[peirce-l] Logic is rooted in the social principle is rooted in logic, was, Re: [peirce-l] Help on a Peirce Quote

2012-01-02 Thread Gary Richmond
Jerry, Kirsti, List, For now I'll comment on just one of your questions, Jerry, that concerning 'the social principle'. Since there are several possible approaches to an answer to it--some of them, for example, might emphasize critical common sense, others, synechism or agapism, etc.--perhaps an

Re: [peirce-l] Help on a Peirce Quote

2012-01-02 Thread Määttänen Kirsti
Gary, list, To me, your trichotomics is a fruitful approach. I don't see any basic disagreement between our views. To comment your provisional diagram: It may be better to take the case with the utterer as the first separately from taking the interpreter as the first. Putting both in the