Re: [PEIRCE-L] [EXTERNAL] Your claim is unpublishable (was Objects and Perception (was God and the Universe (was The Thing In Itself)))

2023-06-13 Thread JACK ROBERT KELLY CODY
John, I do appreciate the advice but: 1. Embodied Existence: Individuals exist as embodied beings in a physical universe. ∃x (Individual(x) ∧ Embodied(x) ∧ InPhysicalUniverse(x)) 2. Derivation of Experience: Human understanding and feeling are derivational of physical elements via sensa

[PEIRCE-L] Your claim is unpublishable (was Objects and Perception (was God and the Universe (was The Thing In Itself)))

2023-06-13 Thread John F Sowa
Jack, Your latest summary is very clear. Unfortunately, there are three criticisms that make it unacceptable for any serious publication: According to three ways of interpreting the phrase "in itself", your claim is (1) obvious and irrelevant, (2) complex and unprovable, (3) irrelevant to any