Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-24 Thread Kevin Grignon
KG01 - see comments inline. On Jul 21, 2012, at 12:07 PM, Shenfeng Liu liush...@gmail.com wrote: Kevin, Good suggestion! Maybe we can use the Priority field together with the Target Miletone field. e.g. For an item we propose to 3.5, we set Target Milestone to AOO 3.5, then setup

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-24 Thread Xue Fei Duan
Simon, I have several questions: 1) we should define feature development and defects fixed plan in one iteration, right? it can help developer and tester finish their task in one iteration. if we need have iteration development plan review? 2)if QE reports severity 1 2 defects, if they all must be

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-24 Thread Shenfeng Liu
Kevin, Please see my comments below. Thanks! - Simon 2012/7/25 Kevin Grignon kevingrignon...@gmail.com KG01 - see comments inline. On Jul 21, 2012, at 12:07 PM, Shenfeng Liu liush...@gmail.com wrote: Kevin, Good suggestion! Maybe we can use the Priority field together with the

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-24 Thread Shenfeng Liu
Xue Fei, Ideally, I want to answer yes to your question 1 2, and define the Target Milestone to not only 3.5.0, but also to the level of 3.5.0M1, 3.5.0M2... And ask people to input their plan. However I'm not sure if it will be too strict for volunteers to do the contribution. Another way can

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-20 Thread Lei Wang
I add some items for Calc application for 3.5 plan in 3.5 Release Planning wiki https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OOOUSERS/AOO+3.5+Release+Planning If there are anything which must be in 3.5 for Calc, please discuss it here or put it in the list in the planning wiki. On Fri, Jul 20,

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-20 Thread Shenfeng Liu
Wang Lei, The proposed items look very good! And you can create issues and setting Issue Type as ENHANCEMENT or FEATURE in BZ if they did not exist, then fill the Task-ID in wiki. Thanks very much for your input! - Simon 2012/7/20 Lei Wang l...@apache.org I add some items for Calc

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-20 Thread Kevin Grignon
KG01 - See comments inline. On Jul 20, 2012, at 4:59 PM, Shenfeng Liu liush...@gmail.com wrote: Wang Lei, The proposed items look very good! And you can create issues and setting Issue Type as ENHANCEMENT or FEATURE in BZ if they did not exist, then fill the Task-ID in wiki. Thanks very

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-20 Thread Shenfeng Liu
Kevin, Good suggestion! Maybe we can use the Priority field together with the Target Miletone field. e.g. For an item we propose to 3.5, we set Target Milestone to AOO 3.5, then setup Priority to: P1 for must have, P2 for should have, P3 for better to have... ? - Simon 2012/7/20 Kevin

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-19 Thread Shenfeng Liu
Juergen, Thanks for your comments! My thoughts below... And I updated the 3.5 Release Planning wikihttps://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OOOUSERS/AOO+3.5+Release+Planningwith a draft of the defect/feature rule. Could you and QE team review and give comments? Again, it is not only

[RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-18 Thread Shenfeng Liu
Hi, all, I made some update on the AOO 3.5 Release Planning wiki Juergen created: https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OOOUSERS/AOO+3.5+Release+Planning. And besides proposing contents in the High Level Overview table, I think we should also think about the release process. And below

Re: [RELEASE][3.5] Process thinking - defectfeature rules, iteration...

2012-07-18 Thread Jürgen Schmidt
On 7/18/12 9:02 AM, Shenfeng Liu wrote: Hi, all, I made some update on the AOO 3.5 Release Planning wiki Juergen created: https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OOOUSERS/AOO+3.5+Release+Planning. And besides proposing contents in the High Level Overview table, I think we should