Re: The War to come ...

2022-03-10 Thread Michael Goldhaber
An interesting discussion, but I’d like to come at it from another angle. My father was born in Lviv—then known as Lemberg, Galicia, Austro-Hungary, pre-WWI–and one of my new granddaughter’s other grandparents was born in the same city —then Lvov, Ukraine SSR. In between it was Lwów, Poland.

Re: The War to come ...

2022-03-10 Thread Brian Holmes
Thanks for your response Prem. I am glad to hear an outside perspective in the first person. We are entering a geopolitical age where new borders and spheres of influence will be set up whether one likes it or not. When war becomes a whole-of-society effort, as it is now, the consequence can only

Is Russia losing in Ukraine? Indian army generals respond (Times of India video)

2022-03-10 Thread patrice riemens
नमस्ते , "When India speaks, the world listens" -Jawaharlal Nehru https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mwj3WtrQZaw (20m46s) (with thanks to Harv S) सत्यमेव जयते ! p+7D!# distributed via : no commercial use without permission #is a moderated mailing list for net criticism, # collaborative

Re: The War to come ...

2022-03-10 Thread Ted Byfield
Felix gets it, imo. Not sure about elsewhere, but the 'special relationship left' — the US certainly and the UK as well, I think — has been stuck in a rut. OT1H hard-ish doctrinaire 'anti-imperialist' formations robotically denounce NATO in the monolithic, one-sided terms Felix points out;

Re: The War to come ...

2022-03-10 Thread Prem Chandavarkar
Hi Brian, Good to hear from you and to be in an exchange of thoughts with you once again. My thoughts: Let me start with your question on NATO’s eastward expansion. Yes - on principle, one cannot deny the freedom of the Eastern European states to choose their alliances. But the consequences

Re: The War to come ...

2022-03-10 Thread Felix Stalder
On 10.03.22 06:02, Brian Holmes wrote: Here's the thing though. Should Nato really have denied entry to all those Eastern European states that requested it? Remember that most of those states, they had been taken over but not absorbed by the Soviet Union. They lived for decades under