Re: Can I do this in EVPN? (Multihome to more different CEs)

2023-02-09 Thread Joshua Miller
Hi Simon, This looks like an interesting project. What are you ultimately trying to achieve? Stretching an Ethernet segment between sites shouldn't be the first choice, but I imagine you're having to deal with some legacy use case and your hands are tied. I'm a little curious on what that might

RE: Can I do this in EVPN? (Multihome to more different CEs)

2023-02-09 Thread Adam Thompson
via NANOG > Sent: February 9, 2023 1:11 PM > Cc: nanog@nanog.org > Subject: Re: Can I do this in EVPN? (Multihome to more different CEs) > > VPLS doesn't handle loop avoidance. At least, not apart from split > horizon rules. > > I assume that them properly connecting routers

Re: Can I do this in EVPN? (Multihome to more different CEs)

2023-02-09 Thread Jason R. Rokeach via NANOG
VPLS doesn't handle loop avoidance. At least, not apart from split horizon rules. I assume that them properly connecting routers only and doing dynamic routing over your service is out of the question? (Even _just_ doing this doesn't completely solve the challenge though.) It sounds to me

Re: Can I do this in EVPN? (Multihome to more different CEs)

2023-02-09 Thread Simon Lockhart
On Thu Feb 09, 2023 at 11:54:28AM -0500, Shawn L wrote: > You should be able to setup a VPLS between 3 (or more) devices. Something > like this -- [snip] Thanks - I'm not committed to EVPN, so VPLS could work too. Would VPLS handle loop avoidance for me? (i.e. if I have two VPLS PE connections

RE: Can I do this in EVPN? (Multihome to more different CEs)

2023-02-09 Thread Shawn L via NANOG
You should be able to setup a VPLS between 3 (or more) devices. Something like this -- Example: VFI on a PE Device The following example shows a virtual forwarding instance (VFI) configuration: Device(config)# l2 vfi vfi110 manual Device(config-vfi)# vpn id 110 Device(config-vfi)# neighbor