Re: [PEIRCE-L] List moderator;s request for a pause in the 'mark' v. 'tone' discussion, Classifying Signs (was Mark Token Type)

2024-04-23 Thread Ben Udell
Gary was not on your recipient list but you obviously intended for him to receive it.  Peirce-l doesn't receive your messages, at least for the time being. - Ben On 4/22/2024 3:53 PM, John F Sowa wrote: Gary and Ben, Why do you insist on punishing me instead of Jon?  Or both? You asked me to

Re: [PEIRCE-L] List moderator;s request for a pause in the 'mark' v. 'tone' discussion, Classifying Signs (was Mark Token Type)

2024-04-20 Thread John F Sowa
Ben, Gary, List, As I said in my last note, this thread has wasted everybody's time for no useful purpose. The real expert on this topic is Tony Jappy, who has devoted years of research and publications to this topic. As I said in the first notes, Tony is the expert on this topic.. But he do

Re: [PEIRCE-L] List moderator;s request for a pause in the 'mark' v. 'tone' discussion, Classifying Signs (was Mark Token Type)

2024-04-20 Thread Ben Udell
Well said. Joe Ransdell would be proud. - Best, Ben On 4/20/2024 6:26 PM, Gary Richmond wrote: List, As Edwina accurately commented a few days ago, this exchange between John and Jon has become less a discussion and more a debate, so much so that I have commented -- now for the third time -- t

[PEIRCE-L] List moderator;s request for a pause in the 'mark' v. 'tone' discussion, Classifying Signs (was Mark Token Type)

2024-04-20 Thread Gary Richmond
List, As Edwina accurately commented a few days ago, this exchange between John and Jon has become less a discussion and more a debate, so much so that I have commented -- now for the third time -- that it would seem to me that Peirce-L members now (and perhaps for some time now) have enough info