Re: The question of Spain

2000-10-24 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Lou posted: From the introduction to "The Castilian Crisis of the Seventeenth Century", edited by I.A.A. Thompson and Bartolomé Yun Casalilla (Cambridge University Press, 1994): snip Yet Spain’s role in early-modern Europe was pivotal. The economy of Castile, which was four parts or more of

Re: Privatizing Universities All the Way

2000-10-24 Thread Colin Danby
With charter schools — public schools managed by private entities — firmly established and multiplying, some of their advocates are floating a new idea: charter colleges. ... How charter colleges might operate is unclear, since there are no formal proposals yet. But if they operated like

Will George Soros now lavish millions on the Serbs in Kosovo?

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
From a recent Human Rights Watch report: Full text at: http://www.hrw.org/backgrounder/eca/kosovo-election-bck.htm The Pre-Election Climate in Kosovo More than a year after the end of the war in Kosovo, the security situation in the province remains a cause for serious concern. Attacks on

Re: Re: Re: Re: Chemical weapons alert

2000-10-24 Thread Jim Devine
At 08:53 PM 10/23/2000 -0500, you wrote: So which states are against altered states? Utah? Utah makes it very hard to get booze (you have to buy it in state-owned stores), but there are a lot of states (like Nebaraska, I believe) that are influenced by the Protestant "dry" or teetotaler

BLS Daily Report

2000-10-24 Thread Richardson_D
BLS DAILY REPORT, MONDAY, OCTOBER 23, 2000: Regional and State unemployment rates were stable during September, with the Midwest posting the lowest regional jobless rate in the country at 3.5 percent, the Labor Department's Bureau of Labor Statistics reports. All four regions reported little or

Decision 2000: point-four percentage points.

2000-10-24 Thread Max Sawicky
Analysis of Bush and Gore budgets finds that by FY2010, Federal spending as share of GDP is 17.0 and 17.4 percent, respectively. Presently it's 18.2. Note that part of the difference is that Gore proposes twice as much military spending growth as Bush ($100b v. $50b).

marxists.org adds political economy section

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
Marxists Internet Archive Updates http://www.marxists.org/admin/new/ 21 October, 2000: A new section of Classics of Political Economy texts has opened in the Reference Writers Archive, including these recently marked-up titles: http://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/economics/index.htm The

E.Wood's defence of Brenner

2000-10-24 Thread Ricardo Duchesne
*The Origin of Capitalism* is an all-too-brief (131-page) book. The grand title is more a reflection of absolute conviction (and defiance against alternate explanations) than an indication of someone secured that they have established thorough control over the field. If the book is small,

RE: E.Wood's defence of Brenner

2000-10-24 Thread Forstater, Mathew
The view that Walter Rodney, Eric Williams, or contemporary proponents of the Williams-Rodney thesis such as Darity or Ronald Bailey, see capitalism in terms of "opportunity" as opposed to coercion, or that they are promoting a model of Smithian commercialism, or that they see the absence of

RE: Re: Brenner Redux (was Re: Russell R. Menard on Eric Williams)

2000-10-24 Thread Forstater, Mathew
"Noncapitalist" is better than "precapitalist" but even "noncapitalist" still forces these "other" forms to be described, analyzed, explored in terms of capitalism. Unfortunately, as Yoshie points out, it is extremely hard to get around using pre- or non-capitalist as shorthand. Partly it is

RE: [PEN-L:3457] Re: Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (was Re: Brenner Redux)

2000-10-24 Thread Forstater, Mathew
Labor that produces commodities that feed capital accumulation within a generalized system of commodity production and capital accumulation is not pre-capitalist, is not non-capitalist. It is capitalist through and through. It is perhaps the archetypal capitalism. Africans Enslaved in the U.S.,

pre-capitalist?

2000-10-24 Thread Jim Devine
[was: Re: [PEN-L:3459] RE: Re: Brenner Redux (was Re: Russell R. Menard on Eric Williams)] At 05:21 PM 10/24/00 -0500, you wrote: "Noncapitalist" is better than "precapitalist" but even "noncapitalist" still forces these "other" forms to be described, analyzed, explored in terms of capitalism.

what is capitalism?

2000-10-24 Thread Jim Devine
[was: Re: [PEN-L:3460] RE: [PEN-L:3457] Re: Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (w as Re: Brenner Redux) ] At 05:37 PM 10/24/00 -0500, you wrote: Labor that produces commodities that feed capital accumulation within a generalized system of commodity production and capital

Kostunica admits Kosovo killings

2000-10-24 Thread Chris Burford
From the Guardian website. Staff and agencies Tuesday October 24, 2000 Yugoslavia's new president has admitted for the first time that Yugoslav army and police forces committed widespread killings in Kosovo last year. VVojislav Kostunica's remarks, in a television interview released early

UK Kosovo role slammed

2000-10-24 Thread Chris Burford
That is the BBC headline over the report of the House of Commons Select Committee on the Kosovo war. The Commons Defence Select Committee report said the UK air forces were badly equipped and responsible for less than 5% of the Nato sorties flown. Britain's major contribution to the

Re: The question of Spain

2000-10-24 Thread Jim Devine
At 06:40 PM 10/24/00 -0400, you wrote: Like J. H. Elliott in his celebrated article on the decline of Spain three years later, they pointed to the excessive concentration of historians on external influences on the Spanish economy and the relative neglect of internal factors. Agrarian

Re: Kostunica admits Kosovo killings

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
"I am ready to... accept the guilt for all those people who have been killed," Mr Kostunica said. "For what Milosevic had done, and as a Serb, I will take responsibility for many of these, these crimes." He'd better. Or else he won't get paid off from the west. Louis Proyect Marxism mailing

Re: Re: The question of Spain

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
So you're saying that Brenner and other historians are ignorant of what happened in Spain. This -- ignorance -- is exactly the kind of thing that professional historians are quite willing to admit to. But given this _general_ ignorance, we can't presume that Brenner is either right or wrong.

