Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-19 Thread Eichberger, German
] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting So now that is two people on this thread that are treating moving lbaas v1 to incubator as an of course, duh kind of thing. I do not agree. Insofar as most of neutron advanced services is feeling the velocity and maturity pain, sure. But lbaas v2 has NO dependency

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-19 Thread Stefano Maffulli
Thanks for the summary Trevor. On 08/18/2014 01:25 PM, Trevor Vardeman wrote: 1) Discuss future of Octavia in light of Neutron-incubator project proposal. a) There are many problems with Neutron-Incubator as currently described Let's be specific, enumerate the problems and address them,

[openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Trevor Vardeman
Agenda items are numbered, and topics, as discussed, are described beneath in list format. 1) Discuss future of Octavia in light of Neutron-incubator project proposal. a) There are many problems with Neutron-Incubator as currently described b) The political happenings in Neutron leave

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Salvatore Orlando
Hi Trevor, thanks for sharing this minutes! I would like to cooperate a bit to this project's developments, possibly without ending up being just deadweight. To this aim I have some comments inline. Salvatore On 18 August 2014 22:25, Trevor Vardeman trevor.varde...@rackspace.com wrote:

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Brandon Logan
Hi Salvatore, It'd be great to get your contributions in this! If you could only bring your knowledge and experience with Neutron to the table that'd be very beneficial. Looking forward to it. Comments in-line On Mon, 2014-08-18 at 23:06 +0200, Salvatore Orlando wrote: Hi Trevor, thanks

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Doug Wiegley
a) Most members in favor of keeping the webex meetings for the time being Correction: most of the people that like to talk over each other in a large voice conference voiced their approval of voice. Those that prefer to wait for pauses to speak were unsurprisingly silent, or tried and failed to

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Doug Wiegley
I agree almost completely with Brandon¹s comments on the incubator. For Octavia, I think we need to not stress neutron vs incubator vs spin-out, and just focus on writing some load-balancing code. We¹ve spent far too much time in Juno working on processes, glue, and APIs, and precious little on

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Stephen Balukoff
I agree pretty strongly with Brandon's and Doug's comments as well. And I did want to clarify that I certainly don't hate the Neutron cores either. I feel like we (those working on Neutron LBaaS and the Cores) made commitments to each other both at the Atlanta summit and the mid-cycle hackathon,

Re: [openstack-dev] [Octavia] Minutes from 8/13/2014 meeting

2014-08-18 Thread Doug Wiegley
So now that is two people on this thread that are treating moving lbaas v1 to incubator as an “of course, duh” kind of thing. I do not agree. Insofar as most of neutron advanced services is feeling the velocity and maturity pain, sure. But lbaas v2 has NO dependency on v1, it’s “stable”, been