[PEN-L:9300] Re: socialism vs. union rights

1999-07-20 Thread Rob Schaap
G'day Jim, Nice post, mate! I have to take that one extra step, I'm afraid - if 'evil' has any serious application at all, it is as well applied to a system capable of killing and incarcerating youngsters who seek change in the expressed spirit of 'The Internationale', as it is to one capable

[PEN-L:9341] Re: Re: Algeria

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Jim Devine wrote: Louis writes: Actually, state ownership is a socialist goal in itself. I don't want to get into a discussion of "goal in itself" (though maybe pen-l's Kant experts want to do so). My point is that state ownership is necessary but not sufficient to the attainment of

[PEN-L:9345] Re: China looks to guarantee incomes

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Jim Devine called the following a "fascist" development. There is a string of encouraging news coming out of China just before the August annual meeting of the CPC in Baidahe. The wind is blowing left again, finally. Those who prejudge China, do it at their own peril. Henry China to Set up

[PEN-L:9350] Re: chopped liver

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
"Even so, China hardly represents much of a threat to the U.S. in the very near future." I would not be so sure. There is a 50-50 chance there might be a military confrontation between China and the US in the Taiwan Straits begore the year ends. Henry C.K. Liu SCMP

[PEN-L:9351] The Culprit is Disney

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
NATIONAL LABOR COMMITTEE IN SUPPORT OF WORKER AND HUMAN RIGHTS 275 Seventh Avenue, 15th Floor New York, NY 10001 Tel: 212-242-3002 Fax: 212-242-3821 Board of

[PEN-L:9352] Re: Re: Re: Capitalist waste

1999-07-20 Thread Rob Schaap
Hi again, On the matter of telecommunications 'rationalisation', 'efficiency' et-bloody-c: We're always hearing that price drops are exclusively a function of competition (Oz only privatised its Telco and invited in all-level competition in 1996). We're also told that technological

[PEN-L:9353] Re: The Culprit is Disney

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Note the following setence in the letter: workers illegally forced to pay an "entrance fee" to secure their job No benefits are paid, despite the legal obligation of the factory to do so. The workers receive no benefits, despite the fact that under China's labor law, the factories are mandated

[PEN-L:9355] Re: Interesting Pen-l Debates

1999-07-20 Thread Charles Brown
Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED] 07/19/99 07:21PM I find it hard to believe that any sane leader would trust the U.S. in negotiating a deal of such magnitude. The U.S. bullies and bullies and then pretends that it is suddenly filled with a burst morality. It reminds me of a sign I saw in a

[PEN-L:9356] Re: Interesting Pen-l Debates

1999-07-20 Thread Charles Brown
All of this , and, that the Chinese Communist Party is actually still a communist party, that China is on the road to socialism with a brief stopover in capitalism, rather than bypassing it all together. Charles Brown Doug Henwood [EMAIL PROTECTED] 07/19/99 10:35PM Michael Perelman wrote:

[PEN-L:9357] Interesting Pen-l Debates

1999-07-20 Thread Louis Proyect
All of this , and, that the Chinese Communist Party is actually still a communist party, that China is on the road to socialism with a brief stopover in capitalism, rather than bypassing it all together. Charles Brown I think part of the problem in writing about China is that is one of the

[PEN-L:9361] prison labor

1999-07-20 Thread Doug Henwood
Christian Parenti, author of the excellent book Lockdown America: Police and Prisons in the Age of Crisis (due in a couple of months from Verso), told me the other week that the actual number of prison workers in the U.S. is much less than you'd believe from the publicity - around 100,000 out

[PEN-L:9362] JFK death a tragic waste say anarchist dissenters

1999-07-20 Thread Robert Naiman
the opinions expressed are those of these author. we're simply providing space to diverse points of view. Date: Tue, 20 Jul 1999 05:33:16 -0400 (EDT) From: "l'o m b r e noire" [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: JFK death a "tragic waste" say anarchist dissenters MIME-Version: 1.0

[PEN-L:9364] How to handle virus?

1999-07-20 Thread Frank Durgin
I apologize to the list for the infected attachment to the the message on Russian Agriculture [PEN-L:9288]. The disastrous effects of Russian Ag. Reform) That is was infected came as quite a surprise to me. I do a McAfee scan virtually every day, and have never had a virus reported. As It

[PEN-L:9366] Re: How to handle virus?

