Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Michael Lazzaro
On Wednesday, November 26, 2003, at 12:29 PM, Larry Wall wrote: If you contrast it with an explicit try block, sure, it looks better. But that's not what I compare it with. I compare it with Perl 5's: $opus.write_to_file($file) or die "Couldn't write to $file: $!"; That has some known prob

Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Michael Lazzaro
On Wednesday, November 26, 2003, at 01:50 PM, Michael Lazzaro wrote: my $c = (defined($a) ? $a : $b); Sorry, P5. Before the grammar police attack... my $c = (defined($a) ?? $a :: $b); Parens for clarity. MikeL

Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Simon Cozens
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Michael Lazzaro) writes: > I think we also need to be skeptical of the false economy of putting such > sugar into CP6AN, if a sizable portion of the community is going to > download it anyway. "The standard Perl library will be almost entirely removed. The point of this is to fo

Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Michael Lazzaro
On Wednesday, November 26, 2003, at 12:13 PM, chromatic wrote: On Wed, 2003-11-26 at 11:39, Michael Lazzaro wrote: I think we also need to be skeptical of the false economy of putting such sugar into CP6AN, if a sizable portion of the community is going to download it anyway. A more interesting q

Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Mark J. Reed
On 2003-11-26 at 12:13:39, chromatic wrote: > Consider Perl 5, where File::Find is a core module. While the interface > may have been nice in 1995 (though I doubt even that), it's been widely > regarded as awful for at least three years. It's likely never to be > removed from the core. File::Fin

Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Larry Wall
On Wed, Nov 26, 2003 at 11:39:41AM -0800, Michael Lazzaro wrote: : On Monday, November 24, 2003, at 03:28 PM, Luke Palmer wrote: : >Damian Conway writes: : >>In which case I think we just fall back to: : >> : >>try{$opus.write_to_file($file); CATCH {die "Couldn't write to : >>$file: : >>$!

Re: 'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread chromatic
On Wed, 2003-11-26 at 11:39, Michael Lazzaro wrote: > I think we also need to be skeptical of the false economy of putting > such sugar into CP6AN, if a sizable portion of the community is going > to download it anyway. A more interesting question is *when* to put something into the core language

'Core' Language Philosophy [was: Re: 'catch' statement modifier]

2003-11-26 Thread Michael Lazzaro
On Monday, November 24, 2003, at 03:28 PM, Luke Palmer wrote: Damian Conway writes: In which case I think we just fall back to: try{$opus.write_to_file($file); CATCH {die "Couldn't write to $file: $!"}} which is, after all, only 5 characters longer than: $opus.write_to_file($file) c