Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-27 Thread Lee Cardona
I defer to Timo, but which distro of Linux are you using? I run everything on Ubuntu v12 LTS, if you're using Alpine distro I'm not familiar as much. Sent from my iPhone > On May 27, 2014, at 3:29 AM, masoom alam wrote: > > Any clue: > > CC nhrp/admin.o > CC nhrp/libev.o > nhr

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-27 Thread masoom alam
Any clue: CC nhrp/admin.o CC nhrp/libev.o nhrp/libev.c: In function ‘evpipe_write’: nhrp/../libev/ev.c:1236:17: warning: ignoring return value of ‘write’, declared with attribute warn_unused_result [-Wunused-result] nhrp/../libev/ev.c:1240:15: warning: ignoring return value of ‘write’

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-26 Thread masoom alam
HI Every one, Do we really need the two interfaces mentioned in the /etc/network/interfaces auto bond0.256 iface bond0.256 inet static address <%ISP1_IP_ADDRESS%> netmask <%ISP1_NETMASK%> auto bond0.257 iface bond0.257 inet static address <%ISP2_IP_ADDRESS%> netmask <%ISP2_NETMASK%> (cf. http

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-18 Thread masoom alam
Thanks Timo and Lee for the detailed answers. On Mon, May 19, 2014 at 10:17 AM, Timo Teras wrote: > On Sun, 18 May 2014 07:25:22 +0500 > masoom alam wrote: > > > Thanks for the answer. > > > > What are the strong points for StrongSWAN for you to select it as a > > replacement for ipsec-tools

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-18 Thread Timo Teras
On Sun, 18 May 2014 07:25:22 +0500 masoom alam wrote: > Thanks for the answer. > > What are the strong points for StrongSWAN for you to select it as a > replacement for ipsec-tools? And what are the issues that you dont > like. strongSwan seems to have evolved one of the most comprehensive open

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-18 Thread Lee Cardona
Masoom, ipsec with NAT is handled via NAT-T specification. Your question really is more fundamental to general how IPSec works as oppose to openNHRP which is the focus of this list. My suggestion would be to practice setting up basic point-to-point IPSec over NAT first and get that working. O

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-18 Thread Alin Gruiescu
AH is not offering encryption. I never saw it in use. For me is not clear. Who is doing nat? As I said in a previous mail if the VPN endpoint is behind nat the only thing you have to forward to it is udp 500 and 4500. - Sincerely / Cu stimă, Alin Gruiescu Tel: +40 7711 03172 On Sun, May 18,

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-18 Thread masoom alam
An illustrative guide to ipsec ( http://www.unixwiz.net/techtips/iguide-ipsec.html) read as: AH and NAT — Not Gonna Happen Though AH provides very strong protection of a packet's contents because it covers *everything* that can be possibly considered immutable, this protection comes at a cost: AH

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-17 Thread masoom alam
Thanks for the answer. What are the strong points for StrongSWAN for you to select it as a replacement for ipsec-tools? And what are the issues that you dont like. On Sat, May 17, 2014 at 1:20 PM, Timo Teräs wrote: > On Sat May 17 2014 04:25:49 AM EEST, masoom alam > wrote: > > > Another th

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-17 Thread Timo Teräs
On Sat May 17 2014 04:25:49 AM EEST, masoom alam wrote: > Another thing that I am looking in to is that what are the pros n cons of > using ipsec-tools with opennhrp than the strongswan. I am aware that > there was some work going on on the API level integration of both > projects. But why we can

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-16 Thread masoom alam
Thanks a lot lee. Another thing that I am looking in to is that what are the pros n cons of using ipsec-tools with opennhrp than the strongswan. I am aware that there was some work going on on the API level integration of both projects. But why we can't use them independently on a single system be

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-16 Thread Lee Cardona
Masoom, Ok so for your first question on getting it to work on ubuntu. I did a make install from source » Here’s what you need to do: STEP 1 wget http://downloads.sourceforge.net/project/opennhrp/opennhrp/opennhrp-.tar.bz2 STEP 2 tar -xjvf opennhrp-.tar.bz2 STEP 3 cd opennhrp-/ STEP 4 make ST

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-16 Thread Alin Gruiescu
Hello, Forward internally udp 500 and 4500. ISAKMP and ISAKMP over NAT. Done that and is working just fine. I have the HUB behind NAT. - Sincerely / Cu stimă, Alin Gruiescu Tel: +40 7711 03172 On Fri, May 16, 2014 at 3:55 PM, Lee Cardona wrote: > Hi Masoom, yes you can do that,.. I need

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-16 Thread Lee Cardona
Hi Masoom, yes you can do that,.. I need to look at my setup ― been awhile since I did it but what you layout is 100% possible. The external firewall you speak of just needs to allow IPSec traffic. Let me dig up my setup and I'll provide some additional details shortly. Sent from my iPhone

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-15 Thread masoom alam
Can do do the following: OpenNHRP on ubuntu + Ipsec-tools for Ipsec + Iptables for handling Natting if our Ubuntu machine is behind the firewall? All of this is to enable OpenNHRP on a linux machine with Ipsec but it is behind the firewall Please guide. On Thu, May 15, 2014 at 7:49 AM, Lee C

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-14 Thread Lee Cardona
Yes, for example it runs great on Ubuntu. Sent from my iPhone > On May 14, 2014, at 9:15 PM, masoom alam wrote: > > Does OpenNHRP is really for Alpine linux? I mean will it work on any other > distribution? > > Thanks > > >> On Wed, May 14, 2014 at 5:39 PM, Timo Teras wrote: >> On Wed, 1

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-14 Thread masoom alam
Does OpenNHRP is really for Alpine linux? I mean will it work on any other distribution? Thanks On Wed, May 14, 2014 at 5:39 PM, Timo Teras wrote: > On Wed, 14 May 2014 16:37:11 +0500 > masoom alam wrote: > > > Hi every one, > > > > I am new bie trying to install OpenNHRP between two VMs on m

Re: [opennhrp-devel] A stupid question about OpenNHRP

2014-05-14 Thread Timo Teras
On Wed, 14 May 2014 16:37:11 +0500 masoom alam wrote: > Hi every one, > > I am new bie trying to install OpenNHRP between two VMs on my laptop. > I am trying to follow > http://wiki.alpinelinux.org/wiki/Dynamic_Multipoint_VPN_%28DMVPN%29 > > However, the VLAN capable switch really confuses me.