1999-07-20 Thread Louis Proyect
You have to periodically update McAfee or Norton Utilities, which are the two most commonly used virus-checkers. With Norton, this involves making a connection to the Internet and then selecting "update virus information" from their menu. Then, it goes out to the Norton website and downloads and

[PEN-L:9367] U.S. War Crimes

1999-07-20 Thread Charles Brown
This is a forward with a comment attached. It is another opinion that the U.S. committed war crimes in the attack on Yugoslavia. Clinton sounds a little like Marie Antoinette, if the report on what he said is true. Charles Brown ( Just another article from the BBC on

[PEN-L:9368] The Chinese State

1999-07-20 Thread Michael Keaney
Howdy y'all The ongoing debates re China are useful, although somewhat mired in personalities rather than policies. Whilst on holiday in Finland I have been reading Irving Louis Horowitz's latest book, "Behemoth: Main Currents in the History and Theory of Political Sociology" (Transaction,

[PEN-L:9369] Re: The Chinese State

1999-07-20 Thread Louis Proyect
Unfortunately much debate seems to be guided by the logic of "an enemy of my enemy is my friend", rather than the acknowledgement of the symbiotic linkages of means and ends which must guide efforts towards a deeper, radical democracy. The latter would permit critical observations of China, Cuba,

[PEN-L:9371] Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Michael Perelman
Henry is correct. I do think that such statements are inappropriate. Henry C.K. Liu wrote: I suppose Perelman thinks that statements like this goes far: "I think Henry Liu has proven himself to be extremely partisan in favor of the Chinese government and so I don't think I can rely on him

[PEN-L:9372] Fw: Re: RE: Re: JFK Jr and the Hubris of the Rich

1999-07-20 Thread Frank Durgin
Eugene Coyle wrote , July 19, 1999 3:24 PM Like Jim I am an experienced pilot -- with maybe more actual crashes than he has -- and thought about JFK Jr's flight quite a bit over the last few days. I have an instrument rating and have myself become a bit disoriented at times and

[PEN-L:9373] Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Doug Henwood
Henry C.K. Liu wrote: This after I repeated pointed out the China opposed capitalist unions, not socialist unions. What's the difference? Doug

[PEN-L:9377] Re: The Chinese State

1999-07-20 Thread Brad De Long
Howdy y'all Whilst on holiday in Finland I have been reading Irving Louis Horowitz's latest book, "Behemoth: Main Currents in the History and Theory of Political Sociology" (Transaction, 1999)... Is it worth reading? Would you recommend it? Brad DeLong

[PEN-L:9378] Re: China debate

1999-07-20 Thread Jim Devine
Before I start, I want to apologize to Henry for insulting him by saying that I didn't see him as a reliable source of information about Harry Wu. Never again. Insults usually say more about the insulter than about the insultee. I defiled myself. I wrote: My point is that state ownership is

[PEN-L:9380] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: chopped liver

1999-07-20 Thread Michael Hoover
Sorry, I understand now. I thought that you were saying that they posed a "military threat." Of course, even a successful Granada would have posed a serious threat if it pointed to a different model. Doug Henwood wrote: So was the "Soviet threat" real? I think this point of view

[PEN-L:9382] PK's new SLATE column

1999-07-20 Thread Jim Devine
I know this is breaking my self-imposed rule, but for those who like to read Krugman, here's his new SLATE column (copyright 1999 Bill Gates): Don't Laugh at Me, Argentina: Serious lessons from a silly crisis. By Paul Krugman Argentina used to be a place of legendary political

[PEN-L:9383] Re: Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
The differences are fiundamental. Ideologically, capitalist unions aim at preserving capitalism against the emrgence of socialism while socialist unions aim at destroying capitalisnm to build toward socialism. Capitalist unions accept competition and stratification as just and necessary within

[PEN-L:9384] Re: China debate

1999-07-20 Thread Charles Brown
Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 07/20/99 01:16PM Crucially, I don't see why any country should be _a priori_ exempt from the application of the materialist principles for understanding the world. BTW, reading the history of many countries around the world, I find that (as often as not) countries

[PEN-L:9385] Fear of flyers?

