[was: [PEN-L:34400] Re: Re: redistributionist
liberals]
Carrol writes: It has always seemed to me that what
demarcates marxism from other working-class trends, liberal, social
democrat, anarchism, etc., is its focus on the social relations
humans enter into in the production and
Devine, James wrote:
[clip]
Above, I'm not disagreeing with Carrol or Lenin as far as I know.
Agreed. Part of the process of moving Lenin's analysis out of the
handbook into the world.
But
I want to quibble about super-imperialism (meaning a unified
rich-capitalist imperialist bloc).
Title: RE: [PEN-L:34406] Re: redistributionism and imperialism
Carrol writes:
I don't think this fundamentally affirms the possibility of
super-imperialism. What Kautsky saw coming was not just a protracted
period of imperialist unity against a serious working-class challenge
