Re: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-26 Thread Joe Abley
On 25 Sep 2008, at 18:55, Craig Holland wrote: ...ones that only originate from RADB. This is the part that I found strange considering the ARIN records are in (show up in) RADB and they are what most would consider a trusted source. The only RPSL repository that I know of that has any

RE: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-25 Thread David Schwartz
Hi, I recently ran across a situation where a large ISP only accepts IRR entries generated by RADB to build their path filters. I use the ARIN Routing Registry. Is this a common practice? Should I convert over to RADB? Thanks, Craig Since 2002, the RADB has included entries that

Re: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-25 Thread Christian Koch
Sounds ridiculous...radb mirrors arins db, I don't see why they are trying to force you to use radb. You can query whois.radb.net and you will be able to see your arin objects... Did they give you a reason on WHY you should have to use RADB? Christian On Thu, Sep 25, 2008 at 6:38 PM, Craig

Re: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-25 Thread bmanning
On Thu, Sep 25, 2008 at 05:38:26PM -0500, Craig Holland wrote: Hi, I recently ran across a situation where a large ISP only accepts IRR entries generated by RADB to build their path filters. I use the ARIN Routing Registry. Is this a common practice? Should I convert over to RADB?

RE: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-25 Thread Craig Holland
, 2008 3:53 PM To: Craig Holland Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X Sounds ridiculous...radb mirrors arins db, I don't see why they are trying to force you to use radb. You can query whois.radb.net and you will be able to see your arin objects... Did

Re: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-25 Thread Joe Provo
On Thu, Sep 25, 2008 at 05:57:20PM -0500, Craig Holland wrote: They gave no particular reason. I figured I'd ask ya'all before I started to push back and use phrases like 'silly', 'ridiculous', and 'pointless' in my argument to them. Allow me: It is silly to attempt to use only a single

Re: ARIN Routing Registry vs RADB vs X

2008-09-25 Thread Randy Bush
i think that what may have been glossed over here is that, if my memory serves, which it often does not, while a whois query to RADB will show mirrored entries from e.g. RGNET peval() to RADB will not yield those mirrored data this is a feature, not a bug, as one wants to order the peval()