generous offer from Ravi

2002-08-12 Thread Rob Schaap
G'day all, If it's any easier, I've a rightly unheralded blog dawdling fitfully along at http://blogorrhoea.blogspot.com/ and would be honoured to put up anything penpals might like to write for the common weal. Er, as long as no technical knowledge other than cutting and pasting is required

God is not making any more water

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
Washington Post, Monday, August 12, 2002 Water's Flow From Private Hands Thirsty, Growing States Turn to New Sources to Meet Demand By William Booth CADIZ, Calif. -- This is one big, dry state, and Keith Brackpool wants to slake its thirst. The politically connected British wheeler-dealer

RE: War in Iraq

2002-08-12 Thread Max B. Sawicky
There is already a liberated Kurdistan. I saw a piece -- forgot where -- about the advisability of federalism for a reconstructed Iraq. That suggests the piecemeal approach that you allude to. Inside the U.S. as far as I can see there is zero meaningful opposition to an invasion. The main

generous offer from Ravi

2002-08-12 Thread Michael Perelman
Justin accidentally sent an article to the list. Ravi sent this note to me: i see this problem crop up every now and then where someone wants to share a document with the list. in the future, if you wish, folks can just email me the doc and i can put it up for HTTP/FTP download on the web and

Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovement His...

2002-08-12 Thread Waistline2
Greetings Economists, Louis Proyect wrote, We have the same requirement today that existed in Russia in 1902 and in the USA in the 70s and 80s, namely to unite scattered Marxist circles and individuals. Understandably, there is a certain amount of gunshyness among Elbaum's generation. The idea of

serious news

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: serious news from Slate's summary of the front pages of major US newspapers, both on the subject of obesity: The NY [TIMES] briefly mentions the latest tensions in the Mideast: Israel lodged a protest with Egypt after the Israeli press reported that Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak

The Wonders of NeoLiberalism

2002-08-12 Thread Michael Perelman
Asked during a news conference in Argentina this week why Latin Americans were increasingly rejecting the magic recipe of privatization, lower tariffs and increased foreign investment, Treasury Secretary Paul H. O'Neill replied, I have no idea. When it was suggested to him that such policies were

Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovement History

2002-08-12 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Louis wrote: We have the same requirement today that existed in Russia in 1902 and in the USA in the 70s and 80s, namely to unite scattered Marxist circles and individuals. If that is the case, I wonder why he isn't a member of the Fourth International, Solidarity and dozens of other groups

Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovement History

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
Jurriaan: If that is the case, I wonder why he isn't a member of the Fourth International, Solidarity and dozens of other groups who argue the same thing. The reason why those groups in the 1970s etc. failed politically was precisely because they thought that Marxism (whatever that is

Backlash in Saudi Arabia

2002-08-12 Thread ken hanly
Backlash in Saudi Arabia By Nawaf Obaid LONDON - As revealed in a recent front-page story in The Washington Post, Briefing Depicted Saudis as Enemies, neoconservatives in the US are gaining a wider audience for their attempts to demonize Saudi Arabia. Such jingoistic talk runs counter to the

RE: Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovement History

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29353] Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovement History what is Stalinophobia? does its rejection mean that we should embrace Stalinophilia? Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://bellarmine.lmu.edu/~jdevine -Original Message- From: Louis

Re: RE: Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On So cialMovement History

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
what is Stalinophobia? does its rejection mean that we should embrace Stalinophilia? Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://bellarmine.lmu.edu/~jdevinehttp://bellarmine.lmu.edu/~jdevine Stalinophobia? I would consider the following as signs of the problem in ATC, a publication that is put

Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Michael, what do you mean when saying Marx began Capital with a stageist flourish - are you referring to the 1859 Preface ? I think Stedman Jones must be correct in stressing the importance of campaigning for reforms, but he is surely wrong in saying that the only alternative is reformism. It

RE: Re: RE: Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On So cialMovement History

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29356] Re: RE: Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On So cialMovement History I don't know about these specific cases, so I'd like to hear what the ATC people say about them. In any event, these points don't answer my question: is there a diffference between the

RE: Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29357] Reform-ism what stageist flourish is that? Marx says that the British case represents the future of the rest of Europe (at the time), but that's hardly stageist. All it says is that he sees capitalism as spreading from the UK to the rest of Europe, as indeed it

