I have been able to use MFD to implement a mib table without any problem. 
I have prior SNMP knowledge but have only worked on enemate (on HP-UX 
ofcource). I think I may not have understood one thing in the way mib2c is 
generating the stubs so my first question:

1) Generated code:
In function

xxxTable_container_load()
The test used befor populating a column defined as:
  wpiPath   DisplayString

     /* Code taht I have problem with */

     if ((NULL == rowreq_ctx->data.wpiPath) ||
         (rowreq_ctx->data.wpiPath_len <
         (wpiPath_len * sizeof(wpiPath[0])))) {
       snmp_log(LOG_ERR, "not enoughhhhh space for value %s %d\n",wpiPath, 
wpiPath_len);
       return MFD_ERROR;
     }
     rowreq_ctx->data.wpiPath_len = wpiPath_len * sizeof(wpiPath[0]);
     memcpy(rowreq_ctx->data.wpiPath, wpiPath,
            wpiPath_len * sizeof(wpiPath[0]));


  "if" above will always fail because the generated data structor for 
wpiPath by mib2c is:

         /*
          * 
wpiPath(2)/DisplayString/ASN_OCTET_STR/char(char)//L/A/w/e/R/d/H
          */
         char            wpiPath[255];
         size_t          wpiPath_len;    /* # of char elements, not bytes */

Would it not always fail? because rowreq_ctx->data.wpiPath_len has not 
been populated, and also what does "of char elements, not  bytes" means in 
above aomments. wouldn't wpiPath_len * sizeof(wpiPath[0]))  still be 
strlen(wpiPath).

The MFD tutorial is using hardcoded values like 6 for ifPhysAddress_len, 
how would I calculate the length (wpi_len)?.

Would I be doing semething wrong by using:
   if((wpiPath_len * sizeof(wpiPath[0])) > 255){
    Or in this case just
       if(wpiPath_len > 255){

2) Is there any performance loss using MFD compared to older ways of 
implementing the MIB.

Thanks for kind handholding

Regards


-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT
Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your
opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys - and earn cash
http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV
_______________________________________________
Net-snmp-coders mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/net-snmp-coders

Reply via email to