Re: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-05-03 Thread Eddie O'Neil
I agree with the sentiment expressed -- OpenJPA has done a good job working together on a good code base with a growing, diverse group of contributors. I'm proud of the work that's been done here. These days, the Board is wary of umbrella projects and is more comfortable with pushing smaller

RE: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-04-27 Thread Patrick Linskey
In terms of graduation, if we go the top-level route, I'd like to propose Craig as the PMC chair. I think that he'd be a good fit since he's quite active in the OpenJPA community, and also has a good deal of knowledge about and experience within Apache. I think that he would do a great job of

Re: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-04-27 Thread Kevin Sutter
Patrick, On 4/27/07, Patrick Linskey [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In terms of graduation, if we go the top-level route, I'd like to propose Craig as the PMC chair. I second that vote, if you are not interested. Craig has gotten us out of Apache hot water a few times with his background on

RE: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-04-27 Thread Patrick Linskey
27, 2007 1:23 PM To: open-jpa-dev@incubator.apache.org Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation Patrick, On 4/27/07, Patrick Linskey [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: In terms of graduation, if we go the top-level route, I'd like to propose Craig as the PMC chair. I second that vote

Re: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-04-23 Thread Marc Prud'hommeaux
I'm personally rather neutral on whether OpenJPA should be a TLP vs. a sub-project. TLP seems like it allows us more flexibility and independence, so by default I would lean towards being a TLP. However, I do notice that the DB TLP already holds other similar projects (Torque, OJB, and

Re: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-04-23 Thread Craig L Russell
On Apr 23, 2007, at 2:58 PM, Marc Prud'hommeaux wrote: I'm personally rather neutral on whether OpenJPA should be a TLP vs. a sub-project. TLP seems like it allows us more flexibility and independence, so by default I would lean towards being a TLP. That's my main concern as well.

RE: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation

2007-04-23 Thread Patrick Linskey
] Sent: Monday, April 23, 2007 4:35 PM To: open-jpa-dev@incubator.apache.org Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] OpenJPA Graduation On Apr 23, 2007, at 2:58 PM, Marc Prud'hommeaux wrote: I'm personally rather neutral on whether OpenJPA should be a TLP vs. a sub-project. TLP seems like it allows