[PEN-L:6080] Re: Fwd: re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Doug Henwood
At 8:56 PM 9/9/96, Max B. Sawicky wrote: >Judging art by who likes it is ridiculous. >After all, there are idiots who like Marx. >(We know who you are.) And I read Henwood. Am I the Marx in this analogy? Doug -- Doug Henwood Left Business Observer 250 W 85 St New York NY 10024-3217 USA +1-21

[PEN-L:6079] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
to bill mitchell: Duke Ellington once claimed that the swingingest piece of music that he had ever heard was Bach's Third Brandenburg Concerto. Yep, it does. Of course, the Duke was an awfully tame jazzman I don't know about classical music in OZ, but I wouldn't be surprised if

[PEN-L:6078] Re: Fwd: re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Max B. Sawicky
Judging art by who likes it is ridiculous. After all, there are idiots who like Marx. (We know who you are.) And I read Henwood. The best progressive music many of you never heard of is the musical theatrical production "Pins and Needles." It was orginally staged by the ILGWU in the forties. T

[PEN-L:6077] Re: Clinton and Blair NOT! on same wavelength

1996-09-09 Thread Blair Sandler
Okay, perhaps I was unnecessarily insulting. Maybe Clinton is *not* a sleazy slimey slug. Let's say he's a sleazy slimy scumbag. After all, while I don't like slugs in my garden, sea slugs are very cool beings. :) Blair P.S. sorry about the sleezy spelling error. I wrote, >>Just so there is

[PEN-L:6076] Re: A Labor Party in Buffalo?

1996-09-09 Thread Gerald Levy
Paul: I am appalled by the treatment you and the Buffalo Chapter received from the Labor Party national leadership. To put it mildly, such undemocratic and bureaucratic fiats do not help the LP realize the potential that it has to challenge the bourgeois political parties. I am also dismayed that

[PEN-L:6075] Re: FYI

1996-09-09 Thread Max B. Sawicky
Doug Henwood wrote: > > If you've been reading your LBO, you know that I think lots of claims about > "globalization" are grossly overdone. Obviously production is more > internationalized now than it was 40 years ago, but the unprecedentedness > of this, the intensity of the trend, and the level

[PEN-L:6074] Re: Fwd: re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Blair Sandler
I'm listening to a very cool CD of Thelonious Monk (advanced jazz?) as I write this. But he's African American, so it's okay, right? Blair (who is NOT on the same wavelength as Clinton) Sandler [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Oh shit, I better turn in my union card, I listen to classical music > (rgh)

[PEN-L:6073] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Blair Sandler
Antonio wrote, >I hope I am not irking any Hegelians out there Oh come now, Antonio: you *like* irking Hegelians! :) Blair Blair Sandler [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:6072] Re: A Labor Party in Buffalo?

1996-09-09 Thread Paul Zarembka
Maggie, Didn't you get my PEN-L:6040 or are you asking for more? Of course, I think there is more to it--like the fact that I have been openly critical of the undemocratic nature of the founding convention and one of our Buffalo members was the woman at the convention who said she cannot work for

[PEN-L:6071] Re: Clinton and Blair NOT! on same wavelength

1996-09-09 Thread Blair Sandler
Just so there is absolutely no mistake: I am NOT! on the same wavelength as Clinton. I'm only sorry we're even on the same planet. I am one of those folks who does *not* believe in lesserevilism, so I will not be voting for Clinton and I will be telling stories everywhere I get the opportunity ab

[PEN-L:6070] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread PHILLPS
I am a little suprised at a kind of a-historicism and cultural insensitivity of Bill and Doug with respect to both classical music (in particular opera) and fold music a la Seeger et al. With respect to opera, Verdi's music was considered so politically dangerous by the elite that he was heavily

[PEN-L:6069] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Antonio Callari
My! My! (If that is the correct idiomatic expression) Does all this talk about music and dance mean that there is something to overdetermination (the complex and open operations of displacement and condensation across processes--class and non-class) after all? Antonio Callari Antonio Callari E-M

