Re: Nightmare or Opening? the Soros perspective

2012-06-16 Thread Murray Simpson
And as historian Harold Perkin noted, most of the people we now refer to as 'capitalists' make most of their money from hugely inflated salaries. Whilst they may own shares, their control of capital lies in their 'control' of public companies, rather than in their direct 'ownership' of them. On 16

Re: Nightmare or Opening? the Soros perspective

2012-06-16 Thread brian.hol...@aliceadsl.fr
Marx's class analysis needs to be refurbished for our purposes. He took it from Ricardo's refinement of classical political economy: three classes landlords, capitalists and workers, each with property in one of the three things that matter: land (nature), capital (money or society, says Polanyi) a

Re: Nightmare or Opening? the Soros perspective

2012-06-16 Thread Keith Hart
There is a lot to engage with in this exchange between Brian and Felix. In a nutshell, Polanyi opposed class analysis as such. Class interests have a serious impact only when they express the interests of society as a whole. These classes can come from anywhere, but what matters is their contingent