Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-12-02 Thread Owen DeLong
On Nov 25, 2014, at 10:56 AM, Bill Woodcock wo...@pch.net wrote: On Nov 25, 2014, at 10:47 AM, Colton Conor colton.co...@gmail.com wrote: I know typically peering exchanges are made for peering traffic between providers, but can you buy IP transit from a provider on an exchange? An

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-30 Thread Colton Conor
Yes, we could of course pay for some space and power with a shared hosting provider, but buying a full rack and power for a single router seems silly. The ideal person to buy the small amount of space and power from would be the transport provider that is transporting us to Equinix, but in most

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-30 Thread Clayton
turned up - significant. I'd say that we now get 2/3 of our inbound by peering, the rest via transit. Netflix is the obvious reason... - Original Message --- Subject: Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange From: Colton Conor colton.co...@gmail.com Date: Sun, 30 Nov

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-30 Thread Justin Wilson
Having run an exchange, I can speak to a couple of points. 1.An exchange is only as good as any other provider. If they don¹t have a redundant design then you have more room for failure. Same can be said about good staff behind it. If they know what they are doing and keep it simple, then it

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-30 Thread Clayton
the one you registered with them (Equnix filters the MAC, but doesn't apply a 60 minute port shut down penalty if you leak like TorIX does). - Original Message --- Subject: Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange From: Justin Wilson li...@mtin.net Date: Sun, 30 Nov 2014

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-30 Thread Stephen Fulton
Hi Clayton, Putting on my TorIX hat, I'll address what you've brought up: 1. We implemented port security because MAC ACL's were not effectively blocking certain types of bad traffic, which was a problem with the hardware in place at the time. As you are certainly aware, getting vendors to

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On Tuesday, November 25, 2014 09:51:47 PM Colton Conor wrote: Are exchanges really that unreliable compared to a traditional cross connect? Not necessarily. It's just that when money is changing hands, folk tend to find (passive) x-connects within the data centre to be far more reliable

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On Tuesday, November 25, 2014 10:34:14 PM Eric Van Tol wrote: It's been a while since I've checked the Equinix Customer Agreement and Policies documents, but I know at one time they required a physical presence in the in the IDC for an Exchange cross-connect. This may have changed in the

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On Tuesday, November 25, 2014 11:03:16 PM Bob Evans wrote: I agree with Bill...going it on the cheap is risky. DOn't consider it for primary. It may be good for backup. I have sold small amounts of transit to non-ISP companies on exchanges (100-200 meg). It's a good extra backup for ISPs, if

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Ammar Zuberi
Hi, I’m pretty sure IX Reach can take you into an Equinix exchange, so it is probably possible that they allow this kind of stuff to happen. Ammar. This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Mark Tinka
On Wednesday, November 26, 2014 02:42:39 PM Ammar Zuberi wrote: I’m pretty sure IX Reach can take you into an Equinix exchange, so it is probably possible that they allow this kind of stuff to happen. I meant in terms of a reseller model between the exchange point and preferred service

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Tue, 25 Nov 2014 15:34:14 -0500, Eric Van Tol said: but I know at one time they required a physical presence in the in the IDC for an Exchange cross-connect. At the risk of being snarky, if somebody doesn't have a presence where do you connect the other end of the cross-connect cable? :)

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Colton Conor
Well, we would have a BGP router in another town. Then get a wave from a transport provider from the other town to the town that equinix or the peering exchange was located at. The cross connect would go from the transport providers Z location to the port on the exchange. I have confirmed that

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
peering exchange was located at. The cross connect would go from the transport providers Z location to the port on the exchange. I have In which case the cross connect is between the target and Z, who *has* a physical presence at the exchange pgp0hLFgZZD1w.pgp Description: PGP signature

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-26 Thread Rob Seastrom
Colton Conor colton.co...@gmail.com writes: Some might ask why not get a cross connect to the provider. It is cheaper to buy an port on the exchange (which includes the cross connect to the exchange) than buy multiple cross connects. Plus we are planning on getting a wave to the exchange,

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Randy Epstein
On 11/25/14, 1:47 PM, Colton Conor colton.co...@gmail.com wrote: I know typically peering exchanges are made for peering traffic between providers, but can you buy IP transit from a provider on an exchange? An example, buy a 10G port on an exchange, peer 5Gbps of traffic with multiple providers

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Nick Hilliard
On 25/11/2014 18:47, Colton Conor wrote: Is this possible? it depends. Some transit providers will decline to do this because it can impact on their margin. Most IXPs don't have a problem with it, but some do - although it's not clear how they can tell which packets are transit and which are

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Bill Woodcock
On Nov 25, 2014, at 10:47 AM, Colton Conor colton.co...@gmail.com wrote: I know typically peering exchanges are made for peering traffic between providers, but can you buy IP transit from a provider on an exchange? An example, buy a 10G port on an exchange, peer 5Gbps of traffic with multiple

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Chris Rogers
I know a couple networks that offer to sell transit over exchanges that permit it, but require that you take a private VLAN on the exchange. Some exchanges offer private VLANs, others don't. Regards, Chris Rogers +1.302.357.3696 x2110 http://inerail.net/ On Tue, Nov 25, 2014 at 1:51 PM, Nick

RE: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Tony Wicks
: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange I know a couple networks that offer to sell transit over exchanges that permit it, but require that you take a private VLAN on the exchange. Some exchanges offer private VLANs, others don't. Regards, Chris Rogers +1.302.357.3696 x2110 http://inerail.net/

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Colton Conor
The exchange in question is Equinix. Their sales team is leading me to believe there are multiple exchange products. One where you can peer with providers (Google, Netflix for example) and then one where you can create virtual private layer 2 vlans between providers. Then there is also the

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Bob Evans
I agree with Bill...going it on the cheap is risky. DOn't consider it for primary. It may be good for backup. I have sold small amounts of transit to non-ISP companies on exchanges (100-200 meg). It's a good extra backup for ISPs, if you setup your local pref, MED and then prepend your AS an extra

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Faisal Imtiaz
: Tuesday, November 25, 2014 2:51:47 PM Subject: Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange The exchange in question is Equinix. Their sales team is leading me to believe there are multiple exchange products. One where you can peer with providers (Google, Netflix for example) and then one

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Ammar Zuberi
Hi Conor, I know this is possible since Hurricane Electric does it for IPv6 transit, however, I'm not sure if it violates any exchange rules or if it's even a good idea. On 25 Nov 2014, at 10:47 pm, Colton Conor colton.co...@gmail.com wrote: I know typically peering exchanges are made for

RE: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Eric Van Tol
Plus we are planning on getting a wave to the exchange, and not having any physical routers or switches at the datacenter where the exchange/wave terminates at. Is this possible? It's been a while since I've checked the Equinix Customer Agreement and Policies documents, but I know at one time

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Justin Wilson
...@fastreturn.net Cc: NANOG nanog@nanog.org Sent: Tuesday, November 25, 2014 2:51:47 PM Subject: Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange The exchange in question is Equinix. Their sales team is leading me to believe there are multiple exchange products. One where you can peer

Re: Buying IP Bandwidth Across a Peering Exchange

2014-11-25 Thread Gregg Berkholtz
Be careful joining an IX just to peer with Google (AS15169) and a few others...especially if your exchange doesn’t have route servers established. Some companies, such as NetFlix, have a truly open peering policy; establishing a bilateral BGP session with them is super-straightforward. On the