Proposed OMC vote to remove C source output from apps

2020-11-03 Thread Dr Paul Dale
Proposed vote text: Remove -C option from the dhparam, dsaparam, ecparam and x509 apps. This is a breaking change and requires OMC approval. The rationale is that it is easier to not support this using the EVP calls and there is some doubt that the options are used anymore. Pauli -- Dr

Proposed OMC vote: drop -crypt option from passwd app

2020-11-03 Thread Dr Paul Dale
Proposed vote text: Remove the -crypt option from the passwd app. The rationale behind this is that this is a very old, long broken algorithm and that supporting it is difficult using non-deprecated calls. This is a breaking change and requires OMC approval. Pauli -- Dr Paul Dale |

OTC VOTE: EVP_PKEY private/public key components

2020-11-03 Thread Matt Caswell
Background to the vote: The OTC meeting today discussed the problems raised by issue #12612. In summary the problem is that there has been a long standing, widespread and documented assumption that an EVP_PKEY with a private key will always also have the public key component. In spite of this it

OTC VOTE: DH Generation

2020-11-03 Thread Matt Caswell
Background to the vote: The OTC meeting today had an extensive discussion on the issues raised in PR #13228. The code in master uses FIPS186-4 for key and parameter generation by default. In 1.1.1 and before we used PKCS#3 generation. This causes a number of backwards compatibility breaks as