Re: nettime The Coming War on General Computation

2012-01-03 Thread Newmedia

Joshua:
 
I was wondering if there is also a transcription of the QA -- since,
as is often the case, that's where the rhetorical nuance of the
presentation tends to be expressed.
 
I believe it was there that Doctorow emphasized the *analogies* of the WAR  
ON DRUGS as well as the one-time practice of WITCH HUNTING to his War on  
General Computing.
 
Analogies are extremely powerful devices when you are speaking to a CROWD  
and, analogizing as he did, this seemed to me to be at the heart of 
Doctorow's  moral argument.
 
Mark Stahlman
Brooklyn NY
 
-

In a message dated 1/3/2012 7:28:09 A.M. Eastern Standard Time,  
nett...@kein.org writes:

The Coming War on General Computation Cory Doctorow
docto...@craphound.com Presented at 28C3

https://github.com/jwise/28c3-doctorow/blob/master/transcript.md

Transcribed  by Joshua Wise jos...@joshuawise.com.

This transcription attempts to be  faithful to the original, but 
disfluencies have generally been removed  (except where they appear to 
contribute to the text). Some words may have  been mangled by the 
transcription; feel free to submit pull requests to  correct them!
 





#  distributed via nettime: no commercial use without permission
#  nettime  is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
#  collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
#  more info: http://mx.kein.org/mailman/listinfo/nettime-l
#  archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nett...@kein.org


nettime How I accidentally became a blogger and blogged the #28c3

2012-01-03 Thread Dmytri Kleiner


Well, #28c3 has come and gone.

I’m not sure how it happened, but after all these years on the 
internet, It looks like I’ve somehow become a blogger.


I never really wanted to be a blogger, after all the most exciting 
thing about the Internet has always been the ability for users to 
interact on neutral turf. Yet, the web, even when it has social 
features, is always home-court for somebody or another.


The definitive technology of the Internet to me was always UseNet, a 
worldwide distributed discussion system, and this was where I first 
began to express and discuss political issues, where the worlds of 
political activism and media art intersected with my life as a computer 
programmer, and drew me into ideas and projects and communities I would 
otherwise have had no connection with.


I didn’t start out thinking about what I was doing as “publishing” so 
much as fishing, posting not so much so people would read my texts, but 
so people would respond to them. Their responses give me new ideas, 
insights, and more leads to better understand these topics I could now 
begin to access, byway of the Internet.


UseNet was an ongoing multiparty dialogue.

When people started blogging I couldn’t see the point. Why post 
something on just one website, instead of millions of news servers all 
around the world? Why force people to use dodgy webforms to leave 
comments, instead of slick news reading software? It seems so 
retrograde, so hierarchical, privileging one writer as the blog’s 
“author” with everyone else reduced to “commentators,” under the 
tyrannical moderation of the blogger, meaning that the presence of 
opposing views, that made UseNet groups so vibrant, was absent.


A personal website seemed to me no more useful than as an elaborate 
.plan file, a kind of online brochure, good for a CV and Contact info, 
maybe even a archive of what you had really posted online (meaning on 
UseNet), but certainly no way to reach any community.


Sadly, UseNet has become increasingly obscure, for reasons that I have 
discussed at length, as part of the Capital-financed enclosure of the 
peer-to-peer Internet with centrally controlled client-server 
technologies.


As a result for years I’ve been lost in wilderness, making my 
contributions on web-boards like Autonomedia’s InterActivist, mailing 
lists, etc, and even *gasp* “Social Media,” Eventually being published 
by Mute Magazine, and other websites, leading to the Telekommunist 
Manifesto being released by the Institute for Network Cultures.


In an effort to co-ordinate my use of these disparate platforms, 
somehow a blog emerged.

So here we are. I’ve accidentally become a blogger.

Last week the #28c3 occurred in Berlin, and it served as the point of 
departure for the last  six texts that I’ve written. For completeness, 
I’ve collected links to all of them below.


- Nobody Goes There Anymore, It’s Too Crowded! | http://wp.me/p24fq

When a place becomes too crowded, things like getting in, getting a 
table, getting service, etc, become more competitive and thereby 
difficult. Some of the original regulars become crowded out and stop 
going, eventually the others stop too, “because nobody goes there 
anymore.”


- The Suck Principle | http://wp.me/p24fqL-qo

Only places that suck can really have a continuous community, because 
if nothing about the place sucks, it will attract more and more people 
until it sucks because of crowding. So if you want a continuous, closely 
knit community, something about the venue or event must suck, your only 
choice is what should suck or how it should suck.


- Exceptionalism and The Internet Surveillance Industry | 
http://wp.me/p24fqL-r1


Expressing outrage that enemies of the US and it’s allies are using the 
technology being developed by the west also seems misplaced, and rests 
on regressive exceptionalist view that privileges western states as 
being somehow noble enough to be trusted with the ability to survey 
their citizens, but  not sinister foreign powers.


- Capital and The War on General Computing | http://wp.me/p24fqL-rg

It is not ignorance, nor even genuinely the needs of law enforcement 
that is driving the war against general computing and a general network. 
It’s too simple to understand this war as simply tyrannical law 
enforcers and paranoid music execs duping clueless legislatures into 
locking-down cyberspace to save Lady Gaga and Katy Perry. Rather this 
war is simply a consequence of the fact that our technology industry is 
funded by finance capital, and finance capital requires profit as a 
return.


- There Is No A List | http://wp.me/p24fqL-rC

Certainly the freedom-loving free markets will punish peddlers of 
tyranny and domination! No doubt ethically minded investors will move 
their investments to the virtuous firms of list A, leaving the B listers 
starved of Capital. Justice conscious consumers will immediately dump 
B’s products and take up the A list! Politicians, eager to