Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-21 Thread Chaim Frenkel
> "TC" == Tom Christiansen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: TC> Ok, so you want message catalogues, and not solely on Perl but anything TC> in the distribution. You should say that. No. That is independent of what I'm suggesting. What I'm suggesting is an enabler. I've seen code that actually l

Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-20 Thread Tom Christiansen
Ok, so you want message catalogues, and not solely on Perl but anything in the distribution. You should say that. --tom

Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-20 Thread Chaim Frenkel
> "TC" == Tom Christiansen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: TC> I'm saying that you can't know what to check for, because you don't TC> know who generated the exception. Can you use your fancy constants? Then please tell me how anyone has ever coded $@ =~ // They don't know what to

Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-20 Thread Tom Christiansen
>> "TC" == Tom Christiansen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >>> Currently many programs handle error returns by examining the text of >>> the error returned in $@. This makes changes in the text of the error >>> message, an issue for the backwards compatibility police. >TC> eval { fn() }; >

Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-20 Thread Brad Hughes
Perl6 RFC Librarian wrote: [...] > =head1 TITLE > > All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier > [...] > An id string could have some structure associated to enable > better handling. One suggestion was to follow the lead of VMS. > > facility: > The program

Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-20 Thread Chaim Frenkel
> "TC" == Tom Christiansen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >> Currently many programs handle error returns by examining the text of >> the error returned in $@. This makes changes in the text of the error >> message, an issue for the backwards compatibility police. TC> eval { fn() }; TC>

Re: RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-19 Thread Tom Christiansen
>Currently many programs handle error returns by examining the text of >the error returned in $@. This makes changes in the text of the error >message, an issue for the backwards compatibility police. eval { fn() }; if ($@ == EYOURWHATHURTS) { } sub fn { die "blindlesnot" }

RFC 85 (v2) All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier

2000-09-19 Thread Perl6 RFC Librarian
This and other RFCs are available on the web at http://dev.perl.org/rfc/ =head1 TITLE All perl generated errors should have a unique identifier =head1 VERSION Maintainer: Chaim Frenkel <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: 9 Aug 2000 Last Modified: 19 Sep 2000 Mailing List: [EMAIL PROTECTED] N