Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-24 Thread Luis QuaggaSnmp
Thank you so much. I will read that tutorial and will tell you my experience 2010/11/24 Dave Shield > On 24 November 2010 06:57, Bart Van Assche wrote: > > It might be a better idea to convert Quagga from SMUX to AgentX. If you > do > > this properly, it will be possible to choose at run-time b

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-24 Thread Dave Shield
On 24 November 2010 06:57, Bart Van Assche wrote: > It might be a better idea to convert Quagga from SMUX to AgentX. If you do > this properly, it will be possible to choose at run-time between running > Quagga as a stand-alone agent or an AgentX-subagent. I would strongly support this approach.

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Bart Van Assche
On Wed, Nov 24, 2010 at 12:35 AM, Luis QuaggaSnmp wrote: > The OS will be always Unix. > I really want to monitoring Quagga without install Net-Snmp. > Now a days, if you want to monitoring a PC with quagga, you have to install > Net-Snmp in this PC. > What I want to do is implement snmpd daemon i

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Luis QuaggaSnmp
Hello Claus. The OS will be always Unix. I really want to monitoring Quagga without install Net-Snmp. Now a days, if you want to monitoring a PC with quagga, you have to install Net-Snmp in this PC. What I want to do is implement snmpd daemon into Quagga. I think putting the snmpd code into quagga

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Claus Klein
Hello, I worked with Quagga and net-snmp on an embedded system a view yeas ago. What i missed was a read/write implementation of the OSPF MIB. If you only want to monitor the if/ip/routing mibs, it works fine with net-snmp without quagga. The main question seems what you really want to do: * To

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Luis QuaggaSnmp
Thank you very much. In answer to your question, I´m looking just reporting routing-related information. For example, when a new ip adress is added. I want to implement Quagga code with snmp daemon inside. So, if I install Quagga in a PC(1), it is not necessary to install Net-SNMP. >From another

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Dave Shield
On 23 November 2010 15:29, Quagga Snmp wrote: > In this situation, in PC(1) is necessary to install two things: quagga AND > stock snmpd. > In my project, I want the snmp daemon into quagga. > I need install only one thing: quagga I think that's somewhat misleading. In the current configuration

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Steve Friedl
On Tue, Nov 23, 2010 at 04:29:31PM +0100, Quagga Snmp wrote: > In this situation, in PC(1) is necessary to install two things: quagga AND > stock snmpd. I understand what you say. > I have to do this project to finish my university studies, if I wanted to do > this, I ´d use your idea. > > Quagga

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Quagga Snmp
In this situation, in PC(1) is necessary to install two things: quagga AND stock snmpd. I understand what you say. I have to do this project to finish my university studies, if I wanted to do this, I ´d use your idea. Quagga is constructed in modules ( rip daemon, bgp daemon, etc...). In my projec

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Steve Friedl
On Tue, Nov 23, 2010 at 03:18:03PM +0100, Quagga Snmp wrote: > But, with SMUX I need a intermediary, or not? I guess so, depending on what you mean. It's been a while since I worked on this, but if I recall correctly you'd need two things: * Stock snmpd, the same one that ships with the distro (

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Quagga Snmp
But, with SMUX I need a intermediary, or not? My idea, I have a PC(1) with Quagga, and other PC(2) with MRTG (monitoring software), and I want to ask some variables from PC(2) to PC(1) without intermediate software. For example, I want to ask which is the value of "ip_forward" in PC(1) from PC(2).

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Steve Friedl
On Tue, Nov 23, 2010 at 02:48:13PM +0100, Quagga Snmp wrote: > Quagga itself does not support SNMP agent (server daemon) functionality but > is able to connect to a SNMP agent using the SMUX protocol. > > I want that quagga support SNMP agent (daemon snmpd) without installing > other software, I m

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Quagga Snmp
Quagga itself does not support SNMP agent (server daemon) functionality but is able to connect to a SNMP agent using the SMUX protocol. I want that quagga support SNMP agent (daemon snmpd) without installing other software, I mean, if you install Quagga software in a PC, immediately you can send "

Re: SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Dave Shield
On 23 November 2010 12:09, Quagga Snmp wrote: > I´m working in a project of my university. The tarjet is to insert a snmp > daemon in Quagga (routing suite). > > Is anyone working in this? I'm no expert on Quagga, but I believe it already has SNMP support (running as a SMUX subagent) See http://

SNMP in Quagga

2010-11-23 Thread Quagga Snmp
Hello. I´m a new user in this list. My name is Luis, I´m from Madrid ( Spain ). I´m working in a project of my university. The tarjet is to insert a snmp daemon in Quagga (routing suite). Is anyone working in this? Quagga is constructed with modules: a module for RIP (ripd), other module for OSP