Re: Re: Re: Re: What is going on?

2001-04-16 Thread Louis Proyect
Anthony wrote: On this I will have to agree with Brad. I think the (advanced capitalist country) left tends to dismiss growth. It is possible that growth is likely to lead to inequality initially (Kuznets curve) but it does not have to remain that way. If as we find in the Korean case,

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What is going on?

2001-04-16 Thread Louis Proyect
correction: Anthony, I don't think any of the few paleo-Marxists on the list like myself would argue that developing countries can [should be CAN NOT] enjoy spurts of remarkable growth at a given time and in a given place. Louis Proyect Marxism mailing list: http://www.marxmail.org

Re: Re: Water pollution in Mexico

2001-04-16 Thread Louis Proyect
Water is fast becoming the bottleneck to development. Canada is probably unique in having so much good water per capita. I suspect that within 10 years, the world will be turning its attention far more to water than to oil. Sort of a global version of Chinatown -- the old movie. Now, NAFTA is

Re: Water pollution in Mexico

2001-04-16 Thread Michael Perelman
Water farming began in California, where the Bass Brothers -- from Texas -- began buying up farms new San Diego in order to sell water. Farmers in my part of California are selling their ground water -- which is ridiculous, since when they pump "their" water, they are also selling "mine". After

water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Michael Perelman
I think that a New Yorker, Doug Henwood, was the first to point out about water farms. After I pointed out a story concerning the Bass Brothers, he chided me because it was printed in a section of the Wall Street Journal that I should not be reading. In defense, I told him the it was on the

Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: I think that a New Yorker, Doug Henwood, was the first to point out about water farms. After I pointed out a story concerning the Bass Brothers, he chided me because it was printed in a section of the Wall Street Journal that I should not be reading. In defense, I told

Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Ian Murray
http://www.hcn.org [to read about the real Queen of the Desert]

Re: Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread michael
You chided me for reading the Money and Investment section rather than the news section. Michael Perelman wrote: I think that a New Yorker, Doug Henwood, was the first to point out about water farms. After I pointed out a story concerning the Bass Brothers, he chided me because it was

Re: Re: Re: Re: What is going on?

2001-04-16 Thread Jim Devine
Anthony wrote: I think the (advanced capitalist country) left tends to dismiss growth. It is possible that growth is likely to lead to inequality initially (Kuznets curve) but it does not have to remain that way. If as we find in the Korean case, labor-intensive export-led growth did

Necessity test as the mother of Intervention

2001-04-16 Thread Ken Hanly
The Observer (London) Sunday April 15, 2001 Necessity test is mother of GATS intervention by Gregory Palast The World Trade Organisation has plans to replace that outmoded political idea: democracy Trade Minister Dick Caborn says 'nothing' all day, and this keeps him very, very

Necessity test as the mother of Intervention

2001-04-16 Thread Ian Murray
In place of a public interest standard, the Secretariat proposes a deliciously Machiavellian 'efficiency principle': 'It may well be politically more acceptable to countries to accept international obligations which give primacy to economic efficiency.' This is an unsubtle invitation to load the

Re: Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Jim Devine
At 11:30 AM 4/16/01 -0400, you wrote: I heard the Bass story from a college friend of mine who used to live in (and grew up in) the Imperial Valley, a blasted desert that has been heavily irrigated and soaked in toxic chemicals. She told me that the local farmers had decided that post-NAFTA,

Re: Political economy of Jesus

2001-04-16 Thread Jim Devine
At 04:39 PM 4/16/01 +0100, you wrote: Jesus was born at a time and in an area of intense mingling of national and class contradictions and a questioning of ethical values, as the subsequent Jewish wars and the discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls attest. One of the things which was happening was

RE: Political economy of Jesus

2001-04-16 Thread Brown, Martin (NCI)
Short curly hair, and beard, (supported by Paul in Corinthians saying that long hair naturally disgraces a man), darker skin, and rounder features, based on reconstruction of a 1st century skulls from the area. Out of some sort of masochistic impulse I usually catch the odious McLaughlin

Re: What is going on?

2001-04-16 Thread christian11
Not to flog a dead horse, but to return to Ken Hanly's response to the uses and abuses of GDP . . . The two options given were that the rich get $1 million and the poor 1c, and the poor all get $100 and the rich loose $100. Is there something about Pareto optimatlity that makes it impossible

Productivity gap

2001-04-16 Thread Ian Murray
Decoding the 'productivity gap' Nobody would argue with increasing economic efficiency. But how do you define it? Peter Robinson Monday April 16, 2001 The Guardian The government is obsessed with closing the "productivity gap". The Treasury and the Department of Trade and Industry have signed

RE: Re: Re: Re: Re: Market Socialism

2001-04-16 Thread Brown, Martin (NCI)
I've never met anyone so dumb as to claim the fact that the Second International did *no* thinking about what society would look like after the revolution played a role in opening the way for Stalin. Until now... I have not been a part of this thread and tend to generally avoid these kinds

