Re: [PEIRCE-L] Beginning of Life a Triadic Action?

2018-08-10 Thread Edwina Taborsky
Mike, list Thanks for this post - and for your previous post on scientific and natural language - Yes, there are many hypotheses about the emergence of life; thermal vents being a strong suggestion but who knows which will be 'the infallible final' - but the key is,

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Beginning of Life a Triadic Action?

2018-08-10 Thread Stephen Curtiss Rose
Feynman in some of his teaching videos is disarmingly appealing in a way that any thinking such as yours is also appealing -- it has no airs and leaves room for understanding our limitations -- ergo fallibility. I am not sure anyone will ever explain origins to the satisfaction of that imagined

[PEIRCE-L] Beginning of Life a Triadic Action?

2018-08-10 Thread Mike Bergman
List, I think we can expand Stephen's suggestion, to which I think I agree, that triadic action is involved Peirce's pragmatic maxim. I think we can understand the supreme importance of triadic action by questioning how life began from inanimate