1999-07-20 Thread Louis Proyect
Fear of flyers 'The implication of some media reporting is that the world would be a safer place for everybody else if people did not insist on taking to the sky. But the facts do not bear this view out.' Private pilot David Thomas wishes light aircraft could spread their wings this summer,

[PEN-L:9387] Re: Re: China debate

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Jim Devine wrote: Before I start, I want to apologize to Henry for insulting him by saying that I didn't see him as a reliable source of information about Harry Wu. Never again. Insults usually say more about the insulter than about the insultee. I defiled myself. I wrote: My point is

[PEN-L:9388] Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Brad De Long
Henry, I did not see Jim Devine saying any such thing. He called Wu a nutcase. Look. You probably know more than anyone about China on the list... -- Michael Perelman ?!?! Maybe I'm hopelessly old-fashioned, but I had always thought of "ideology" as something different from "knowledge"...

[PEN-L:9389] Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
No, you are not old fashion. You are pompous which is different than intelligent. Henry C.K. Liu Brad De Long wrote: Henry, I did not see Jim Devine saying any such thing. He called Wu a nutcase. Look. You probably know more than anyone about China on the list... -- Michael Perelman

[PEN-L:9393] Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Doug Henwood
Brad De Long wrote: Maybe I'm hopelessly old-fashioned, but I had always thought of "ideology" as something different from "knowledge" Which just proves you're in the grip of ideology! Quoting, as I did a few weeks ago, from Slavoj Zizek's intro to his edited collection, Mapping Ideology:

[PEN-L:9394] RE: Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
or the grip metaphor is misleading. The second "law" of thermodynamics is true regardless of whether we live in a socialist society or a capitalist society; this is not the same as succumbing to scientism, just that some statements are true whether we wish them to be so or not. The weirdness of

[PEN-L:9396] Re: How to handle virus?

1999-07-20 Thread Michael Pollak
On Tue, 20 Jul 1999, Frank Durgin wrote: As It will be a couple of weeks before I can get any help 'from the mainland", I wonder if anyone could offer some advice to this computer novice on how to handle it. McAfee will clean it for you. It did for me. (That message someone sent you was

[PEN-L:9398] Re: My Ideologies

1999-07-20 Thread Brad De Long
Brad De Long wrote: Maybe I'm hopelessly old-fashioned, but I had always thought of "ideology" as something different from "knowledge" Which just proves you're in the grip of ideology! Doug To which of my ideologies are you referring? (A) My--ideological--belief that the liberal

[PEN-L:9399] Re: Re: Capitalist waste

1999-07-20 Thread Sam Pawlett
Doug Dowd wrote an interesting and short book called *The Waste of Nations*. There is also a fascinating and very original book called The World's Wasted Wealth by J.W. Smith a non-academic, Montana ranchhand and arch left populist. Sam Pawlett

[PEN-L:9400] Re: a warning from the nanny

1999-07-20 Thread Brad De Long
"Henry C.K. Liu" wrote: Devine attacks China for opposing capitalist unions. He defends Harry Wu, even after he has been given some basic facts. He wants to promote Western democracy in socialist China. He buys into all the propaganda slandering about China without any effort to

[PEN-L:9403] Re: Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Michael Eisenscher
BY LAW, unions in the USA and those who work in administrative positions in those unions must declare themselves to be against communism or they GO TO JAIL (Taft-Hartley Act). NOT SO! The non-communist affidavit of T-H was thrown out by the Supreme Court many years ago. I believe the case

[PEN-L:9397] Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Sam Pawlett
Henry C.K. Liu wrote: The differences are fiundamental. Ideologically, capitalist unions aim at preserving capitalism against the emrgence of socialism while socialist unions aim at destroying capitalisnm to build toward socialism. Unions in capitalism usually aim at protecting the

[PEN-L:9392] Re: Moore set to take reigns of WTO

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Tension over the Taiwan Strait has today escalated higher than the temperature in August. Jiang Zemin was reported today as having made a declaration of "3 regardless". 1) Regardless of limits, the PLA will reunited China by force to prevent Taiwan independence, confronting US forces if

[PEN-L:9390] Moore set to take reigns of WTO

1999-07-20 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
Everybody seems so uptight today...workers of the world, relax. It's freakin' hot..Grab a beer. BTW here's some more bad news. Ian Tuesday July 20, 1:00 pm Eastern Time FOCUS-New Zealand's Moore set to get top WTO job (recasts throughout) By Robert Evans GENEVA, July 20 (Reuters) - Former

[PEN-L:9386] Re: Re: How to handle virus?

