[peirce-l] Re: A sign as First or third...

2006-06-30 Thread Jorge Lurac
Alase, List:    Yes. I shipped my reply to Claudio with an attachment too extensive for to be distributed, according to the Lyris Administrator. The attachment contained a work that Michel Balat sent me 6 years ago, entitled 'Sur le pragmatisme de Peirce ¨ l'usage des psychistes'. Since Claudio had

[peirce-l] Re: Sinsign, Legisign, Qualisign - help! ...real-reality... truth...

2006-06-30 Thread Jorge Lurac
Claudio,   2.457-458 are not paragraphs. See A Sketch of  Logical Critics on EP 2, pages 451 to 462.   J. LuracClaudio Guerri <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Joe, Ben, Jim, List   thanks for all information   I could not find 'A Sketch of Logical Critics', EP 2.457-458, 1911 because (I

[peirce-l] Re: Sinsign, Legisign, Qualisign - help!

2006-06-30 Thread Benjamin Udell
Hi, Joe, I don't know, maybe you've seen straight through to Calvino's "formula," such that the technique is too obvious to you or something like that. But you also say that you have trouble getting a "firm footing." I doubt that my wide reading (it's not _that_ wide) has that much to do with m

[peirce-l] Re: Sinsign, Legisign, Qualisign - help!

2006-06-30 Thread Joseph Ransdell
In response to me saying:. >Maybe I should add that I find it difficult to believe that anyone has >actually been able to read all of the way through Calvino's practical joke >of a book! Ben says: It's also difficult to believe that anyone eats all the way through a rich, multi-layered Italia

[peirce-l] Re: Trikonic diagram observation of Peirce's 10 Sign Classes

2006-06-30 Thread Gary Richmond
Dear Luis and List, Sorry. I thought this was an off-list post. Gary Gary Richmond wrote: Dear Luis, Thanks for your comments. While the discussion was taking place on Peirce-l I half thought you'd post something (I could have used your help!) But now I see you were away during th

[peirce-l] Re: Trikonic diagram observation of Peirce's 10 Sign Classes

2006-06-30 Thread Gary Richmond
Dear Luis, Thanks for your comments. While the discussion was taking place on Peirce-l I half thought you'd post something (I could have used your help!) But now I see you were away during the exchange. I think Jean-Marc Orliaguet likes to "debate" while I prefer to "inquire," and I don't thin

[peirce-l] Re: Trikonic diagram observation of Peirce's 10 Sign Classes

2006-06-30 Thread merkle
Dear Gary, You are completly right when you say that each diagram stresses some dimensions of semiotic processes. Indeed, today I would complement that the Icon, Index and Symbol, can be both a classificatory scheme (tree classes) or a dimension in a broader set of classes (10 or more classes). T