Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
List, Edwina: First, Edwina, I will not answer directly your question about allowances on this list. In my experiences here on this list, I fear for my freedom to continue to express my analysis of the ontology and epistemology of the chemical sciences. As for the connections between the

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Semiosis and Mathematical abduction

2021-08-16 Thread John F. Sowa
> John, List: > > You write: >> In any case, this is just one of many cases where it's essential to >> distinguish (a) mathematics as the infinite totality of all patterns >> and teories about them, (b) the people who discover mathematical >> theories, and (c) the application of mathematics

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Semiosis and Mathematical abduction

2021-08-16 Thread Jerry LR Chandler
John, List: You write: > In any case, this is just one of many cases where it's essential to > distinguish (a) mathematics as the infinite totality of all patterns > and teories about them, (b) the people who discover mathematical > theories, and (c) the application of mathematics in other

Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread John F. Sowa
Jerry and Edwina, I found three quotations by Peirce that directly contradict  the three sentences in ADT's slide 25,  (Copies below my signature) In the first sentence of that slide, ADT belittles Peirce's life's work: "we cannot count on mathematicians to help figure out what goes on in

Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread Edwina Taborsky
Jerry, list I like your outline of the nine terms and the graphic connections. I'm not a chemist and your outline is 'packed' with meaning, but, I agree with your conclusion, that " to 'transition out of mathematics’ infers, from the perception chemical signs, transitioning out

Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread Robert Marty
In English : Where do you get this position of power on this list that allows you to choose very biased ADT slides, to supposedly put them up for debate, to set yourself up as a vigilante when participants argue disagreements and to pass judgement on them? Edwina has long experienced this and I

Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread Robert Marty
Le lun. 16 août 2021 à 17:10, a écrit : > Bernard, thanks for this clarification; it shows that my comment about the > “dynamic object” of the term “phaneroscopy” was completely wrong. Indeed > you’ve shown that the concept of a “dynamic object” plays no part in your > philosophy of language. >

Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread Robert Marty
Gary F, Soyez persuadé que je ne cesserai pas de lut Le lun. 16 août 2021 à 17:10, a écrit : > Bernard, thanks for this clarification; it shows that my comment about the > “dynamic object” of the term “phaneroscopy” was completely wrong. Indeed > you’ve shown that the concept of a “dynamic

Aw: [PEIRCE-L] ⚠ It’s A Trap ⚠

2021-08-16 Thread Helmut Raulien
Jon, List   The classification of a sign is due to the three relations S-S, S-O, S-I. Is this another kind of projective reducibility, in which XxX, XxY, XxZ also determines the triadic relation XxYxZ, and determination in this case is classification?   Best, Helmut     16. August 2021 um

RE: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread gnox
Bernard, thanks for this clarification; it shows that my comment about the “dynamic object” of the term “phaneroscopy” was completely wrong. Indeed you’ve shown that the concept of a “dynamic object” plays no part in your philosophy of language. BM: To my sense, be it a technical or standard

[PEIRCE-L] ⚠ It’s A Trap ⚠

2021-08-16 Thread Jon Awbrey
Cf: ⚠ It’s A Trap ⚠ https://inquiryintoinquiry.com/2013/05/18/%e2%9a%a0-its-a-trap-%e2%9a%a0/ Re: Kenneth W. Regan • Graduate Student Traps https://rjlipton.wpcomstaging.com/2013/05/15/graduate-student-traps So it begins ... The most common mathematical trap I run across has to do with Triadic

[PEIRCE-L] Are we bodies or souls? The Logic and Religion Webinar, August 19

2021-08-16 Thread Logic and Religion Association LARA
Dear Colleague, You are invited to join the second session of The Logic and Religion Webinar Series, organized by the Logic and Religion Association (LARA), which will be held on August 19 at 4pm CEST with the topic: *ARE WE BODIES OR SOULS?* Speaker: Richard Swinburne (University of Oxford,

Re: [PEIRCE-L] André De Tienne: Slow Read slide 25

2021-08-16 Thread Bernard Morand
Gary F., list Le 15/08/2021 à 14:35, g...@gnusystems.ca a écrit : Bernard, I wish I could converse about this aspect of language in French, but unfortunately I don’t have that ability. BM: But I am wholly astonished by the rigorus property you are attaching to definitions or descriptions