1999-07-20 Thread Frank Durgin
Doug: I thank you for the message. As regards how to cure it, a message I got yesterday ( copied below) indicates that there are ways of cleaning it. I'm an absolute novice here, but I thought possibly the message might be of interest Frank Virus Incident Information

[PEN-L:9381] Re: Re: Re: chopped liver

1999-07-20 Thread Charles Brown
I agree with Doug's point below. The Soviet Union and the other countries mentioned were not MILITARY threats. The mindbenders in the capitalist world developed the big lie of the Communist military threat, as a cover for attacking socialist countries which were a political alternative and

[PEN-L:9376] Re: Re: Re: chopped liver

1999-07-20 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: Agreed. We also hear of the North Korean threat. Remember Reagan's line about the Sandinistas being close to southern Texas? I do not think that those people believe in the reality of such threats. Well, maybe Reagan did. So was the "Soviet threat" real? I think this

[PEN-L:9375] Re: How to handle virus?

1999-07-20 Thread Doug Henwood
Frank Durgin wrote: That is was infected came as quite a surprise to me. I do a McAfee scan virtually every day, and have never had a virus reported. As It will be a couple of weeks before I can get any help 'from the mainland", I wonder if anyone could offer some advice to this computer

[PEN-L:9370] Re: Re: chopped liver

1999-07-20 Thread Michael Perelman
Doug Henwood wrote: I bet we're going to hear a lot more about the Chinese threat. Agreed. We also hear of the North Korean threat. Remember Reagan's line about the Sandinistas being close to southern Texas? I do not think that those people believe in the reality of such threats. Well,

[PEN-L:9363] RE: prison labor

1999-07-20 Thread Max Sawicky
This issue has some wrinkles. I would bet that prisoners would prefer some types of work to doing nothing. Obviously not working in chain-gangs or picking tomatoes, but booking airline tickets or doing light manufacturing -- even at pitiful or zero wages -- might be preferable to alternatives.

[PEN-L:9360] Re: Let's slow down here

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
I suppose Perelman thinks that statements like this goes far: "I think Henry Liu has proven himself to be extremely partisan in favor of the Chinese government and so I don't think I can rely on him for such assertions being true." Devine wrote: Concerning issues of fact, I started and ended

[PEN-L:9354] Re: Re: Re: Re: Capitalist waste

1999-07-20 Thread ann li
Hi Rob, I'm not sure who is promoting the idea that natural monopoly is gone in telecom/telematics, but I would like to see something a bit more analytical and quantitative on that score; I recall some journalists making that claim. It still seems pretty solid in the teaching literature. Of

[PEN-L:9344] China on the right path

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
July 1, 1999 President Jiang Zemin's Speech on the 78th anniversary of the founding of the CPC ¡¡As general secretary of the CPC Central Committee, Jiang made his plea when addressing a forum on June 28 marking the 78th anniversary of the founding of Party. Jiang Urges Party to Emphasize Its

[PEN-L:9343] Re: Re: Re: Interesting Pen-l Debates

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Those were not "optimistic" (in defiant of fact) words. I forwarded pro-Western HK newspaper reports about leftist opposition to economic reform, WTO and SOE privatization. These are high visible and well noticed facts that even the casual observer cannot miss. Michael Perelman wrote: What

[PEN-L:9342] Re: Re: socialism vs. union rights

1999-07-20 Thread Henry C.K. Liu
Devine attacks China for opposing capitalist unions. He defends Harry Wu, even after he has been given some basic facts. He wants to promote Western democracy in socialist China. He buys into all the propaganda slandering about China without any effort to verify any facts. I have already

Re: [PEN-L:9311] A Polemic against neo-liberal globalism

1999-07-20 Thread John M. Legge
See my web site for a review of Gray (and James Galbraith) John M. Legge http://www.users.bigpond.com/msn/jlegge/ - Original Message - From: Craven, Jim [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, 20 July 1999 6:51 Subject: [PEN-L:9311] A Polemic against neo-liberal globalism For an intresting