Re: Curious views on HCB

2014-05-15 Thread Bob W-PDML
Some of those comments appear to be reviews of the exhibition rather than of HCB's work. As far as critical and popular opinions of his work are concerned, most great artists under reappraisal and a dip in popularity after their death, so it shouldn't be a surprise if this happens to HCB. Part

Re: Curious views on HCB

2014-05-15 Thread Christine Aguila
I think I agree with you Mark about Frank's comments, and think the point, which I might agree with to a degree, is made a bit too sharply. Cheers, Christine Sent from my iPad > On May 15, 2014, at 5:32 PM, Mark Roberts wrote: > > Well first off, the critics quoted come off as exactly the ki

Re: Curious views on HCB

2014-05-15 Thread Christine Aguila
The point about curation is well taken, Ann. Interestingly, with respect to the music biz, Johnny Lovine, Beats owner, talks about the lack of curation in the digital music business--here's the video. http://www.thatericalper.com/2014/05/10/watch-beats-electronics-jimmy-iovine-talk-about-the-

Re: Curious views on HCB

2014-05-15 Thread Mark Roberts
Well first off, the critics quoted come off as exactly the kind of pretentious, self-important wankers who give art and artists a bad name. They're the visual equivalent of wine snobs ("flaccid!", "absurd!", "fruity, yet arrogant"). I understand Frank's criticism and agree to a limited extent, but

Re: Curious views on HCB

2014-05-15 Thread Ann Sanfedele
When you said you were not aware of Frank's position I thought of OUR Frank - who certainly is a fan of HCB as am I. I didn't know about Robert Frank's opinion either. I saw the exhibit at MOMA - my final opinion was that it was too inclusive - that is - there was too much of the work that he

Curious views on HCB

2014-05-15 Thread Christine Aguila
Hi Everyone: In the foreword to the 2013 edition of The Best American Travel Writing, Jason Wilson includes some curious quotes from reviews of the HCB retrospective exhibition at MOMA several years ago: "The show was deemed 'almost unenduringly majestic' by The New Yorker's Peter Schjeldshl,