RFC CR-000024 - Revert meaning to String - ARB deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Vincent McCauley
Hi Thomas, 1. I think node_id rather than meaning for the name of this data would be clearer. 2. A compromise suggestion to address Dipak's issue (which I think is important) as well as reduce XML bloat: Change the datatype to just a string but introduce a new section at the start of the XML

RFC CR-000024 - Revert meaning to String - ARB deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Thomas Beale
Vincent McCauley wrote: Hi Thomas, 1. I think node_id rather than meaning for the name of this data would be clearer. I suspect we will make this change - most people prefer it 2. A compromise suggestion to address Dipak's issue (which I think is important) as well as reduce XML bloat:

RFC CR-000024 - Revert meaning to String - ARB deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Thomas Beale
Dear all, due to changes in the openEHR website repositories area, the URLs I gave out previous should be replaced by the following ones: Text of the CR-00024: http://www.openehr.org/repositories/spec-0.9_D/latest/publishing/CM/CRs/CR-24.txt Common Model:

RFC CR-000101 - request for comments - deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Christian Heller
The CR to be considered in this post is CR-000101- Improve Modelling of Structure classes. See http://www.openehr.org/repositories/spec/latest/publishing/CM/CRs/CR-00010 1.txt . This CR proposes a change to the Data structure classes which makes for more efficient data representation. The

RFC CR-000024 - Revert meaning to String - ARB deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Thomas Beale
Christian Heller wrote: 1. I think node_id rather than meaning for the name of this data would be clearer. I suspect we will make this change - most people prefer it I propose to delete all name, meaning, id or similar fields from all archetypes. The only way an archetype should be

RFC CR-000101 - request for comments - deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Karsten Hilbert
- every concept, everything in existence (as the human mind perceives it) is hierarchical, to microcosm as well as towards macrocosm Including the brain itself ? Karsten -- GPG key ID E4071346 @ wwwkeys.pgp.net E167 67FD A291 2BEA 73BD 4537 78B9 A9F9 E407 1346 - If you have any questions

RFC CR-000024 - Revert meaning to String - ARB deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Christian Heller
Christian, you may have misunderstood - the 'meaning' fields in an archetype are the node-level ids - which also double as codes, whose meaning is given in the lower part of the archetype. See for example http://www.openehr.org/repositories/archetype/latest/adl/archetypes/openehr

RFC CR-000101 - request for comments - deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Christian Heller
- every concept, everything in existence (as the human mind perceives it) is hierarchical, to microcosm as well as towards macrocosm Including the brain itself ? Yes, because in our concept of a brain it consists of regions, neuron cells, organelles, molecules etc. You have to distinguish

RFC CR-000101 - request for comments - deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Karsten Hilbert
physical brain == carrier of knowledge == neurons, synapses etc. == real world But they are not interconnected in a hierarchy only, to the best of my knowledge. The mind knows about itself and its physical carrier, the brain. But the functioning of the brain has nothing to do with the abstract

RFC CR-000024 - Revert meaning to String - ARB deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Nathan Lea
Please note that due to engineering works, the OpenEHR server will have to be shutdown today until tomorrow morning (approx 9am). With best wishes, Nathan -- Nathan C. Lea Research Fellow

RFC CR-000101 - request for comments - deadline 23 july 2004

2004-07-12 Thread Christian Heller
physical brain == carrier of knowledge == neurons, synapses etc. == real world But they are not interconnected in a hierarchy only, to the best of my knowledge. I did not say that. I was talking about concepts (mind) only. The mind knows about itself and its physical carrier, the brain.