[PEN-L:11189] US FDI in Indonesia

1999-09-17 Thread Seth Sandronsky
Hi All, I'm looking for recent data on US foreign direct investment in Indonesia. Thanks in advance, all. Seth Sandronsky __ Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com

[PEN-L:11192] Re: Re: Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Jim Devine
Rod writes: The question is why did the Europeans burst out of their continent from the 15th century on, and why were they able to conquer everyone in their path. Bill writes: In a nutshell, if I remember Blaut correctly, they luckily stumbled upon America where they plundered with

[PEN-L:11195] Re: Re: Back to Smith, Bentham, Cobden Bright? (was Re: Role of the Colonial Trade)

1999-09-17 Thread Michael Perelman
Sam P. cited Michael Hudson's wonderful 2 volume work. He clearly makes the case that Smith et al. made the case that colonialism did not pay only to suggest to potential competitors that they should not follow England's example and try to industrialize except via the market. In effect, he was

[PEN-L:11197] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
Blaut hardly understands Weber, as became quite evident in our exchange last Winter in the World-H list. Each and every claim here about China can be easily refuted. But now I am dealing with the colonial trade. Jim Blaut, "Colonizer's Model of the World": It is now known beyond doubt

[PEN-L:11198] Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Charles Brown wrote: Charles: I suggest Chapter 9, "Financial Rulers of America" in _Superprofits and Crises_ by Victor Perlo, to dispel this notion that Lenin thought banks and not stock markets were the financial capitalist institutions. Perlo says "Ownership and control of stocks is part

[PEN-L:11199] Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Jim Devine
Doug wrote: Forget Perlo and Lenin and read the Wall Street Journal instead. but not the editorials. Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://clawww.lmu.edu/~JDevine

[PEN-L:11205] Request from Matt Forstater

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
the hurricane has knocked me off e-mail and I can't post to pen-l from this (I don't think). Can someone ask Ricardo on the list why he is not responding to my posts-- that is, why he is not responding to the Darity arguments??? he requested that I type in the stuff. are they not worthy of

[PEN-L:11208] Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread ann li
A general question for pen-l'ers: For those who are much better at the marxological stuff than I, could someone who perhaps has read the original tell me if Hilferding in the Bottomore version of Finance Capital when he speaks of fictitious capital is saying the same kind of thing in German and

[PEN-L:11210] Re: US FDI in Indonesia

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Seth Sandronsky wrote: I'm looking for recent data on US foreign direct investment in Indonesia. Thanks in advance, all. Choose from your options at http://www.bea.doc.gov/bea/di1.htm. Doug

[PEN-L:11213] Re: Re: Re: Back to Smith, Bentham, Cobden Bright? (was Re: Role of the Colonial Trade)

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: Sam P. cited Michael Hudson's wonderful 2 volume work. He clearly makes the case that Smith et al. made the case that colonialism did not pay only to suggest to potential competitors that they should not follow England's example and try to industrialize except via the

[PEN-L:11214] Re: Request from Matt Forstater

1999-09-17 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
the hurricane has knocked me off e-mail and I can't post to pen-l from this (I don't think). Can someone ask Ricardo on the list why he is not responding to my posts-- that is, why he is not responding to the Darity arguments??? he requested that I type in the stuff. are they not worthy

[PEN-L:11215] Re: Re: Re: Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
Jim, Blaut argues that it was the fact that the Atlantic is narrower than the Pacific that accounted for the crucial ability of the Western Europeans to get to the Americas to do the exploiting before the Chinese (some Asians having already gotten there earlier but who lacked sufficient

[PEN-L:11221] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Jim Devine
Barkley writes: Blaut argues that it was the fact that the Atlantic is narrower than the Pacific that accounted for the crucial ability of the Western Europeans to get to the Americas to do the exploiting before the Chinese (some Asians having already gotten there earlier but who lacked

[PEN-L:11224] Re: Patrick's categories

1999-09-17 Thread Jim Devine
Patrick Bond separates out three categories: a) an international reformism aimed at merely improving (around the edges) the embryonic world-state institutions, as was done with the WB over the past decade or so, namely making them more green, more gender-friendly, more transparent, and more