[PEN-L:6068] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Antonio Callari
Michael, in Italy, opera was very much an arena of political action during the Risorgimento (a decades long struggle for italian independence from a number of 'foreign' powers.) Verdi and others were political figures as well as artists. It's true, of course, that italy was eventually unified as a

[PEN-L:6067] Re: Assistance, please

1996-09-09 Thread MScoleman
Dear femeconers and pen-lers; Would people please reply to me off list with addresses of 'progressive' lists and web sites? I am making a non-objective, non-scientific survey. maggie coleman Reply to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:6066] Notes on the construction of kultur

1996-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
Here are some notes concerning the making of high brow and low brow theater: Wilentz, Sean. 1984. Chants Democratic: New York City and the Rise of the American Working Class (New York: Oxford University Press). 255: The unions promoted a code of "radical rectitude," yet many workers retained th

[PEN-L:6065] Fwd: re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread MScoleman
Oh shit, I better turn in my union card, I listen to classical music (rgh) maggie coleman [EMAIL PROTECTED] - Forwarded message: From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Doug Henwood) Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-to: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] (Multiple recip

[PEN-L:6064] Re: A Labor Party in Buffalo?

1996-09-09 Thread MScoleman
Paul, Hey, that's not fair :), you can NOT tell us you've been ex-communicated by pope tony without telling us the whys and wherefores! maggie coleman [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:6063] Re: Higher Ed, $$$ and class

1996-09-09 Thread MScoleman
I'm not sure quite where this fits in with David laibman's original post, but The problem I have with computerized learning is the standardization of education. Each teacher brings to the class a unique viewpoint and a personality through which learning is filtered to the student. If we be

[PEN-L:6062] Clinton and Blair on same wavelength

1996-09-09 Thread D Shniad
The London Times September 9 1996 BLAIR HEADS FOR CLASH WITH TUC ON NO-STRIKE PACKAGE By Philip Bassett and Philip Webster RADICAL plans to prevent a Labour government being derailed by a wave of public sector pay strikes are to be put forward by the Labour leadership tomorrow in a

[PEN-L:6061] web and network (fwd)

1996-09-09 Thread D Shniad
> Please list the following in your search engine and web pointer or > wherever you let these things out ... > > Web site: http://www.lightlink.com/wrehberg > > This is Web site for SPAN/--Shoestrings & Grace, twin upstate New > York ecumenical social-justice and human-rights volunteer project

[PEN-L:6060] What Is Profit? (I)

1996-09-09 Thread SHAWGI TELL
The question of "making a living" is a most important one for human beings. "Livings" have been made in various ways at different times and stages of the development of human society. The main form of making a living in a society is determined by the manner in which the ruling class or class

[PEN-L:6059] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread bill mitchell
Jim writes: >It seems to me that _any_ kind of music can be turned into >"ruling class music": there's rock, but there's also homogenized >corporate rock; there's rap, but there's also manipulative >corporate rap; etc. well i wasn't talking about the way the cappos steal every good idea that

Re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Wojtek Sokolowski
With all due respect, this debate on the political nature of music, while focusing on the aesthetic interpretations, misses a much simpler point: how music is being produced or, more precisely, what kind of resources are needed to produce it. To produce, say, a piece for an orchestra you need a l

[PEN-L:6058] "New" Book--Same old...

