Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
Am 16.06.22 um 13:09 schrieb Denis Maier via ntg-context: Hmmm, I probably was to quick. Does not really work in my real document... I'll try to solve the issue now by integrating the notes into the caption. Let's see if the authors accept it. Anyway, maybe that would be a nice topic for the monthly context chat? I agree – local, floating or postponed footnotes are an interesting topic. In MkIV we needed \automigrateinserts, but that’s unnecessary and a noop in LMTX. In my book still footnotes (esp. in table floats) go missing, and I need to find a MWE. In your example, I get repeated footnotes in a strange order after the postponed notes. Next online meetup is on July 13th. but maybe we can resolve everything before that date ;) Hraban ___ If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the Wiki! maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://context.aanhet.net archive : https://bitbucket.org/phg/context-mirror/commits/ wiki : http://contextgarden.net ___
Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
Hmmm, I probably was to quick. Does not really work in my real document...
I'll try to solve the issue now by integrating the notes into the caption.
Let's see if the authors accept it.
Anyway, maybe that would be a nice topic for the monthly context chat?
> -Ursprüngliche Nachricht-
> Von: ntg-context Im Auftrag von Denis Maier
> via ntg-context
> Gesendet: Donnerstag, 16. Juni 2022 11:16
> An: mse...@telus.net; ntg-context@ntg.nl
> Cc: Maier, Denis Christian (UB)
> Betreff: Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
>
> Thanks, Max! That's very neat, and it indeed works in my use case.
>
> Can anyone see any drawbacks here?
>
> Best,
> Denis
>
> > -Ursprüngliche Nachricht-
> > Von: Max Chernoff
> > Gesendet: Donnerstag, 16. Juni 2022 01:32
> > An: ntg-context@ntg.nl
> > Cc: Maier, Denis Christian (UB)
> > Betreff: Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
> >
> > > What's the current state of affairs regarding footnotes in floats?
> > > Both
> > version in the example below don't quite work...
> > > (Ideally, the note should be on the page with the float and the
> > > caption, but the numbering should also be adjusted.)
> >
> > We can completely abuse a bunch of different ConTeXt features to
> > ensure that the footnote numbers are always in the page order.
> >
> > % New Code
> > \unprotect
> >
> > \startluacode
> > userdata.visual_order = 0
> > userdata.input_order = 0
> > userdata.save_data = job.passes.define("saved_footnotes")
> > userdata.previous_data =
> > job.passes.getcollected("saved_footnotes")
> >
> > interfaces.implement {
> > name = "set_footnote_number",
> > actions = function ()
> > userdata.input_order = userdata.input_order + 1
> >
> > local input_index = userdata.input_order
> > local page_index =
> > userdata.previous_data[input_index]
> >
> > if page_index then
> > structures.counters.set("footnote", 1, page_index - 1)
> > end
> > end
> > }
> > \stopluacode
> >
> > \def\save_footnote_data#1{%
> > \latelua{
> > userdata.visual_order = userdata.visual_order + 1
> > userdata.save_data[#1] = userdata.visual_order
> > }%
> > }
> >
> > \let\old_footnote=\footnote
> >
> > \starttexdefinition protected footnote #1
> > \begingroup
> > \clf_set_footnote_number
> >
> > \def\insert##1\bgroup##2\egroup{
> > \normalexpanded{
> > \noexpand\save_footnote_data
> > {\cldcontext{userdata.input_order}}
> > }
> > \normalinsert##1{##2}
> > }
> >
> > \old_footnote{#1}
> > \endgroup
> > \stoptexdefinition
> >
> > \protect
> >
> > % Original Example
> >
> > \starttext
> >
> > \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> >
> > \input ward
> >
> > \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
> > \externalfigure[cow.pdf]
> > \stopplacefigure
> >
> > \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> >
> > \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
> > \externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
> > \stopplacefigure
> >
> > \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> >
> >
> > \page
> > \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> >
> > \input ward
> >
> > \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
> > \externalfigure[cow.pdf]
> > \stopplacefigure
> >
> > \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> >
> > % (Can't use postponingnotes)
> > % \startpostponingnotes
> > \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
> > \externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
> > \stopplacefigure
> > % \stoppostponingnotes
> >
> > \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> > \stoptext
> >
> > Here, we save a mapping between each footnote's index in the input and
> > its index in the output to the .tu
Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
Thanks, Max! That's very neat, and it indeed works in my use case.
Can anyone see any drawbacks here?
Best,
Denis
> -Ursprüngliche Nachricht-
> Von: Max Chernoff
> Gesendet: Donnerstag, 16. Juni 2022 01:32
> An: ntg-context@ntg.nl
> Cc: Maier, Denis Christian (UB)
> Betreff: Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
>
> > What's the current state of affairs regarding footnotes in floats? Both
> version in the example below don't quite work...
> > (Ideally, the note should be on the page with the float and the
> > caption, but the numbering should also be adjusted.)
>
> We can completely abuse a bunch of different ConTeXt features to ensure
> that the footnote numbers are always in the page order.