[PEN-L:11227] Re: Re: Request from Matt Forstater

1999-09-17 Thread Mathew Forstater
Ricardo- I understand to a certain extent. But we all many of us have limited time and other responsibilities, and it appears you have time for other responses, and yet until now you have not even acknowledged the Darity interventions (via my sore and aching fingertips). I look forward with

[PEN-L:11229] Re: Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread michael
Ann, I thought that H.'s discussion of fic. capital was pretty thin. I had expected a lot more. Hilferding, p. 225: "It is clear that with the increasing concentration of property, the owners of the fictitious capital which gives power over the banks, and the owners of the capital which gives

[PEN-L:11230] Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
Jim Blaut, "Colonizer's Model of the World": Precious Metals We notice first the export of gold and silver from the Americas and its insertion within the circuits of an Eastern Hemispheric market economy in which gold and silver already provide the common measure of value, directly or

[PEN-L:11231] Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
Of course this does not answer the crucial question as to why the Chinese did not go around the Cape of Good Hope in the 1400s while the Portuguese did in 1497 with Vasco da Gama. Thus we had the Portuguese in Goa and Macau rather than the Chinese in Cadiz and Lisbon. Barkley Rosser Blaut

[PEN-L:11237] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/17/99 12:29PM My reading suggests that a crucial reason why capitalism came to Europe first was the decentralized and somewhat chaotic socioeconomic organization of the western part of the continent that has been called "feudalism." The constant wars encouraged

[PEN-L:11240] Re: Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
Whereas in the Wall Street Journal gems are far from rare. CB Doug Henwood [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/17/99 04:10PM Charles Brown wrote: Victor Perlo is writing TODAY ( but history hasn't really ended) I know. Believe it or not, I read the People's Weekly World. Every once in a while you come

[PEN-L:11242] Person work hours at the dawn of capitalism

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
The quantitative studies you refer to must be based on the records of the early capitalists, in the case of calculating for the very beginning of capitalism. Do those records keep track of all the hours that their first slaves and semi-slaves in the colonies worked ? Afterall , since they

[PEN-L:11241] Re: Wallerstein's response to O'Brien

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
Do you have any stats on the number of person hours worked in Europe and the number of person hours worked in the colonies by slaves and semi-slaves at the rosy dawn of capital ? Charles Brown "Ricardo Duchesne" [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/17/99 04:48PM Wallerstein starts his response saying he

[PEN-L:11239] : finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
Doug Henwood [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/17/99 01:20PM Forget Perlo and Lenin and read the Wall Street Journal instead. Charles: Perlo is alive today, and has written books on capitalism today. So, your implication that my argument here is not based on a contemporary professional

[PEN-L:11236] Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
It may be something as weird as that the Chinese--living in the "Central Country"--didn't have the crusading habit. By contrast Europeans were used to the idea that there were other richer guys with interesting stuff in other parts of the world--and had acquired the crusading habit half a

[PEN-L:11235] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Brad De Long
Jim, Blaut argues that it was the fact that the Atlantic is narrower than the Pacific that accounted for the crucial ability of the Western Europeans to get to the Americas to do the exploiting before the Chinese ... But Cheng Ho's ships would have had little trouble making it across the

[PEN-L:11234] Re: Back to Smith

1999-09-17 Thread Sam Pawlett
Mathew Forstater wrote: But Smith, contrary to much popular misconception clearly stated the many advantages that came to the colonizers as well as the disadvantages to the colonized. Great post, Mat. To what extent do you think Smith's vigorous opposition to any form of interference in

[PEN-L:11232] Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
Ricardo: "Should remember that many Marxists, including Wood, do not think the colonial trade was that important." Ricardo, I own all of Wood's books and waited until I got home to check up on this. Her newest "The Origin of Capitalism" does not seem to take sides on O'Brien-Darity type

[PEN-L:11233] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Stephen E Philion
Louis, You missed it entirely, it's to Ed Wood(recall the movie?)... Steve On Fri, 17 Sep 1999, Louis Proyect wrote: Ricardo: "Should remember that many Marxists, including Wood, do not think the colonial trade was that important." Ricardo, I own all of Wood's books and waited until

