Re: Re: Re: Re: smartness

2000-02-11 Thread Doug Henwood

Brad De Long wrote:

Brad De Long wrote:

Why is there this extraordinary--eager--desire to take Keynes's
quote out of context?

Remarkable, isn't it? Didn't Hayek offer the charming interpretation
that Keynes's queerness made him not care about the future?

Doug

I missed this. Where?

Dunno, can't remember, which is why I phrased it as a question. I'm 
pretty sure I read that somewhere though. Does anyone else here 
recognize that?

Doug



Re: Re: Re: smartness

2000-02-09 Thread Doug Henwood

Jim Devine wrote:

Brad asks:
Why is there this extraordinary--eager--desire to take Keynes's 
quote out of context?

Unfortunately, Brad, quoting out of context is a major indoor sport. 
Marx is quoted out of context more than most. Keynes is hardly the 
only target. Worse are made-up quotes, as seen in the book THEY 
DIDN'T SAY THAT.

Keynes himself fell for that quote attributed to Lenin, about how the 
surest way to destroy a country is to debase its currency, something 
Lenin apparently never said.

Doug



Re: Re: smartness

2000-02-09 Thread Jim Devine

Brad asks:
Why is there this extraordinary--eager--desire to take Keynes's quote out 
of context?

Unfortunately, Brad, quoting out of context is a major indoor sport. Marx 
is quoted out of context more than most. Keynes is hardly the only target. 
Worse are made-up quotes, as seen in the book THEY DIDN'T SAY THAT.

Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED]  
http://clawww.lmu.edu/Faculty/JDevine/JDevine.html



Re: Re: Re: smartness

2000-02-09 Thread Brad De Long

Brad De Long wrote:

Why is there this extraordinary--eager--desire to take Keynes's
quote out of context?

Remarkable, isn't it? Didn't Hayek offer the charming interpretation
that Keynes's queerness made him not care about the future?

Doug

I missed this. Where?

Brad DeLong



Re: Re: smartness

2000-02-08 Thread Doug Henwood

Brad De Long wrote:

Why is there this extraordinary--eager--desire to take Keynes's 
quote out of context?

Remarkable, isn't it? Didn't Hayek offer the charming interpretation 
that Keynes's queerness made him not care about the future?

Doug