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramen to On So cialMovement History

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
Jim Devine: In any event, these points don't answer my question: is there a diffference between the Stalinophobia that Louis decries and (say) the view that Stalin was a bloody dictator who helped establish the rule by a new stratum or class that would fight like hell to preserve their power

stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: stalinophobia [was: RE: [PEN-L:29360] Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramen to On So cialMovement History] I don't see how inaccurate criticism (if that's what Rappaport did) of FARC has anything to do with Stalin or Stalinophobia. FARC isn't Stalinist or

Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovementHistory

2002-08-12 Thread Carrol Cox
Jurriaan Bendien wrote: Louis wrote: We have the same requirement today that existed in Russia in 1902 and in the USA in the 70s and 80s, namely to unite scattered Marxist circles and individuals. We are still in the 1890s (Russia) 1950s (US). It is important to remember that WITBD was

learning from history

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: learning from history RE: [PEN-L:29362] Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovementHistory Carrol: Actually, analogies don't help much. Learn from History is a capitalist not a marxist slogan. What one learns from history is best represented by what the French General

Re: stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
I don't see how inaccurate criticism (if that's what Rappaport did) of FARC has anything to do with Stalin or Stalinophobia. FARC isn't Stalinist or Stalinophilic, is it? Of course it has something to do with hatred of Stalin. The FARC leaders are all veteran Stalinists, but they never set

Re: Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Michael Perelman
The stageism I had in mind was the De te fabula narratur. [I can type in Latin] Marx, as we have discussed numerous times, also supported reforms without reformism. On Mon, Aug 12, 2002 at 06:28:06PM +0200, Jurriaan Bendien wrote: Michael, what do you mean when saying Marx began Capital with

Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Justin Schwartz
I think Stalinophobia means an unreasonable refusal to support Milosovic and an incorrect refusal to recognize that the Yugoslav regime from 1990-98 represented a last bastion of socialism. What this has to do with anything that is relevant today, I don't know. I personally regard Stalin as a

RE: Re: Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:29365] Re: Reform-ism Despite working indirectly for the Roman Catholic Church, I don't read (or speak!) Latin. The Penguin edition translates this as The tale is told of you. What it says to me in context is that Germans of Marx's day can learn a lot about their future from

Re: RE: Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Michael Perelman
Jim, at the time he saw the spread as inevitable, but later he recognized that countries, such as Russia could follow a different course. On Mon, Aug 12, 2002 at 11:53:34AM -0700, Devine, James wrote: what stageist flourish is that? Marx says that the British case represents the future of

Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Michael Perelman
guaranteed flame bait??? On Mon, Aug 12, 2002 at 08:45:09PM +, Justin Schwartz wrote: I think Stalinophobia means an unreasonable refusal to support Milosovic and an incorrect refusal to recognize that the Yugoslav regime from 1990-98 represented a last bastion of socialism. What this

Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Gar Lipow
It seems to me that attacking something called Stalinphobia is more the flame bait. Michael Perelman wrote: guaranteed flame bait??? On Mon, Aug 12, 2002 at 08:45:09PM +, Justin Schwartz wrote: I think Stalinophobia means an unreasonable refusal to support Milosovic and an incorrect

Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Jurriaan Bendien
Michael is quite right. I just don't see any real evidence of Marx arguing for stage-ism, in the sense of a necessary sequence of stages of development. He just says that the more developed capitalist country shows the less developed capitalist country an image of its own future. That is a

Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Justin Schwartz
My comment is flamebait, and Jim's isn't. Care to explain? jks From: Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [PEN-L:29369] Re: Stalinophobia Date: Mon, 12 Aug 2002 14:35:41 -0700 guaranteed flame bait??? On Mon, Aug 12, 2002 at 08:45:09PM

Re: Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
Jurriaan Bendien wrote: stagist way, I suppose). But Trotsky argues no different, he makes the same argument but then in terms of unequal and combined development. I've just been rereading some chapters of his history of the Russian revolution. Boy, was that guy bright or what. Must

Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread phillp2
Michael, I am not sure I agree with you. Appended is an article about the attempt (by the US) to 'Stalinize' Milosevic. Paul Phillips, Economics, University of Manitoba Date sent: Mon, 12 Aug 2002 14:35:41 -0700 From: Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED]> To:

Turkey through the eyes of a Blogorrhoea patient - I

2002-08-12 Thread Sabri Oncu
Dear All, I refer those of you who don't know about this recently discovered psychic condition called Blogorrhoea to the web page of Rob Schaap. The address of his page is below: http://blogorrhoea.blogspot.com/ I had been in Turkey until yesterday and before I left for Turkey in early July, I

Japanese firms cutting pension benefits report

2002-08-12 Thread Ulhas Joglekar
The Economic Times Sunday, August 11, 2002 Japanese firms cutting pension benefits: report REUTERS TOKYO: Declining investment returns are forcing a growing number of Japanese companies to cut pension benefits, according to a government survey reported in the financial daily Nihon Keizai

the l e of cloning

2002-08-12 Thread Ian Murray
Monday, Aug. 12, 2002 Lawyers Group May Endorse Cloning By ANNE GEARAN Associated Press Writer WASHINGTON (AP) - The nation's largest lawyers' group will decide this week whether to endorse cloning to advance human health, while condemning government intervention that would make criminals of

Metropolis

2002-08-12 Thread Louis Proyect
Despite the permanent loss of 25 percent of the original footage, movie-goers can now see a version of Fritz Lang's Metropolis that is faithful to the 1927 version. This dystopian tale of downtrodden workers living deep beneath an ultra-modern city built through their labor includes many

Re: Reform-ism

2002-08-12 Thread Ulhas Joglekar
Jurriaan Bendien wrote: Michael is quite right. I just don't see any real evidence of Marx arguing for stage-ism, in the sense of a necessary sequence of stages of development. He just says that the more developed capitalist country shows the less developed capitalist country an image of its

Re: Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Carrol Cox
I think one can offer a definition of stalinophobia (and though I've never heard the term used, of stalinophilia also). Both consist of the assumption that labelling a political position Stalinist eliminates the need for further thought. To avoid both it is also important not even to accept

Re: Re: Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Michael Perelman
Someone once proposed -- I think they pronounce it a law -- that once the word Hitler appears in the debate all dialogue is finished. If that idea is a law, a Stalin corollary is warranted. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Ian Murray
- Original Message - From: Michael Perelman [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, August 12, 2002 7:24 PM Subject: [PEN-L:29381] Re: Re: Re: Re: Stalinophobia Someone once proposed -- I think they pronounce it a law -- that once the word Hitler appears in the debate

Re: Re: Max Elbaum To Speak In Sacramento On SocialMovement His...

2002-08-12 Thread Doyle Saylor
Greetings Economists, Melvin P replies to my thoughts, Melvin, Welcome to the heat tank. Doyle, Sounds like the hot pot for fresh email posters. ;-) Melvin, His use of the words sectarianism and cult are in my estimate justifiable historically. And also Melvin writes, Suffice it to state that

Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Devine, James
Title: Stalinophobia Michael Perelman writes:Someone once proposed -- I think they pronounce it a law -- that once the word Hitler appears in the debate all dialogue is finished. If that idea is a law, a Stalin corollary is warranted. I don't think so. One reason why Hitler the Nazis

But the work of reconstructing corporate America has barely begun.

2002-08-12 Thread Ian Murray
[Jim Devine is PK gettin' that old time progessive law and economics gestalt going, what's with the multiple turns of phrase? When will we he go after the tax code as a tool for deconstructing corporate america?] August 13, 2002 Clueless in Crawford By PAUL KRUGMAN Today, in its Waco

Re: New Zealand election

2002-08-12 Thread Bill Rosenberg
An update on the final New Zealand election result. Labour has formed a coalition with the PCP (foregone conclusion) with the support in confidence and supply of the economic right/moral conservative United Future Party outside the government. The Greens are signing some kind of agreement

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Stalinophobia

2002-08-12 Thread Gar Lipow
The actual law was that the first person to bring up Hitler was automatically the loser of the debate. Since no one mentioned Stalin until LP brought it up, does that mean this applies to him? Michael Perelman wrote: Someone once proposed -- I think they pronounce it a law -- that once the