[PEN-L:11228] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Wojtek Sokolowski
PS. I am apalled by the systematic exclusion of historical accident, especially on the Left which is infatauted with hindsight rationalizations. But I would go as far as saying that perhaps three fourths of history (both national and persons) is a result of accident, being in the right place at

[PEN-L:11226] Re: Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Wojtek Sokolowski
At 01:42 PM 9/17/99 -0700, Jim Devine wrote: If one blames all of E's rise on exploitation, then in some ways it's a critique of the periphery that allowed itself to be conquered and exploited. If, on the other hand, one blames it all on capitalism's (or Europe's) internal dynamic, it's quite a

[PEN-L:11225] Re: RE: Re: IMF to become autonomous?

1999-09-17 Thread Carrol Cox
Max Sawicky wrote: . . . Question: do you think there can be progressive nationalism for the U.S., and if so, what might it look like? I couldn't say exactly what it would be but I know what its enemies would call it: Isolationism. In fact that is what the WSJ always calls any fragment of

[PEN-L:11223] Re: Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
Jim, Well, putting my two earlier posts together with your response would suggest the possibility that the crucial difference between Western Europe and China was that Europe had a sufficiently developed form of nascent capitalism that some Europeans were motivated to explore and conquer out

[PEN-L:11222] RE: Re: IMF to become autonomous?

1999-09-17 Thread Max Sawicky
. . . c) a "progressive nationalism" (again, a PEN-L phrase) which, in advocating WB/IMF defunding, takes heart and strength and knowledge from the potential unity of the variety of particularistic struggles against local forms of structural adjustment, malevolent "development" projects and

[PEN-L:11220] RE: Re: Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Max Sawicky
Charles Brown wrote: Victor Perlo is writing TODAY ( but history hasn't really ended) I know. Believe it or not, I read the People's Weekly World. Every once in a while you come across a real gem in there - like Jarvis Tyner's fond farewell to John-John. Doug Hey, lay off PWW; they call me

[PEN-L:11219] Re: Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Charles Brown wrote: Victor Perlo is writing TODAY ( but history hasn't really ended) I know. Believe it or not, I read the People's Weekly World. Every once in a while you come across a real gem in there - like Jarvis Tyner's fond farewell to John-John. Doug

[PEN-L:11218] Re: Re: Re: Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread J. Barkley Rosser, Jr.
One can make a serious argument that a nascent form of capitalism was in existence in Northern Italy (and in Flanders not long thereafter) from the 1200s on. Even Marx recognized this, labeling it "merchant capitalism." T-balance sheet accounting dates from this period from Pisa and Florence

[PEN-L:11217] Re: Wallerstein's response to O'Brien

1999-09-17 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
Wallerstein starts his response saying he will not contest "the particular numbers O'Brien has calculated", except to remind the reader that, in O'Brien's own words, the existing stats on these matters are "scarce and shaky". My view is that, while the data themselves can be the matter of

[PEN-L:11216] Re: Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Jim Devine wrote: Doug wrote: Forget Perlo and Lenin and read the Wall Street Journal instead. but not the editorials. They're hilarious. They're the WSJ's substitute for a comics page, as Michael Thomas says. Doug

[PEN-L:11212] Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: recession?

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Jim Devine wrote: I think Greenspan is a Randian reformist (or pragmatist), not a revolutionary. THere was an article in a recent ish of Reason, the fairly pure libertarian magazine, arguing that even though he works for the state, AG is still fundamentally a Randian. Doug

[PEN-L:11211] Re: Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
Victor Perlo is writing TODAY ( but history hasn't really ended) CB Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/17/99 01:17PM Doug wrote: Forget Perlo and Lenin and read the Wall Street Journal instead. but not the editorials. Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://clawww.lmu.edu/~JDevine

[PEN-L:11209] Re: Re: finanz kapital

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
The basic point is this. "Finance Capital" is a general term meant to encompass all the many forms that the bourgeoisie use for aggregating loan or creditors money. The names and forms have developed some ( although there seem to be Investment BANKS and Merchant BANKS on Wallstreet. And Trusts

[PEN-L:11207] Re: Re: Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/17/99 12:29PM My reading suggests that a crucial reason why capitalism came to Europe first was the decentralized and somewhat chaotic socioeconomic organization of the western part of the continent that has been called "feudalism." The constant wars encouraged

[PEN-L:11206] Re: Re: IMF to become autonomous?

