Re: public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-05 Thread David Conrad
Brandon, On Apr 4, 2013, at 5:35 PM, Brandon Butterworth bran...@rd.bbc.co.uk wrote: You do realize this requires changing validating resolver configuration data, right? Yes. How hard can it be (answer not required). While it's quaint that the elders of the internet meet and bless each

Re: public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-05 Thread Randy Bush
rant The point of the wildly over-engineered root key signing ceremony is to build trust by publicly demonstrating at every step there is no opportunity for intentional or accidental badness to occur without being noticed. at some point, long passed, the more pomp, the less safe i feel.

Re: public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-05 Thread David Conrad
Randy, On Apr 6, 2013, at 7:10 AM, Randy Bush ra...@psg.com wrote: at some point, long passed, the more pomp, the less safe i feel. Have you actually watched/participated in a root key signing ceremony? Pomp is not the term I would use. there is protecting against technical/engineering

Re: public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-04 Thread David Conrad
On Apr 4, 2013, at 12:59 AM, Brandon Butterworth bran...@rd.bbc.co.uk wrote: The topic at hand and the specific questions that have been asked as part of the consultation are important ones; Do it when you feel like, nobody should notice. Anything this important should be routine procedure,

Re: public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-04 Thread Brandon Butterworth
The topic at hand and the specific questions that have been asked as part of the consultation are important ones; Do it when you feel like, nobody should notice. Anything this important should be routine procedure, make it daily. You do realize this requires changing validating

public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-03 Thread Joe Abley
Hi all, As advised a month or so ago, the following public comment period is open: http://www.icann.org/en/news/public-comment/root-zone-consultation-08mar13-en.htm We have received a small number of responses which are accessible from that page. The topic at hand and the specific

Re: public consultation on root zone KSK rollover

2013-04-03 Thread Brandon Butterworth
The topic at hand and the specific questions that have been asked as part of the consultation are important ones; Do it when you feel like, nobody should notice. Anything this important should be routine procedure, make it daily. the decisions taken will have operational consequences to any