>
> % New Code
> \unprotect
>
> \startluacode
> userdata.visual_order = 0
> userdata.input_order = 0
> userdata.save_data = job.passes.define("saved_footnotes")
> userdata.previous_data = job.passes.getcollected("saved_footnotes")
>
> interfaces.implement {
> name = "set_footnote_number",
> actions = function ()
> userdata.input_order = userdata.input_order + 1
>
> local input_index = userdata.input_order
> local page_index = userdata.previous_data[input_index]
>
> if page_index then
> structures.counters.set("footnote", 1, page_index - 1)
> end
> end
> }
> \stopluacode
>
> \def\save_footnote_data#1{%
> \latelua{
> userdata.visual_order = userdata.visual_order + 1
> userdata.save_data[#1] = userdata.visual_order
> }%
> }
>
> \let\old_footnote=\footnote
>
> \starttexdefinition protected footnote #1
> \begingroup
> \clf_set_footnote_number
>
> \def\insert##1\bgroup##2\egroup{
> \normalexpanded{
> \noexpand\save_footnote_data
> {\cldcontext{userdata.input_order}}
> }
> \normalinsert##1{##2}
> }
>
> \old_footnote{#1}
> \endgroup
> \stoptexdefinition
>
> \protect
>
> % Original Example
>
> \starttext
>
> \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
>
> \input ward
>
> \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
> \externalfigure[cow.pdf]
> \stopplacefigure
>
> \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
>
> \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
> \externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
> \stopplacefigure
>
> \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
>
>
> \page
> \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
>
> \input ward
>
> \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
> \externalfigure[cow.pdf]
> \stopplacefigure
>
> \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
>
> % (Can't use postponingnotes)
> % \startpostponingnotes
> \startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
> \externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
> \stopplacefigure
> % \stoppostponingnotes
>
> \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
> \stoptext
>
> Here, we save a mapping between each footnote's index in the input and its
> index in the output to the .tuc file. The code is definitely not pretty, but
> works well enough for the sample file provided.
>
> -- Max
___
If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the
Wiki!
maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context
webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://context.aanhet.net
archive : https://bitbucket.org/phg/context-mirror/commits/
wiki : http://contextgarden.net
___
Re: [NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
What's the current state of affairs regarding footnotes in floats? Both version
in the example below don't quite work...
(Ideally, the note should be on the page with the float and the caption, but
the numbering should also be adjusted.)
We can completely abuse a bunch of different ConTeXt features to ensure
that the footnote numbers are always in the page order.
% New Code
\unprotect
\startluacode
userdata.visual_order = 0
userdata.input_order = 0
userdata.save_data = job.passes.define("saved_footnotes")
userdata.previous_data = job.passes.getcollected("saved_footnotes")
interfaces.implement {
name = "set_footnote_number",
actions = function ()
userdata.input_order = userdata.input_order + 1
local input_index = userdata.input_order
local page_index = userdata.previous_data[input_index]
if page_index then
structures.counters.set("footnote", 1, page_index - 1)
end
end
}
\stopluacode
\def\save_footnote_data#1{%
\latelua{
userdata.visual_order = userdata.visual_order + 1
userdata.save_data[#1] = userdata.visual_order
}%
}
\let\old_footnote=\footnote
\starttexdefinition protected footnote #1
\begingroup
\clf_set_footnote_number
\def\insert##1\bgroup##2\egroup{
\normalexpanded{
\noexpand\save_footnote_data
{\cldcontext{userdata.input_order}}
}
\normalinsert##1{##2}
}
\old_footnote{#1}
\endgroup
\stoptexdefinition
\protect
% Original Example
\starttext
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\input ward
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf]
\stopplacefigure
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
\stopplacefigure
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\page
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\input ward
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf]
\stopplacefigure
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
% (Can't use postponingnotes)
% \startpostponingnotes
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
\stopplacefigure
% \stoppostponingnotes
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\stoptext
Here, we save a mapping between each footnote's index in the input and
its index in the output to the .tuc file. The code is definitely not
pretty, but works well enough for the sample file provided.
-- Max
___
If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the
Wiki!
maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context
webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://context.aanhet.net
archive : https://bitbucket.org/phg/context-mirror/commits/
wiki : http://contextgarden.net
___
[NTG-context] Foonotes in Captions ... again
Hi everyone
What's the current state of affairs regarding footnotes in floats? Both version
in the example below don't quite work...
(Ideally, the note should be on the page with the float and the caption, but
the numbering should also be adjusted.)
Best,
Denis
\starttext
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\input ward
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf]
\stopplacefigure
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
\stopplacefigure
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\page
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\input ward
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 1}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf]
\stopplacefigure
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\startpostponingnotes
\startplacefigure[title={asdfasdf\footnote{test 2}}]
\externalfigure[cow.pdf][height=10cm]
\stopplacefigure
\stoppostponingnotes
\footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf} \footnote{asdf}
\stoptext
___
If your question is of interest to others as well, please add an entry to the
Wiki!
maillist : ntg-context@ntg.nl / http://www.ntg.nl/mailman/listinfo/ntg-context
webpage : http://www.pragma-ade.nl / http://context.aanhet.net
archive : https://bitbucket.org/phg/context-mirror/commits/
wiki : http://contextgarden.net
___