1999-09-17 Thread Doug Henwood
Patrick Bond wrote: a "progressive internationalism" (as it was termed on PEN-L a few years ago) aimed at establishing a world-state What about a progressive internationalism that doesn't focus on creating a world state, but instead focuses on building links among unions, NGOs (the good kind,

[PEN-L:11204] RE: Re: Why China Failed to Become Capitalist

1999-09-17 Thread Charles Brown
I agree with Max that the history of capitalism as an aspect of the theory of social change must be united with action and practice. This means especially for those of us in the U.S.and other imperialist centers making this discussion of history (some of it remote in some senses) relevant to

[PEN-L:11203] Memorable quotations

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
Attitudes of the Rich and Famous... The American system of ours, call it Americanism, call it Capitalism, call it what you like, gives each and every one of us a great opportunity if we only seize it with both hands and make the most of it. --Al Capone The point is that you can't be too

[PEN-L:11202] BLS Daily Report

1999-09-17 Thread Richardson_D
BLS DAILY REPORT, THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 16, 1999 Prices consumers pay for most goods and services--except energy products--rose modestly again in August, resulting in a 0.3 percent rise in the consumer price index for all urban consumers, according to BLS. Analysts looking for new evidence to

[PEN-L:11201] How to pay for debt cancellation

1999-09-17 Thread Robert Naiman
How to pay for debt cancellation: I propose a tax on global blah-blah. The tax could be implemented by granting a patent on global blah-blah to a non-profit corporation, which could then charge royalties for its use and then use the proceeds to purchase debt at market value and cancel it.

[PEN-L:11200] Re: Capitalist development

1999-09-17 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
but his problem with Brenner has always been lost on me because he makes no clear distinction between Brenner and Weber's arguments about the origin of capitalist development. A paper of mine that will come out soon shows that Brenner, in the course of expounding his 'relations of

[PEN-L:11196] Re: Role of the Colonial Trade

1999-09-17 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
Ajit wrote: I think the method of counterfactual is simply a poor way of doing economic history. When it comes to historical data, I think they are usually of rough nature and should be taken with more than a pinch of salt. Yes, these numbers are not 'hard data', but they are certainly

[PEN-L:11194] Re: Re: Re: Re: recession?

1999-09-17 Thread Jim Devine
I wouldn't have thought issuing vouchers or cooking prisoners were particularly/definitively Randian manouvres. Vouchers seem a reformist Randian measure, the free-marketization of public schools. Zapping prisoners is part of the repressive role of the state, a part of the "capitalist ideal"

[PEN-L:11193] Re: Role of the Colonial Trade

1999-09-17 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
Before I sent O'Brien's numbers, Ajit speculated that, if we assume that the take-off to industrialization requires an investment of approx 8% of the GDP, and that the domestic savings contributes 5% to 6% of that, whereas the colonies contribute 2% to 3%, then one cannot deny that that 2% or

[PEN-L:11191] Egyptian art show

1999-09-17 Thread Louis Proyect
The NY Times has an interesting review of the show I referred to the other day, including a photo of the beguiling sculpture of the King and Queen with her arm wrapped around his shoulder. http://www.nytimes.com/library/arts/091799egypt-art-review.html Louis Proyect

[PEN-L:11188] Fw: Please call for East Timor today

1999-09-17 Thread Arno Mong Daastoel
- Original Message - From: Dr Alan Cheney To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [EMAIL

[PEN-L:11187] Re: IMF to become autonomous?

1999-09-17 Thread Patrick Bond
From: Chris Burford [EMAIL PROTECTED] But could you explain the apparent discrepancy between this remark Go for the nation-state, man, it is the only hope. and this remark in your post on Jubilee 2000 this movement is about neither a "final" or a "short" burst of activity up to 2000. An