Re: [PEIRCE-L] on the reality of objects

2016-06-12 Thread Jerry Rhee
Kirsti, Clark, Gary, list: Are the following questions the same? “Is God general?”, “What would God be?”, “What is God?”, “quid sit deus?” To ask if God is general is to ask what the idea or the form of God is. This is a Platonic question and “"Idea," nearer Plato

Re: [PEIRCE-L] on the reality of objects

2016-06-12 Thread kirstima
Clark, Thank you very much for your posts on this thread. Greatly appreciated! Also, Neglegted Argument has been my favorite piece since I started with CSP. The question of the reality of God has always seemed to me to be a critical question to pose in front of anything Peirce wrote. However