1996-09-09 Thread James Michael Craven
I picked up a book the other day "Centuries of Economic Endeavor:Parallel Paths in Japan and Europe and Their Contrast With the Third World" by John P. Powelson, Univ of Michigan, 1997 ed. On the cover the endorsements read: "Extremely exciting...Leverage...is a very important conept which I h

[PEN-L:6057] Disinformation In Canada

1996-09-09 Thread SHAWGI TELL
Disinformation is a weapon of the ruling circles to maintain the status quo. The triumvirate of big government, big business and big labor uses it to keep the people, particularly the working class, in a state of ideological and political disorientation about the problems facing society

[PEN-L:6056] globalization

1996-09-09 Thread JDevine
The contrast between Jeremy Seabrook's article on globalization (that Sid Schniad posted) and Doug Henwood's article in MONTHLY REVIEW (that Mike Yates lauded) is striking. While Seabrook stresses globalization (seemingly) as a new phenomenon, for Henwood, much of it is very similar to the er

[PEN-L:6055] Re: Korean reunification complications

1996-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
Rosser Jr, John Barkley wrote: > BTW, I apologize to the list for picking on poor old > Shawgi Tell so much. Michael P. has told me offlist to cut > it out, but I really find it hard to resist. I guess that > Michael figures that either 1) Shawgi can't defend himself > because he is so woo

[PEN-L:6054] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Doug Henwood
At 11:19 AM 9/9/96, Thad Williamson wrote: >But 30 years later, Seeger is still at it, going around playing the >same songs on left fundraisers and events all year long. Dylan is still >at it too, but neither he nor the other rockers of that generation have >any overt connection with any politicl

Re: [PEN-L:6042] Re: the politics of classical music

1996-09-09 Thread Peter Dorman
I can't believe this discussion (in this form) is taking place over pen-l. The political significance of an artform is not reducible to who produces it, enjoys it, pays for it, etc., although all of these may be relevant. There is, of course, a long tradition on the left of analyzing these thing

Re: [PEN-L:6034] Attack on tenure

1996-09-09 Thread Wojtek Sokolowski
I see nothing wrong in attacking the tenure as we know it. The academia has long been used in this country to dillute social movements and ease popular pressure on the elites. The tenure system is basically coopting the potential community organizers by giving them meaningless sinecures. Thus f

[PEN-L:6053] Internationalism vs. Globalization

1996-09-09 Thread D Shniad
INTERNATIONALISM VERSUS GLOBALIZATION While internationalism would celebrate the achievements, struggles and creativity of the poor, and the equal rights of all peoples of the world to develop in dignity, sufficiency and security, globalisation and global capitalism requires the humiliation of hu

[PEN-L:6052] What Should Be Tha Aim Of The Toronto Shutdown?

1996-09-09 Thread SHAWGI TELL
Since the first shutdown in London last December, opposition to the anti-social offensive has been clearly established as the aim of the OFL Fightback Campaign. The leadership of the OFL has not shown any indication that it will take the aim further. In fact, since Peterborough, some of the

[PEN-L:6051] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Thad Williamson
Doug repeats the standard pro-rock'n-roll line! Yes, Pete Seeger is a Harvard drop-out, and no, he and many otheres weren't happy when Dylan plugged in at Newport in 1965. But 30 years later, Seeger is still at it, going around playing the same songs on left fundraisers and events all year long

[PEN-L:6050] overdetermination (not music)

1996-09-09 Thread JDevine
Continuing the discussion of overdetermination and the Amherst school (but not that of music): Steve Cullenberg writes that:>> I am not sure why you want to continue to insist that overdetermination is warmed-over empiricism (you wrote the essence of overdetermination is empiricism), but I do hop

[PEN-L:6049] Korean reunification complications

1996-09-09 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
On the editorial page of the _Wall Street Journal_ this morning there was a column arguing that the recent convictions of the former South Korean presidents would make peaceful reunification of the Koreas harder because the North Korean leadership would now view itself as in danger of be

[PEN-L:6048] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
On Mon, 9 Sep 1996 09:27:24 -0700 (PDT) [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > It seems to me that _any_ kind of music can be turned into > "ruling class music": there's rock, but there's also homogenized > corporate rock; there's rap, but there's also manipulative > corporate rap; etc. > > By "rulin

