Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Jim Mercer
i remember implementing quasi-QoS on uucp. after having our modem pool hogged too many times by a select few users, i put a script into our mail system. if the script determined an email was X bytes (100k?), the message body was rewritten with: Contents removed at LSUC, email is not a file

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Vadim Antonov
It wasn't Moscow State U. It was privately-owned network (called RELCOM) from the day one (which was in 1990, not 1987... in 1987 connecting a dial-up modem to phone network was still illegal in the USSR), built by DEMOS co-op (that company is still alive, by the way). Moscow State U was one of

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Michael Sokolov
Jim Mercer j...@reptiles.org wrote: if the script determined an email was X bytes (100k?), the message body was rewritten with: Contents removed at LSUC, email is not a file transport protocol. and the mail was left to continue on its path. i kinda feel like adding the same script back

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Lamar Owen
On Saturday 03 April 2010 09:38:46 pm IPv3.com wrote: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? 'The Internet' is a collective internetworking of several thousand autonomous systems, using a common protocol, that masquerades as a unified whole. Whether this protocol is 1822, NCP, or IPvX

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Larry Sheldon
On 4/5/2010 10:21, Michael Sokolov wrote: Jim Mercer j...@reptiles.org wrote: if the script determined an email was X bytes (100k?), the message body was rewritten with: Contents removed at LSUC, email is not a file transport protocol. and the mail was left to continue on its path. i

RE: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Joe
- From: Michael Sokolov [mailto:msoko...@ivan.harhan.org] Sent: Monday, April 05, 2010 11:22 AM To: nanog@nanog.org Subject: Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? Jim Mercer j...@reptiles.org wrote: if the script determined an email was X bytes (100k?), the message

RE: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? (Jim Mercer)

2010-04-05 Thread Joel M Snyder
The ability to build dirt-cheap networks over crappy phone lines and using some no-name PCs as message and packet routers was noticed, see for example: Developing Networks in Less Industrialized Nations by Larry Press Heck, I even wrote my PhD dissertation

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-05 Thread Owen DeLong
On Apr 4, 2010, at 12:18 PM, Steven Bellovin wrote: On Apr 4, 2010, at 3:08 16PM, Lyndon Nerenberg wrote: File transfer wasn't multihop It was, for at least some versions (V2 and later?), if the intermediate site(s) allowed execution of the uucp command. 25 years on the brain is

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread James Bensley
If you did some more reading this would all be come clear? On 4 April 2010 02:38, IPv3.com ipv3@gmail.com wrote: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? Well both and neither, both of these are used and much more! As of 2010, many people would likely answer that question based

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread James Bensley
Sorry for double post: Also having the email account ipv3@gmail.com, thats not very useful? This sort email address should be on the list rules like that other fellow who was spamming about top 50 AS's for botnets/spam etc. -- Regards, James. http://www.jamesbensley.co.cc/

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Randy Bush
Also having the email account ipv3@gmail.com, thats not very useful? an amazing insight! we need an email address police to get rid of those folk who have un-american email addresses. randy

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Suresh Ramasubramanian
On Sun, Apr 4, 2010 at 2:42 PM, James Bensley jwbens...@gmail.com wrote: Also having the email account ipv3@gmail.com, thats not very useful? He's still got to reach the heights of IPv9 -- Suresh Ramasubramanian (ops.li...@gmail.com)

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Larry Sheldon
On 4/3/2010 21:36, Joe Greco wrote: What if TCP is removed ? and IP is completely re-worked in the same 160-bit foot-print as IPv4 ? Would 64-bit Addressing last a few years ? I must have dozed off--what is the connection between the Subject: and the recent traffic under it. The Internet (Note

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Larry Sheldon
On 4/4/2010 00:29, Randy Bush wrote: UNIX-to-UNIX Service-Based solutions pre-date many ARPA DARPA DOD funding programs run by people who do not write code you're shocking lack of clue is showing As is the lack of access to any of a large collection of books, articles, and anecdotes.

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
UUCP is not a descriptor of any kind of a network in any engineering sense that I know of.  It is a point-to-point communications protocol. You should revise some of the history behind it. It was a descriptor for a very large network, it was even a TLD in the mid eighties when the transition to

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
UNIX-to-UNIX Service-Based solutions pre-date many ARPA DARPA DOD funding programs run by people who do not write code you're shocking lack of clue is showing As is the lack of access to any of a large collection of books, articles, and anecdotes.  (Access here meaning physical access to a

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jim Mercer
On Sun, Apr 04, 2010 at 09:57:12AM -0500, Jorge Amodio wrote: You should revise some of the history behind it. It was a descriptor for a very large network, it was even a TLD in the mid eighties when the transition to DNS was taking place, the old bang style addresses like mine original

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Larry Sheldon
On 4/4/2010 09:57, Jorge Amodio wrote: UUCP is not a descriptor of any kind of a network in any engineering sense that I know of. It is a point-to-point communications protocol. You should revise some of the history behind it. It was a descriptor for a very large network, it was even a TLD

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Larry Sheldon
On 4/4/2010 10:37, Jim Mercer wrote: On Sun, Apr 04, 2010 at 09:57:12AM -0500, Jorge Amodio wrote: You should revise some of the history behind it. It was a descriptor for a very large network, it was even a TLD in the mid eighties when the transition to DNS was taking place, the old bang

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Lyndon Nerenberg
File transfer wasn't multihop It was, for at least some versions (V2 and later?), if the intermediate site(s) allowed execution of the uucp command. 25 years on the brain is fuzzy on the details ... --lyndon

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Steven Bellovin
On Apr 4, 2010, at 3:08 16PM, Lyndon Nerenberg wrote: File transfer wasn't multihop It was, for at least some versions (V2 and later?), if the intermediate site(s) allowed execution of the uucp command. 25 years on the brain is fuzzy on the details ... You could certainly add uux and

