote:
I use all 4 - BGPmon, RIPE, PHAS, and Watchmy.net.
BGPMon kicks ass on all of them. RIPE showed up 5-6 hours later. PHAS and
Watchmy were nowhere to be seen.
is that a bug or a feature?
this was a non-event in
--- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
From: Todd Underwood [EMAIL PROTECTED]
interesting, but it's not operationally significant. i would not
consider the fact that PHAS and Watchmy didn't alert any particular
criticism of them.
but perhaps there was something else to which you were referring.
It may be the North American NOG, but it's been said before that it functions
as a GNOG, G for Global. I don't think Brazil is insignificant. I respect
Todd's work greatly, but I think he's wrong on this point.
- original message -
Subject:Re: Prefix Hijack Tool Comaprision
From
alexander, all,
On Thu, Nov 13, 2008 at 07:56:26PM +, Alexander Harrowell wrote:
It may be the North American NOG, but it's been said before that it
functions as a GNOG, G for Global. I don't think Brazil is
insignificant. I respect Todd's work greatly, but I think he's wrong
on this
OK. This seems to be a flaw in RIPE RIS, a pity because BGPlay is great.
- original message -
Subject:Re: Prefix Hijack Tool Comaprision
From: Todd Underwood [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Date: 13/11/2008 8:05 pm
alexander, all,
On Thu, Nov 13, 2008 at 07:56:26PM +, Alexander
Todd Underwood wrote:
i said that *this* hijacking took place in an insignificant corner of
the internet. i mean this AS-map wise rather than geographically.
this hijacking didn't even spread beyond one or two ASes, one of whom
just happened to be a RIPE RIS peer.
Yet for someone
of what to send
and what to drop.
Mohit
Date: Thu, 13 Nov 2008 20:27:32 +
From: Alexander Harrowell [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: Re: Prefix Hijack Tool Comaprision
To: Todd Underwood [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: nanog@nanog.org
OK. This seems to be a flaw in RIPE RIS, a pity because BGPlay
10 matches
Mail list logo
