Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-29 Thread Patrick Tracanelli
On 28/01/2015, at 23:38, Song Li refresh.ls...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Patrick, We want to know what's the reason for the received routes containing local ASN. Hence we need real cases of those routes in the Internet. And any routes like that are welcome, whether they are on Juniper router

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread Chuck Anderson
It used to be the case that looped routes didn't even show up as hidden routes, because Junos discarded them even from Adj-RIB-In, although this may have changed at some Junos version. Also, Junos won't even advertise such looped routes to a neighbor with the same AS by default, so in many cases

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread Pedro Cavaca
If your ISP utilizes Juniper platforms, you might have to ask them to allow the advertisement of these routes, see http://www.firstdigest.com/2012/09/cisco-vs-juniper-different-ebgp-behavior/ On 28 January 2015 at 09:32, Song Li refresh.ls...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Joel, It is right that the BGP

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread Song Li
Thanks! It seems hard to see such routes on the edge router. Nonetheless, we do believe there must exist such routes in the wild. We still hope to find some real cases of them. If anybody see them in your routers, please let us know. Regards! Song 在 2015/1/28 21:27, Chuck Anderson 写道: It

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread Song Li
Hi Joel, It is right that the BGP route containing the local ASN will be droped. However, such routes can still be displayed on router. For example, you can run show route hidden terse aspath-regex .*local ASN.* on Juniper to check them. We are looking for those routes. If you can run the

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread joel jaeggli
On 1/27/15 5:45 AM, Song Li wrote: Hi everyone, Recently I studied the BGP AS path looping problem, and found that in most cases, the received BGP routes containing local AS# are suspicious. However, we checked our BGP routing table (AS23910,CERNET2) on juniper router(show route hidden

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread Song Li
Hi Patrick, We want to know what's the reason for the received routes containing local ASN. Hence we need real cases of those routes in the Internet. And any routes like that are welcome, whether they are on Juniper router or other BGP software. Thank you! Regards! Song 在 2015/1/29 1:50,

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread Patrick Tracanelli
On 28/01/2015, at 07:32, Song Li refresh.ls...@gmail.com wrote: Hi Joel, It is right that the BGP route containing the local ASN will be droped. However, such routes can still be displayed on router. For example, you can run show route hidden terse aspath-regex .*local ASN.* on Juniper

Re: look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-28 Thread joel jaeggli
On 1/28/15 1:32 AM, Song Li wrote: Hi Joel, It is right that the BGP route containing the local ASN will be droped. However, such routes can still be displayed on router. There is also the non-zero probability that they don't arrive. If this is and edge router if your neighbor is a juniper

look for BGP routes containing local AS#

2015-01-27 Thread Song Li
Hi everyone, Recently I studied the BGP AS path looping problem, and found that in most cases, the received BGP routes containing local AS# are suspicious. However, we checked our BGP routing table (AS23910,CERNET2) on juniper router(show route hidden terse aspath-regex .*23910.* ), and have