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Lyndon Nerenberg
You could certainly add uux and uux to the list of legal remote commands, but I confess that my memory is also dim about whether uucp file a!b!c would be translated automatically. It has indeed been a while... I'm pretty sure it was adding 'uucp' in the commands list that enabled

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
i don't recall .uucp making it into the actual DNS, but i remember our mail system used it as a trigger to do a uucp-maps lookup. It was for a brief period of time as a pseudo-domain and placeholder for MX RRs for machines participating in the UUCP project. Mary Ann Horton (formerly Mark

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
But when I think of network I think of things like the PSTN, ABC, Mutual, California's DOJ torn-tape TTY, and FIDO where the message to be delivered was the focus and the internal works were pretty much uninteresting to the user. Read Notable Computer Networks, John Quarterman and Josiah

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
That the UUCP world developed links to The Internet (and FIDONet, and BITNET and ) goes without saying.  But landing you Piper Cherokee at LAX doesn't make you part of the Commercial Airline Industry. That's how for some time the distinction between internet and Internet was born. Jorge

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jaap Akkerhuis
It was, for at least some versions (V2 and later?), if the intermediate site(s) allowed execution of the uucp command. 25 years on the brain is fuzzy on the details ... You could certainly add uux and uux to the list of legal remote commands, but I confess that my memory is

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Bruce Williams
This is an example of the law that the number of replys is directly propotional to the cluelessness of the post? Bruce On Sun, Apr 4, 2010 at 1:43 PM, Jaap Akkerhuis j...@nlnetlabs.nl wrote:    It was, for at least some versions (V2 and later?), if the    intermediate site(s) allowed

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jim Burwell
On 4/4/2010 12:18, Steven Bellovin wrote: On Apr 4, 2010, at 3:08 16PM, Lyndon Nerenberg wrote: File transfer wasn't multihop It was, for at least some versions (V2 and later?), if the intermediate site(s) allowed execution of the uucp command. 25 years on the brain is fuzzy on

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Randy Bush
the visibility of the path was the only thing ordinary users had to worry about. you forgot, and thus sigs were born. they once served a purpose other than ego randy

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Randy Bush
fwiw, i still run uucp for a very few remaining odd sites. randy

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Steven Bellovin
On Apr 4, 2010, at 6:55 07PM, Randy Bush wrote: the visibility of the path was the only thing ordinary users had to worry about. you forgot, and thus sigs were born. they once served a purpose other than ego Right, of course -- they had to show the uucp path from a well-known node.

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Sun, 04 Apr 2010 19:01:30 EDT, Steven Bellovin said: Right, of course -- they had to show the uucp path from a well-known node. I remember trying to debug a very messy mail routing problem some 25 years ago, which we finally traced back to the fact that pathalias was too smart by half, and

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Barry Shein
I remember around 1987 when Helsinki (Univ I believe) hooked up Talinn, Estonia via uucp (including usenet), who then hooked up MSU (Moscow State Univ) and the traffic began flowing. You could just about see the wide-eyed disbelief by some as they saw for example alt.politics, you people just

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
I remember around 1987 when Helsinki (Univ I believe) hooked up Talinn, Estonia via uucp (including usenet), who then hooked up MSU (Moscow State Univ) and the traffic began flowing. I bet that there many histories, perhaps those that didn't have access to modern communications and vast

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jim Burwell
On 4/4/2010 17:20, Barry Shein wrote: I still believe that had as much to do with the collapse of the Soviet Union as the million other politicians who wish to take credit. It's arguable that UUCP (and Usenet, email, etc that it carried) was one of the most powerful forces for change in

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Jorge Amodio
I agree.  I remember back in the 80s when I first got access to UseNet and UUCP based email thinking and saying things like the net will change the world, because for the first time people from all over the globe were communicating fairly openly and inexpensively, and somehow the internet and

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Robert Brockway
On Sun, 4 Apr 2010, Jim Burwell wrote: I agree. I remember back in the 80s when I first got access to UseNet and UUCP based email thinking and saying things like the net will change the world, because for the first time people from all over the globe were communicating fairly openly and

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-04 Thread Larry Sheldon
On 4/4/2010 09:02, Larry Sheldon wrote: This attribution line is wrong--I meant to leave only the two line below it--for my purposes it did matter who said it. On 4/3/2010 21:36, Joe Greco wrote: The line above should have been edited out leaving only these two. What if TCP is removed ? and

What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-03 Thread IPv3.com
What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? As of 2010, many people would likely answer that question based on the Services they use as opposed to a religious adoration for TCP/IP. What if TCP is removed ? and IP is completely re-worked in the same 160-bit foot-print as IPv4 ? Would 64-bit

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-03 Thread Jorge Amodio
What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? None of the above. Read the instructions manual and don't abuse your meds. J.

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-03 Thread Joe Greco
What if TCP is removed ? and IP is completely re-worked in the same 160-bit foot-print as IPv4 ? Would 64-bit Addressing last a few years ? IPv6 is a loser because everyone has to carry the overhead of bloated packets. It is a one-size-fits-all take it or leave it solution. By that logic,

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-03 Thread Dave CROCKER
On 4/3/2010 6:38 PM, IPv3.com wrote: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ? As of 2010, many people would likely answer that question based on the Services they use as opposed to a religious adoration for TCP/IP. See: http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc1775.txt ...anti-v6 religious

Re: What is The Internet TCP/IP or UNIX-to-UNIX ?

2010-04-03 Thread Randy Bush
UNIX-to-UNIX Service-Based solutions pre-date many ARPA DARPA DOD funding programs run by people who do not write code you're shocking lack of clue is showing randy