Dear all:
Method in the historical sciences...with examples from ancient
marsupials!
Best, Jeremy B
------
Jeremy Butterfield:
Trinity College, Cambridge CB2 1TQ: Tel: 07557-668413 (mobile)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Butterfield
---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Mon, 17 Oct 2016 20:19:41 +0100
From: Adrian Currie <ac2...@cam.ac.uk>
To: "hps-discuss...@lists.cam.ac.uk <hps-discuss...@lists.cam.ac.uk>"
<hps-discuss...@lists.cam.ac.uk>,
Subject: +++ First McMenemy Seminar of Term - 19 October. Come listen toAdrian
Currie talk about extinct species
Hi all,
See below for details of the first McMenemy seminar at Trinity Hall this term,
delivered by, um, me. It will be an accessible look into the philosophy of
historical science, with plenty of extinct marsupials... Its being held in the
Bridgetower room â just ask at the entrance.
Adrian Currie
Postdoctoral Researcher, CSER (http://cser.org/)
https://sites.google.com/site/adrianmitchellcurrie/
http://www.extinctblog.org/
From: McMenemy Seminar TH
Sent: 17 October 2016 08:28
To: trinhall-mcr-c...@lists.cam.ac.uk
Subject: +++ First McMenemy Seminar of Term - 19 October. Come listen toAdrian
Currie talk about extinct species
Dear MCR members,Â
You are welcome to attend the McMenemy Seminar in the Leslie Stephen Room this
coming Wednesday (19 October) from 6.30 o'clock (Please note the different time
from last year).Â
Come listen to Adrian Currie present his research about Australia's extinct
species and the way he tackles the question.Â
His presentation is entitled "Stories, Omnivores & Marsupial Lions: how do we know
so much about the past?"Â
Please also download and add to your calendars the seminars of this term - all
listed in the term card.
-----Â
Here is the abstract of Adrian Currie's presentation.Â
Australiaâs Pleistocene boasted an array of strange critters. In addition to
giant wombats and kangaroos, enormous lizards and the rhino-sized Diprotodon,
the largest mammalian predator was Thylacoleo carnifex, the so-called
âmarsupial lionâ (although Iâll argue that marsupial bulldog is a more
appropriate moniker). There is a rich debate about T. carnifex, how it lived
and how it killed, which Iâll use to consider the nature of historical
evidence and science.
When philosophers and scientists reflect on evidence from the deep past, we
often conclude that it is impoverished: after all, signals decay and
millennia-old events are hardly amenable to the controlled, repeated
experiments which are the by-word of scientific success. However, the
historical sciencesâgeology, archaeology, paleontology, and cosmology, for
instanceâare extremely successful. Our understanding of past events and
patterns, and the processes which shape them, continues to deepen. So, why so
much success in the face of such terrible evidence?
Iâm going to argue that this tension is resolved when we see that it is our
understanding of historical method and evidence which is impoverished, not the
evidence itself.
Iâll highlight two aspects of how historical scientists think which explains
their success. First, Iâll argue that narrative consistencyâtelling a
coherent storyâis a more significant epistemic achievement than is typically
recognised. In addition to linking existing traces to the past, historical
scientists knit their hypotheses about the past together, often using
well-confirmed, systematic theories. These linksâstoriesâextend our reach
into the past. Second, Iâll emphasize the opportunism of historical
scientists, their capacity to co-opt, adapt and incorporate a wide range of
different kinds of evidence and techniques. This âmethodological omnivoryâ
explains how they do so much, with so little.
...brought to you by HPS-discussion.
To subscribe or to be removed please send mail to hps-ad...@lists.cam.ac.uk.
_____________________________________________________
To unsubscribe from the CamPhilEvents mailing list,
or change your membership options, please visit
the list information page: http://bit.ly/CamPhilEvents
List archive: http://bit.ly/CamPhilEventsArchive
Please note that CamPhilEvents doesn't accept email
attachments. See the list information page for further
details and suggested alternatives.