[osol-discuss] could ZFS be used to replace FAT/FAT32 in removeable media

2009-03-27 Thread russell aspinwall
Hi, After purchasing a USB to IDE/SATA drive caddy to allow system backups, my attempt was to use a 120GB IDE drive that came out of an old PC. While changing the partition information with fdisk was straight forward, newfs'ing the disk was more of a problem as you had to enter the number of

Re: [osol-discuss] could ZFS be used to replace FAT/FAT32 in removeable media

2009-03-27 Thread Casper . Dik
As ZFS does not have the limits of FAT/FAT32 and is also open source, could it be proposed to the makers of digitial devices like camera, usb memory manufacturers, router manufacturers, etc as a way of eliminating the FAT licensing yoke. This of course would require drivers to be available for

Re: [osol-discuss] could ZFS be used to replace FAT/FAT32 in removeable media

2009-03-27 Thread Martin Bochnig
On Fri, Mar 27, 2009 at 12:19 PM, casper@sun.com wrote: As ZFS does not have the limits of FAT/FAT32 and is also open source, could it be proposed to the makers of digitial devices like camera, usb memory manufacturers, router manufacturers, etc as a way of eliminating the FAT licensing

Re: [osol-discuss] could ZFS be used to replace FAT/FAT32 in removeable media

2009-03-27 Thread 7willows
Hi Casper, Thanks for the reply. It would nice to have an Open Source file system format which could be used by these electronic devices which did not require FAT. casper@sun.com wrote: As ZFS does not have the limits of FAT/FAT32 and is also open source, could it be proposed to the

Re: [osol-discuss] could ZFS be used to replace FAT/FAT32 in removeable media

2009-03-27 Thread Paul Gress
casper@sun.com wrote: There are many reasons why this doesn't fly: - First of all you will need to build away to easily, automatically import and export removable ZFS pools - Installed base (windows, USB, cameras) - pcfs uses about 1/10 of the code needed for

Re: [osol-discuss] could ZFS be used to replace FAT/FAT32 in removeable media

2009-03-27 Thread Martin Bochnig
On Fri, Mar 27, 2009 at 4:31 PM, Paul Gress pgr...@optonline.net wrote: casper@sun.com wrote:  There are many reasons why this doesn't fly:    - First of all you will need to build away to easily, automatically      import and export removable ZFS pools    - Installed base (windows,