[tickets] [opensaf:tickets] #2088 CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node
- **status**: review --> fixed --- ** [tickets:#2088] CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node** **Status:** fixed **Milestone:** future **Created:** Mon Oct 03, 2016 07:34 AM UTC by Srikanth R **Last Updated:** Fri Sep 01, 2017 07:01 AM UTC **Owner:** Ravi Sekhar Reddy Changeset : 7997 5.1.FC The saClmClusterNodeGetAsync api returns SA_AIS_OK on a non member node. The expected behavior is saClmClusterNodeGetAsync, should return ERR_AVAILABLE like the api saClmClusterNodeGet_4. Currently the saClmClusterNodeGet_4 api returns ERR_AVAILABLE on a nonmember node. Below is the snippet from CLM agent trace. Oct 3 12:40:34.532320 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1235] >> saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532330 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1278] >> clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.532338 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532345 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532363 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1227] >> clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.532383 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.532392 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.532399 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532406 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0192] >> clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532412 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0207] << clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532418 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533347 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0697] >> clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533377 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0729] T2 CLMSV_CLMA_API_RESP_MSG rc = 31 Oct 3 12:40:34.533388 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0809] << clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533448 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1253] << clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533474 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0656] >> clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533486 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0694] << clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533496 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1395] << clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.533502 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1245] << saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.533657 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1422] >> saClmClusterNodeGetAsync Oct 3 12:40:34.533668 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533674 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533681 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1274] >> clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533692 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533700 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.533707 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 5 Oct 3 12:40:34.533713 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0229] >> clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533720 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0245] << clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533726 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533744 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1296] << clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533753 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1497] << saClmClusterNodeGetAsync --- Sent from sourceforge.net because opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net is subscribed to https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/tickets/ To unsubscribe from further messages, a project admin can change settings at https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/admin/tickets/options. Or, if this is a mailing list, you can unsubscribe from the mailing list.-- Check out the vibrant tech community on one of the world's most engaging tech sites, Slashdot.org! http://sdm.link/slashdot___ Opensaf-tickets mailing list Opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/opensaf-tickets
[tickets] [opensaf:tickets] #2088 CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node
- **status**: assigned --> review - **Comment**: We are not observing this issue now Here is the test I performed On two node systems Locked the CLM Node SC-2 and then invoked the async API returns ERR_UNAVAILABLE I think the issue can be closed root@SC-2:~# clmprint -a 0x2020f node_id:131599(2020f) ===CLM NODE GET CALLBACK STARTS== Error: SA_AIS_ERR_UNAVAILABLE (31) Invocation: 0 error - InvocationId wrong,expected: , received: 0 ===CLM NODE GET CALLBACK ENDS== --- ** [tickets:#2088] CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node** **Status:** review **Milestone:** future **Created:** Mon Oct 03, 2016 07:34 AM UTC by Srikanth R **Last Updated:** Wed Aug 30, 2017 09:25 AM UTC **Owner:** Ravi Sekhar Reddy Changeset : 7997 5.1.FC The saClmClusterNodeGetAsync api returns SA_AIS_OK on a non member node. The expected behavior is saClmClusterNodeGetAsync, should return ERR_AVAILABLE like the api saClmClusterNodeGet_4. Currently the saClmClusterNodeGet_4 api returns ERR_AVAILABLE on a nonmember node. Below is the snippet from CLM agent trace. Oct 3 12:40:34.532320 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1235] >> saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532330 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1278] >> clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.532338 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532345 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532363 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1227] >> clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.532383 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.532392 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.532399 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532406 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0192] >> clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532412 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0207] << clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532418 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533347 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0697] >> clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533377 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0729] T2 CLMSV_CLMA_API_RESP_MSG rc = 31 Oct 3 12:40:34.533388 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0809] << clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533448 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1253] << clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533474 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0656] >> clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533486 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0694] << clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533496 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1395] << clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.533502 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1245] << saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.533657 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1422] >> saClmClusterNodeGetAsync Oct 3 12:40:34.533668 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533674 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533681 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1274] >> clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533692 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533700 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.533707 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 5 Oct 3 12:40:34.533713 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0229] >> clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533720 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0245] << clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533726 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533744 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1296] << clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533753 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1497] << saClmClusterNodeGetAsync --- Sent from sourceforge.net because opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net is subscribed to https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/tickets/ To unsubscribe from further messages, a project admin can change settings at https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/admin/tickets/options. Or, if this is a mailing list, you can unsubscribe from the mailing list.-- Check out the vibrant tech community on one of the world's most engaging tech sites, Slashdot.org! http://sdm.link/slashdot___ Opensaf-tickets mailing list Opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/opensaf-tickets
