Re: Identity and difference

2018-10-27 Thread Ian Alan Paul
"Like charismatic Candace Owens says on Fox News these days, race does not exist to her. Neither does it to me. And gender is merely a rough but not fixed orientation toward dividual archetypes of tribal contribution." What a strikingly ahistorical, antimaterialist, and ideological statement. Anyo

Identity and difference

2018-10-27 Thread Alexander Bard
Dear Ian It's great that you bring up Asad Haider because he is a brilliant historian of identity politics and I agree with him that the big shift happened in 1977. But while for Haider 1977 meant a deepening of emancipatory struggle to include feminist and anti-racist minoritarian causes that he

Re: Identity and difference

2018-10-27 Thread Ian Alan Paul
If you you think being of critical and suspicious of theological metanarratives is intellectually lazy, wait until you hear about faux-Marxist class reductionism! In all seriousness, for those of you looking for actually useful analyses of the complex relations between identity, class, and emanci

Re: Identity and difference

2018-10-27 Thread Alexander Bard
Dear Joseph While you resentfully remain obsessed with my tonality and my etiquette (as if this was some smelling salt-driven cocktail party at a ship doomed to sink) I do prefer to stay with the topic I brought up. Forget about me. Ans forget about Joseph's preoccupation with my style and whateve

Re: Identity and difference

2018-10-27 Thread Joseph Rabie
Alexander addresses me with an injunction and second-guesses my answer: "What is your tactic? Further excuses for not dealing with the crisis of the left?" My answer is that I do not have the slightest idea, and that anyone who claims to have one is either a liar, fool, or utopian dictator. And