[PEN-L:6047] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread Doug Henwood
At 9:27 AM 9/9/96, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >This is especially so since people can >often use "ruling class music" for purposes for which it was not >designed. Classical music has become upscale muzak for sensitive yuppies, an aural marker of "sophisticiation" popular in cafes, boutiques, and J

[PEN-L:6046] re: rethinking overdetermination

1996-09-09 Thread JDevine
It seems to me that _any_ kind of music can be turned into "ruling class music": there's rock, but there's also homogenized corporate rock; there's rap, but there's also manipulative corporate rap; etc. By "ruling class music" do we a type of music that (a) doesn't encourage any critical thi

[PEN-L:6045] Liberal Party of Canada and Korean students

1996-09-09 Thread Rosser Jr, John Barkley
Please, Shawgi, tell us: Are South Korean students applying in droves for refugee status in Canada? We are all dying to know how they have been fascistically rejected. -- Rosser Jr, John Barkley [EMAIL PROTECTED]

[PEN-L:6044] RE: Higher Ed. $$$ & Class

1996-09-09 Thread Jim Westrich
At 10:19 PM 9/7/96 -0700, you wrote: >Are the following "facts" true? > >1. Faculty salaries are not keeping up with inflation. This is not true for every year since 1976. I should have added the CPI (1983=100) data to my chart from last Friday. All data from Research Associates of Washingto

[PEN-L:6043]

1996-09-09 Thread Peter Karl Kresl
UN-SUBSCRIBE PEN-L PETER KARL KRESL Peter Karl Kresl Department of Economics Bucknell University Lewisburg, PA 17837 USA Tel: 717-524-1478 Fax: 717-524-3451

[PEN-L:6042] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
bill mitchell wrote about classical music. In Italy, the opera seems to have been popular among more common people. Am I wrong? Were there inexpensive opera tickets. With classical music, I do not think that it is only the music, but the mileiu. No talking, just sitting quietly. In Wilenz

[PEN-L:6041] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Michael Perelman
bill mitchell wrote about Classical music. The same applies to other aspects of culture. Wilenz's Chants Democratic describes how in New York, elite entertainment was produced on Broadway. The working class reviled in mh -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Ch

[PEN-L:6040] Re: A Labor Party in Buffalo?

1996-09-09 Thread Paul Zarembka
On Sun, 8 Sep 1996, Michael Perelman wrote: > Paul, Why? Michael, The Buffalo Chapter of the LP endorsed a UAW Regional Director to run for Congress against Bill Paxon (chair of the Republican House Campaign Committee and very right-wing; also husband to Susan Moliarni). That UAW officer is we

[PEN-L:6039] FW: BLS Daily Report

1996-09-09 Thread Richardson_D
BLS DAILY REPORT, FRIDAY, SEPTEMBER 6, 1996 RELEASED TODAY: EMPLOYMENT SITUATION -- Unemployment declined in August, and nonfarm payroll employment continued to increase. The nation's jobless rate fell from 5.4 to 5.1 percent. The number of jobs on nonfarm payrolls rose by 250,000 in Augu

[PEN-L:6038] in defense of the classics

1996-09-09 Thread Gerald Levy
bill mitchell wrote: > well i think this depends on what cultural-economic enviroment you have > grown up in. classical music in the capitalist western world (say, > australia) tends very firmly to be what i would term "ruling class" > entertainment. there is no popular classical culture in OZ.

[PEN-L:6037] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread bill mitchell
Jerry wrote: > >The rejection of classical music including operas by many also, I think, >has an anti-intellectual component to it. > well i think this depends on what cultural-economic enviroment you have grown up in. classical music in the capitalist western world (say, australia) tends very f

[PEN-L:6036] Re: Rethinking Overdetemination

1996-09-09 Thread Gerald Levy
> Its argument > was that the folk audience was actually quite elite (I think the word > Harvard even came up), and folkies were scandalized when the *real* popular > music, rock & roll, got started. > Doug This attitude, in part, strikes me as generational since rockers were also in general "sca