[tickets] [opensaf:tickets] #2088 CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node
- **status**: unassigned --> assigned - **assigned_to**: Ravi Sekhar Reddy - **Blocker**: --> False --- ** [tickets:#2088] CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node** **Status:** assigned **Milestone:** future **Created:** Mon Oct 03, 2016 07:34 AM UTC by Srikanth R **Last Updated:** Mon Oct 03, 2016 07:34 AM UTC **Owner:** Ravi Sekhar Reddy Changeset : 7997 5.1.FC The saClmClusterNodeGetAsync api returns SA_AIS_OK on a non member node. The expected behavior is saClmClusterNodeGetAsync, should return ERR_AVAILABLE like the api saClmClusterNodeGet_4. Currently the saClmClusterNodeGet_4 api returns ERR_AVAILABLE on a nonmember node. Below is the snippet from CLM agent trace. Oct 3 12:40:34.532320 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1235] >> saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532330 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1278] >> clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.532338 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532345 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532363 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1227] >> clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.532383 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.532392 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.532399 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532406 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0192] >> clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532412 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0207] << clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532418 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533347 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0697] >> clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533377 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0729] T2 CLMSV_CLMA_API_RESP_MSG rc = 31 Oct 3 12:40:34.533388 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0809] << clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533448 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1253] << clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533474 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0656] >> clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533486 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0694] << clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533496 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1395] << clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.533502 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1245] << saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.533657 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1422] >> saClmClusterNodeGetAsync Oct 3 12:40:34.533668 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533674 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533681 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1274] >> clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533692 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533700 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.533707 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 5 Oct 3 12:40:34.533713 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0229] >> clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533720 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0245] << clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533726 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533744 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1296] << clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533753 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1497] << saClmClusterNodeGetAsync --- Sent from sourceforge.net because opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net is subscribed to https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/tickets/ To unsubscribe from further messages, a project admin can change settings at https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/admin/tickets/options. Or, if this is a mailing list, you can unsubscribe from the mailing list.-- Check out the vibrant tech community on one of the world's most engaging tech sites, Slashdot.org! http://sdm.link/slashdot___ Opensaf-tickets mailing list Opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/opensaf-tickets
[tickets] [opensaf:tickets] #2088 CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node
--- ** [tickets:#2088] CLM : saClmClusterNodeGetAsync returns OK on a non member node** **Status:** unassigned **Milestone:** 4.7.2 **Created:** Mon Oct 03, 2016 07:34 AM UTC by Srikanth R **Last Updated:** Mon Oct 03, 2016 07:34 AM UTC **Owner:** nobody Changeset : 7997 5.1.FC The saClmClusterNodeGetAsync api returns SA_AIS_OK on a non member node. The expected behavior is saClmClusterNodeGetAsync, should return ERR_AVAILABLE like the api saClmClusterNodeGet_4. Currently the saClmClusterNodeGet_4 api returns ERR_AVAILABLE on a nonmember node. Below is the snippet from CLM agent trace. Oct 3 12:40:34.532320 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1235] >> saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532330 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1278] >> clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.532338 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532345 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.532363 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1227] >> clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.532383 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.532392 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.532399 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 4 Oct 3 12:40:34.532406 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0192] >> clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532412 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0207] << clma_enc_node_get_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.532418 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533347 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0697] >> clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533377 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0729] T2 CLMSV_CLMA_API_RESP_MSG rc = 31 Oct 3 12:40:34.533388 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0809] << clma_mds_dec Oct 3 12:40:34.533448 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1253] << clma_mds_msg_sync_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533474 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0656] >> clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533486 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0694] << clma_msg_destroy Oct 3 12:40:34.533496 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1395] << clmaclusternodeget Oct 3 12:40:34.533502 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1245] << saClmClusterNodeGet_4 Oct 3 12:40:34.533657 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1422] >> saClmClusterNodeGetAsync Oct 3 12:40:34.533668 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0036] >> clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533674 clma [7881:clma_util.c:0042] << clma_validate_version Oct 3 12:40:34.533681 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1274] >> clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533692 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0317] >> clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533700 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0352] T2 msgtype: 0 Oct 3 12:40:34.533707 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0366] T2 api_info.type: 5 Oct 3 12:40:34.533713 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0229] >> clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533720 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0245] << clma_enc_node_get_async_msg Oct 3 12:40:34.533726 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:0407] << clma_mds_enc Oct 3 12:40:34.533744 clma [7881:clma_mds.c:1296] << clma_mds_msg_async_send Oct 3 12:40:34.533753 clma [7881:clma_api.c:1497] << saClmClusterNodeGetAsync --- Sent from sourceforge.net because opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net is subscribed to https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/tickets/ To unsubscribe from further messages, a project admin can change settings at https://sourceforge.net/p/opensaf/admin/tickets/options. Or, if this is a mailing list, you can unsubscribe from the mailing list.-- Check out the vibrant tech community on one of the world's most engaging tech sites, SlashDot.org! http://sdm.link/slashdot___ Opensaf-tickets mailing list Opensaf-tickets@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/opensaf-tickets
