Re: What are values with : called?
On 11/2/25 7:13 PM, Bruce Gray wrote:
On Nov 2, 2025, at 20:31, ToddAndMargo via perl6-users
wrote:
On 11/2/25 4:55 PM, Joseph Brenner wrote:
my $proc = run 'echo', 'Raku is Great!', :out, :err;
$proc.out.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «Raku is Great!»
$proc.err.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «»
Hi Joseph,
The default of both :out and :err is "-",
which is STDOUT and STDERR. This is
similar to curl's "--output -" which send
to the STDOUT.
What I find puzzling is where else would they
be going?
They (STDOUT and STDERR) would be going to the standard filehandles of the
*parent* process, just like if you run a command inside a Bash script.
The parent in this case is Raku itself, so they would go to your screen, or
wherever you have redirect all the Raku STDOUT and/or STDERR to.
% raku -e '
say "raku talks to STDOUT";
run(|);
note "raku talks to STDERR";
run(|);
' > a.txt 2>b.txt
% cat a.txt
raku talks to STDOUT
.
% cat b.txt
raku talks to STDERR
ls: fake: No such file or directory
The spawned command 'ls' exited unsuccessfully (exit code: 1, signal: 0)
in block at -e line 5
Can I modify :out to :out("eraseme.txt") and
have the output go to a file (eraseme.txt)
instead of STDOUT? That would be kind of cool.
Yours in puzzlement,
-T
`:out` can take a argument, but it needs a filehandle, not a filename.
It you want to open it in-line, it must be a *writable* filehandle, so this
will not work:
:out("eraseme.txt".IO)
Instead, use this:
:out("eraseme.txt".IO.open(:w))
or, open the filehandle separately, potentially to use it across several `run`
commands, then close it manually.
Hi Bruce,
I am slowly catching on.
:out and :err set to "-" are "capturing" the STDOUT and
STDERR to $p.out and $p.err. Otherwise they go to your
console/shell.
And if you want to alter then, your need to provide
and file handle.
Thank you!
-T
Re: What are values with : called?
> On Nov 2, 2025, at 20:31, ToddAndMargo via perl6-users
> wrote:
>
> On 11/2/25 4:55 PM, Joseph Brenner wrote:
>>my $proc = run 'echo', 'Raku is Great!', :out, :err;
>>$proc.out.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «Raku is Great!»
>>$proc.err.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «»
>
> Hi Joseph,
>
> The default of both :out and :err is "-",
> which is STDOUT and STDERR. This is
> similar to curl's "--output -" which send
> to the STDOUT.
>
> What I find puzzling is where else would they
> be going?
They (STDOUT and STDERR) would be going to the standard filehandles of the
*parent* process, just like if you run a command inside a Bash script.
The parent in this case is Raku itself, so they would go to your screen, or
wherever you have redirect all the Raku STDOUT and/or STDERR to.
% raku -e '
say "raku talks to STDOUT";
run(|);
note "raku talks to STDERR";
run(|);
' > a.txt 2>b.txt
% cat a.txt
raku talks to STDOUT
.
% cat b.txt
raku talks to STDERR
ls: fake: No such file or directory
The spawned command 'ls' exited unsuccessfully (exit code: 1, signal: 0)
in block at -e line 5
> Can I modify :out to :out("eraseme.txt") and
> have the output go to a file (eraseme.txt)
> instead of STDOUT? That would be kind of cool.
>
> Yours in puzzlement,
> -T
`:out` can take a argument, but it needs a filehandle, not a filename.
It you want to open it in-line, it must be a *writable* filehandle, so this
will not work:
:out("eraseme.txt".IO)
Instead, use this:
:out("eraseme.txt".IO.open(:w))
or, open the filehandle separately, potentially to use it across several `run`
commands, then close it manually.
--
Hope this helps,
Bruce Gray (Util of PerlMonks)
Re: What are values with : called?
On 11/2/25 4:55 PM, Joseph Brenner wrote:
my $proc = run 'echo', 'Raku is Great!', :out, :err;
$proc.out.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «Raku is Great!»
$proc.err.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «»
Hi Joseph,
The default of both :out and :err is "-",
which is STDOUT and STDERR. This is
similar to curl's "--output -" which send
to the STDOUT.
What I find puzzling is where else would they
be going?
Can I modify :out to :out("eraseme.txt") and
have the output go to a file (eraseme.txt)
instead of STDOUT? That would be kind of cool.
Yours in puzzlement,
-T
Re: What are values with : called?
On 11/2/25 4:55 PM, Joseph Brenner wrote: ToddAndMargo wrote: my Proc $p = run( |@args, :err, :out ); What are the values with the ":" in front of them officially called? I take it "thingies with the colon in front of them" does not cut it. They're colon-pairs, though you'll also see them called "adverbs" depending on context. You could call them adverbs here-- they're flags that turn on different behavior for the output. https://docs.raku.org/routine/run If you want to capture standard output or error instead of having it printed directly you can use the :out or :err arguments, which will make them available using their respective methods: Proc.out and Proc.err. my $proc = run 'echo', 'Raku is Great!', :out, :err; $proc.out.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «Raku is Great!» $proc.err.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «» You could see a construct like that used with an argument though, in which case it's an "adverbial pair": https://docs.raku.org/syntax/Adverbial%20Pair Adverbs get used a lot with regular expressions, where the syntax is different: https://docs.raku.org/syntax/Regex%20adverbs Thank you!
Re: What are values with : called?
ToddAndMargo wrote: > my Proc $p = run( |@args, :err, :out ); > > What are the values with the ":" in front of them > officially called? I take it "thingies with the > colon in front of them" does not cut it. They're colon-pairs, though you'll also see them called "adverbs" depending on context. You could call them adverbs here-- they're flags that turn on different behavior for the output. https://docs.raku.org/routine/run If you want to capture standard output or error instead of having it printed directly you can use the :out or :err arguments, which will make them available using their respective methods: Proc.out and Proc.err. my $proc = run 'echo', 'Raku is Great!', :out, :err; $proc.out.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «Raku is Great!» $proc.err.slurp(:close).say; # OUTPUT: «» You could see a construct like that used with an argument though, in which case it's an "adverbial pair": https://docs.raku.org/syntax/Adverbial%20Pair Adverbs get used a lot with regular expressions, where the syntax is different: https://docs.raku.org/syntax/Regex%20adverbs
Re: What are values with : called?
On 11/2/25 3:31 PM, ToddAndMargo via perl6-users wrote: Hi All, In the following: my Proc $p = run( |@args, :err, :out ); What are the values with the ":" in front of them officially called? I take it "thingies with the colon in front of them" does not cut it. Many thanks, -T search.brave.com's AI to the rescue. Is this correct? Sounds to me somewhat like a hash. https://search.brave.com/search?q=raku+what+values+with+a+colon+in+front+of+them+called%3F&spellcheck=0&source=alteredQuery&summary=1&conversation=e2eb9c9060b8b4e26cf857 In Raku, values with a colon in front of them are known as colon-pairs. These are used to create Pair objects and are often employed as named arguments in function calls. The colon-pair syntax can take various forms, such as :identifier which creates a Pair with the key being the identifier and the value being Bool::True, or :!identifier which creates a Pair with the value being Bool::False. T hey can also be used with a value, like :key(value), which is equivalent to key => value