Re: Re: Kostunica admits Kosovo killings

2000-10-24 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:3467] Re: Kostunica admits Kosovo killings, el 24 Oct 00, a las 19:22, Louis Proyect dijo: "I am ready to... accept the guilt for all those people who have been killed," Mr Kostunica said. "For what Milosevic had done, and as a Serb, I will take responsibility for many

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Chemical weapons alert

2000-10-24 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:3447] Re: Re: Re: Re: Chemical weapons ale, el 24 Oct 00, a las 7:23, Jim Devine dijo: BTW, the whole "dry" movement, which stimulated Canadian exports from 1920 or so to the early 1930s by imposing Prohibition on the US, is a prime example of the limits of standard

Re: Re: Re: The question of Spain

2000-10-24 Thread Jim Devine
At 07:29 PM 10/24/2000 -0400, you wrote: When I am ready to say something [about Spain], you will know it. But I won't say anything until I have a chance to review the book carefully. In any case, I've heard 16th century Spain referred to on PEN-L as a country that was ill-equipped to take

Is Kostunica setting the stage for a phony fuel-shortage melodrama?

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
The URL for this article is http://emperors-clothes.com/news/price.htm Is Kostunica setting the stage for a phony fuel-shortage melodrama? by Jared Israel (10-21-2000) www.tenc.net [Emperor's Clothes] Note: The following table is based on reports from employees at two Belgrade supermarkets.

Michel Chossudovsky: Kostunica Coalition Drives Up Prices Blames...Milosevic

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
The URL for this article is http://emperors-clothes.com/articles/chuss/triples.htm Kostunica Coalition Drives Up Prices Blames...Milosevic by Michel Chossudovsky (10-19-2000) www.tenc.net [Emperor's Clothes] "Immediately after taking the office, the new government shall abolish all types

Spain, the Americas, the General Crisis of the 17th Century(was Re: The question of Spain)

2000-10-24 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
From my understanding of 17th century Spain was that it was quite well equipped to take over most of the New World, looting it and enslaving (or enserfing) many people. But the empire wasn't set up to turn that loot into capitalist development, so that they ended up importing crucial

trade pact with Jordon

2000-10-24 Thread Michael Perelman
Do any of you know about the trade pact with Jordon? The NY Times says that labor approved. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

RE: trade pact with Jordan

2000-10-24 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
well it must be true... Do any of you know about the trade pact with Jordan? The NY Times says that labor approved. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University Chico, CA 95929 Tel. 530-898-5321 E-Mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (was Re: Brenner Redux)

2000-10-24 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
CB: OK , but I don't get how this particular fact impacts the question as to whether or not slavery should be analyzed as a component part of capitalism in combination with wage-labor. Indentured servitude might be analyzed as a component part of capitalism too. As I said, capitalism would be

Re: Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (was Re: Brenner Redux)

2000-10-24 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Labor that produces commodities that feed capital accumulation within a generalized system of commodity production and capital accumulation is not pre-capitalist, is not non-capitalist. It is capitalist through and through. It is perhaps the archetypal capitalism. Mat Mat, with your

Re: Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (was Re: Brenner Redux)

2000-10-24 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 10/23/00 10:17PM * Negro slavery was more or less patriarchal _so long as consumption was directed to immediate local needs_. But in proportion as the export of cotton became of interest to the United States, patriarchal slavery was, in the words of Marx, 'drawn into

Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (was Re: Brenner Redux)

2000-10-24 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 10/23/00 10:17PM * Negro slavery was more or less patriarchal _so long as consumption was directed to immediate local needs_. But in proportion as the export of cotton became of interest to the United States, patriarchal slavery was, in the words of Marx, 'drawn

Re: Brenner Redux (was Re: Russell R. Menard on Eric Williams)

2000-10-24 Thread Yoshie Furuhashi
Yoshie Furuhashi quoted: Ideas, of course, are not "national" in themselves. But every Marxist (at least, every Marxist!) should know that ideas which are not roted in the actual stream of human life within their own people will hardly be anything but an exotic overgrowth. This is, in my

Re: Brenner, C. L. R. James, José Carlos Mariátegui (was Re: Brenner Redux)

2000-10-24 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 10/24/00 03:21PM ** To determine if C. L. R. James is empirically accurate, one must really study the _evolution_ of slavery: how the number of slaves increased; what slaves produced, what kind of work they performed, what the median number of slaves owned by a master

The question of Spain

2000-10-24 Thread Louis Proyect
From Ellen Meiksins Wood's "The Origin of Capitalism" (MR, 1999): Marxist historians have persuasively demonstrated, against many arguments to the contrary, that the greatest crime of European empire, slavery, made a major contribution to the development of industrial capitalism. But here, too,