Cincinnati Zapatista Coalition miriamczc@yahoo.com04/16/01 01:28AM

2001-04-16 Thread Charles Brown
Cincinnati Zapatista Coalition [EMAIL PROTECTED] 04/16/01 01:28AM Press Release For Immediate Release April 11, 2001 Further information: Dan La Botz 513-861-8722 Brian Garry 513-236-4180 Steve Schumacher 513-221-2822 A number of individuals and

Market Socialism: Secret Socialism

2001-04-16 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 04/14/01 11:03PM Probably not intentionally calculated to do so. Michael Yates suggested that it was a reflexive action. As I said, it is not a reflex action. It is a mere commonplace: If you refuse to *think* about the future--claim that thinking about the future is

Use of Eminent Domain as a power tool

2001-04-16 Thread Charles Brown
Los Angeles Times, Monday, April 9, 2001 Use Eminent Domain as a Power Tool By MICHAEL J. AGUIRRE Gov. Gray Davis should follow Pacific Gas Electric's example and admit that his electricity program is also bankrupt. The governor's primary objective was to keep the utilities from

Market Socialism

2001-04-16 Thread Charles Brown
Is Brad D. discussing and planning a socialist or a capitalist future ? CB [EMAIL PROTECTED] 04/13/01 05:56PM Wow. On Thu, Apr 12, 2001 at 10:41:54PM -0700, Brad DeLong wrote: I recall how Marx scrupulously tried to avoid discussions about how to organize the future, since it would just

Re: Necessity test as the mother of Intervention

2001-04-16 Thread Ken Hanly
Surely efficiency is not simply a function of rights. Rights certainly are necessary for efficiency--as even eocnomists such as Coase recognize-- and the degree of efficiency may partially is determined by rights structures: but that does not entail that efficiency is a function of rights in that

Re: Re: Water pollution in Mexico

2001-04-16 Thread Ken Hanly
Shouldn't you be able to sue if as a result of the pumping the water table is lowered and your well goes dry? CHeers, Ken Hanly - Original Message - From: Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, April 16, 2001 9:58 AM Subject: [PEN-L:10264] Re: Water

Re: Re: Necessity test as the mother of Intervention

2001-04-16 Thread Carrol Cox
Ken Hanly wrote: 5) Two machines both cost the same. One produces 10 widgets an hour the other 50. Imagine the machines under any system of rights you want. Does the efficiency vary. In some regimes is the first machine more efficient than the second. How come? The goal of the

Re: Re: Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Tim Bousquet
--- Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: isn't water in California agriculture subsidized (relative to cost)? So isn't water-farming taking advantage of the taxpayer? And how. I'll get back to you on the exact numbers, but the biggest scam going is something called the Westlands Water

Re: Re: What is going on?

2001-04-16 Thread Ken Hanly
I was simply pointing out a difficulty in using Pareto optimality as a criterion of an increase in welfare. Actually the situation is even worse since it is not an actual but just a potential increase that is the standard criterion. You can imagine any distribution you like that gives the two

Bloomberg Commentary: Consumers May Begin to Feel the Pain

2001-04-16 Thread Sabri Oncu
Consumers May Begin to Feel the Pain Commentary. Art Pine is a columnist for Bloomberg News. The opinions expressed are his own. By Art Pine Washington, April 16 (Bloomberg) -- One of the most critical uncertainties about the U.S. economy is how much consumers will pull in their horns.

Re: Re: Re: Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread michael
Scams a plenty. When the initial holdings of the Kern Co. land co. came when people claimed to row their boats across wetlands to stake their claims. The land was actually dry at the time, and the boats were atop wagons. The claims still are valid today. -- Michael Perelman Economics

Re: ater farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Michael Perelman
I should have mentioned that the federal gov't only allows 160 acres of land to get subsidized water. The state constructed a multibillion dollar water system to mix state and federal water to make enforcement impossible. The head of Kern Co. land testified, "we have non enforcement of the law,

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: water farms again

2001-04-16 Thread Louis Proyect
Scams a plenty. When the initial holdings of the Kern Co. land co. came when people claimed to row their boats across wetlands to stake their claims. The land was actually dry at the time, and the boats were atop wagons. The claims still are valid today. -- Michael Perelman Speaking of

Re: What is going on?

2001-04-16 Thread christian11
Ken wrote: P.S. My only interest in talking about Pareto optimality is that it is a key value assumption in mainstream welfare economics. Actually an increase in GDP itself does not entail Pareto Optiimality since some could be made worse off by the growth, but presumably it would be a

BLS Daily Report

2001-04-16 Thread Richardson_D
BLS DAILY REPORT, MONDAY, APRIL 16, 2001: The college enrollment rate for the high school graduating lass of 2000 rose 0.4 percentage points to 63.3 percent, but was still far below the record high rate of 67 percent in 1997, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reports. The enrollment rate

A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread Sabri Oncu
Friends, You are amazing. I checked my mailbox after a few days today and there were 82 unread mails. And I am using this address for PEN-L only. Like Michael, I also like to hear from other countries and I am writing this mail to tell this to the friends from these countries. Prior to June

Re: A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread phillp2
2) Most of these lists are dominated by posters from the first world. Most posters from the non-english speaking countries are from the first world. One potential reason is that, despite lack of real democracy, these countries are not as repressive as the non-first world countries and

