John, List:
JFS: We were talking about a method that a student or scholar of Peirce may
use for testing a sign to determine whether it is an instance of 1ns, 2ns,
or 3ns.
Again, according to Peirce, there are *ten different respects* by which a
sign can be classified as an instance of
Jon, List,
You recently wrote:
JAS: I do not know whether anyone has posted a mathematical proof of
Peirce's reduction thesis on the Internet. Robert Burch wrote an entire
book to present his [. . .] while Sergiy Koshkin purports to demonstrate it
even more rigorously in a recent paper.
I
List,
A couple of List members have noted that *Commens *is back up and running.
http://www.commens.org
We have Ben Udell to thank for noodling within the site when it went down,
then alerting Mats Bergman -- who manages and, along with Sami Paavola and João
Queiroz, developed that very useful
Jon, John, List,
The answer "A brooch" looks like a rheme, but as an answer it is a proposition, as "he gives her" is just omitted for the reason, that both know this opening. A triadic proposition, I think, if not already is an argument, at least involves a "because". For example if you say;
