Re: Loop controls

2002-04-27 Thread Allison Randal
Hmmm... some discussion generated on this subject, but fairly light. I take that as an indicator that an Celse on loops is a fairly popular idea. The other possibilities are that b) people don't want any form of else on loops and aren't saying so or c) people simply don't care, but silence and

Re: Loop controls

2002-04-27 Thread Paul Johnson
On Sat, Apr 27, 2002 at 05:20:06AM -0500, Allison Randal wrote: Hmmm... some discussion generated on this subject, but fairly light. I take that as an indicator that an Celse on loops is a fairly popular idea. The other possibilities are that b) people don't want any form of else on loops

Re: Loop controls

2002-04-27 Thread Allison Randal
On Sat, Apr 27, 2002 at 10:53:09PM +1000, Damian Conway wrote: Allison wrote: And the discussion of scope led to (what I think is) an interesting tidbit on NAMED blocks... Which I presume was that the proposed usage: while $result.get_next() - $next { # do something with

Re: Loop controls

2002-04-27 Thread Damian Conway
Allison wrote: This leads me to conclude that a normal (trailing, un-nested) Celse is a much more reasonable construct for a Cwhile -- and at least arguable for a Cfor. And Cloop, I hope. Sure. I always think of a Cloop as just a Cwhile with delusions of grandeur. ;-) Of course, one

Re: Loop controls

2002-04-27 Thread tex
Allison Randal wrote: Hmmm... some discussion generated on this subject, but fairly light. I take that as an indicator that an Celse on loops is a fairly popular idea. The other possibilities are that b) people don't want any form of else on loops and aren't saying so or c) people simply

Going meta to tagmemic rhetoric (was Re: Loop controls)

2002-04-27 Thread Allison Randal
On Sat, Apr 27, 2002 at 12:50:49PM +0200, Paul Johnson wrote: Here's another possibility. People trust Larry to get it right and don't feel the need to weigh in with opinions. I trust Larry. That's actually why I feel free to play the devil's advocate. I trust him to toss the dross and