Re: [PEIRCE-L] Delta Existential Graphs (was The Proper Way in Logic)

2024-02-20 Thread John F Sowa
Jon, The entire letter L376 is about Delta graphs and applications of Delta graphs. Since Peirce began the letter to Risteen shortly after his visit, he was assuming that Risteen knew a great deal about the material they had discussed. Therefore, he plunged into examples without much of an in

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Language as Semiosis

2024-02-20 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
Michael, List: Thanks for sharing the article. Although it seems incidental to your overall project, footnote 2 caught my eye. MS: The use by Peirce of the form "rationalized" (rather than "rational") as a modifier of "variety" in the quotation above should be taken advisedly. This use of the par

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Delta Existential Graphs (was The Proper Way in Logic)

2024-02-20 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
John, List: Here is an exact quotation of what Peirce actually says in R L376 (letter to Risteen) about the phemic sheet consisting of multiple "papers." CSP: I provide my system with a *phemic sheet*, which is a surface upon which the utterer and interpreter will, by force of a voluntary and act

Re: [PEIRCE-L] The Proper Way in Logic (was Peirce's Ongoing Semiotic Project)

2024-02-20 Thread Edwina Taborsky
I did not say that the Hopi way of taking about time is objectionable. I said that I consider it incorrect to consider that because the Hopi view time in a particular manner and have words for this view, that this does not mean that they would not understand the SAE way of thinking about time. T