Re: A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread Louis Proyect
How can we encourage those subscribers from S. Korea, Indoneasia, Brazil, Argentina, Turkey and the like, some of whom most likely are non-experts and some of whom most likely are not-so-well-known experts to join the discussions? Best, Sabri Perhaps we can encourage Michael Perelman to spend a

on Kerala

2001-04-16 Thread Anthony DCosta
For all those admirers from afar of the Kerala model see the following: http://csf.colorado.edu/bcas/kerala/kerther1.htm also same as above...kerala/ker-omv.htm Anthony P. D'Costa Associate Professor

Re: Re: Political economy of Jesus

2001-04-16 Thread Chris Burford
Martin Brown wrote: The house "conservative" Tony Blankley who use to be Newt Gingrich's press guy, was appalled at the "ignoble appearance" presented by this revisionist image. Well at least that is one point for the BBC series! At 09:34 16/04/01 -0700, Jim Devine wrote: One of the things

Re: Re: A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread Michael Perelman
Lou is absolutely correct about my narrow horizons. I have spent a week or so in Cuba, under the tutelage of Jim Devine, and a week in Puerto Rico. Not much, I admit. Perhaps we can encourage Michael Perelman to spend a year travelling in Africa and Asia. Actually Sabri wrote me before he

Re: Re: Re: A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread Louis Proyect
Actually Sabri wrote me before he came on the list, introducing himself as an Indonesian. I did not know where he was located. Now I am confused. I was under the distinct impression that Sabri was from Turkey! Louis Proyect Marxism mailing list: http://www.marxmail.org/

Re: on Kerala

2001-04-16 Thread ravi narayan
Anthony DCosta wrote: For all those admirers from afar of the Kerala model see the following: http://csf.colorado.edu/bcas/kerala/kerther1.htm i do not admire kerala from afar - my father was brought up there and i have lived in the neighbouring state of tamil nadu for 20 of the 30

Re: Re: Necessity test as the mother of Intervention

2001-04-16 Thread Ian Murray
Surely efficiency is not simply a function of rights. They don't say that. Rights certainly are necessary for efficiency--as even eocnomists such as Coase recognize-- and the degree of efficiency may partially is determined by rights structures: but that does not entail that

Re: Re: Re: A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread Sabri Oncu
--- Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Actually Sabri wrote me before he came on the list, introducing himself as an Indonesian. I did not know where he was located. Michael, Sabri is an arabic/muslim name (not that I have any religion) so it is possible that an Indonesian with the

Economic Reporting Review, by Dean Baker, 4/16/01

2001-04-16 Thread Robert Naiman
Economic Reporting Review By Dean Baker You can sign up to receive ERR via email every week by sending a "subscribe ERR" email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] You can find the latest ERR at http://www.tompaine.com/news/2000/10/02/index.html . All ERR prior to August are archived at

Re: Re: on Kerala

2001-04-16 Thread ravi narayan
i wrote: snip list of questions i have to confess that some of the questions i raised in my message were addressed (if not answered to my satisfaction) in the essay. in particular the essay not only suggested that the latest data proves unsustainability but also provided reasons to

Re: Re: Re: A late response to Michael's original invitation [was What is going on?]

2001-04-16 Thread jdevine
Michael Perelman writes: Lou is absolutely correct about my narrow horizons. I have spent a week or so in Cuba, under the tutelage of Jim Devine... hey, I was under _your_ tutelage... In reality, we were both on an urban planning tour in 1970 (run by the late New York GUARDIAN). It's pretty

More on the California Power Crisis

2001-04-16 Thread Ken Hanly
I sent my son David, an economist who works for the Saskatchewan government, a recent post by David Shemano and this is his reply. Cheers, Ken Hanly Hi, What has been indicated below is correct since the state of California stepped in I believe in December (?) when out of state utilities

Re: Re: Re: on Kerala

2001-04-16 Thread Anthony D'Costa
I will have to get back to Ravi's long post later. I am on my way out to discuss, yes, "failed states" and new imperialism. But a quick look suggests some gross factual errors. For example, Bihar being dubbed by Ravi as highly industralized. I hope you are not serious! Bihar is the classic

Re: More on the California Power Crisis

2001-04-16 Thread Tim Bousquet
Does anyone have any information on how the spliting of PGE into two separate entities (PGE Co., which owns the transmission business and is now bankrupt, and PGE Corp., which owns the generating facilities and is now fabulously profitable) has affected stock owners? Seems like the net effect

Talking Points on the FTAA?

2001-04-16 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Has any of you written an article, given a talk, organized a teach-in, etc. on the FTAA (Free Trade Area of Americas)? If you have an article, could you post it here or send it to me offlist? I got invited to be on a panel discussion on the FTAA. What do you think should be my talking

Political economy of Jesus

2001-04-16 Thread Chris Burford
As the religious influence of Christianity arguably fades, popular history presents it in a fuller material political and economic context, and perhaps gives insights into its future role. The 3-part BBC historical documentary made with France 3, which completed on Easter Sunday, has the