Gary F., List:
GF: It’s lacking an object. It doesn’t represent anything. The
performance *interprets
*the score but doesn’t *represent *it; it simply presents itself.
I honestly do not see how the performance can be accurately described as
interpreting the score *without *representing it. A per
m: peirce-l-requ...@list.iupui.edu On
Behalf Of Jon Alan Schmidt
Sent: 7-Nov-21 16:48
To: Peirce-L
Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Theosemiotic, the entire universe as a narrative or
argument?
Gary F., List:
FYI, your post once again had some white-on-white text, which I have fixed
below.
GF: A narrativ
Gary F., List:
FYI, your post once again had some white-on-white text, which I have fixed
below.
GF: A *narrative *is basically a representation of *a sequence of events* which
is not necessarily meaningful in any way.
JAS: On the contrary, a narrative is a sign, and every sign is "meaningful"
..
Supplement: Maybe the universe is both the text and the writer (pantheism), or the universe is the text and the writer´s body (panentheism), or the universe is the text alone (theism). Which of these three possibilities are real, we can never know, because it is impossible to conclude from
List,
I think, a narrative is not necessarily an argument, or a set of propositions and arguments, it may also be a set of propositions only. I agree, that a narrative has a purpose, which is the narrator´s intention to narrate. Narrative intention is the intention to fixate belief. If the narr
n Alan Schmidt
Sent: 6-Nov-21 17:22
To: Peirce-L
Subject: Re: [PEIRCE-L] Theosemiotic, the entire universe as a narrative or
argument?
Gary F., Gary R., List:
GF (via GR below): What’s the difference between a narrative and an argument?
An argument is a specific kind of sign as disting
Gary F., Gary R., List:
GF (via GR below): What’s the difference between a narrative and an
argument?
An argument is a specific kind of sign as distinguished from a proposition
or a name in that it distinctly represents its interpretant, namely, its
conclusion (CP 2.95, 1902). Accordingly, I sug
List,
In an off List message Gary Fuhrman offered this quotation by the Peirce
scholar, most recently president of the Charles S. Peirce Society (now past
president) through the covid lockdown year of 2020, Michael Ramposa.
“For anyone who embraces theosemiotic, the entire universe is a text, no
