Re: RPKI unknown for superprefixes of existing ROA ?

2023-10-21 Thread William Herrin
On Sat, Oct 21, 2023 at 11:47 AM Mark Tinka wrote: > The question is - who gets to decide how much space is "too large"? I thought Amir's point was that if an announced route is larger than the RIR allocation then unless you're intentionally expecting it, it's invalid. Because there's no

Re: RPKI unknown for superprefixes of existing ROA ?

2023-10-21 Thread Mark Tinka
On 10/21/23 16:03, Amir Herzberg wrote: Hi Owen, Randy, Job and other NANOGers, I surely agree with you all that we shouldn't expect discarding of ROA-unknown `anytime soon' (or ever?). But I have a question: what about discarding ROA-unknowns for very large prefixes (say, /12), or for

RPKI unknown for superprefixes of existing ROA ?

2023-10-21 Thread Amir Herzberg
Hi Owen, Randy, Job and other NANOGers, I surely agree with you all that we shouldn't expect discarding of ROA-unknown `anytime soon' (or ever?). But I have a question: what about discarding ROA-unknowns for very large prefixes (say, /12), or for superprefixes of prefixes with announced ROAs? Or