[PHP-DEV] Suggest: Have PHP Session cookies-enabled check use any cookie

2002-03-10 Thread Matt Richardson
Hi, I don't know if this has been discussed before, but I have a suggestion about how PHP checks whether cookie support is enabled. Here is my understanding of the current setup: On the first PHP page encountered, all links will be turned into GET style URLS with the session id attached because

Re: [PHP-DEV] Suggest: Have PHP Session cookies-enabled check use any cookie

2002-03-10 Thread Daniel Lorch
hi, [..] If it were set up like this, we could then set a dummy cookie with a long lifetime on their first visit to the site. [..] -2 people tend to dislike cookies - many see cookies as a dangerous threat to their privacy and security (that's why IE 6.0 blocks almost all DANGEROUS cookies

Re: [PHP-DEV] Suggest: Have PHP Session cookies-enabled check use any cookie

2002-03-10 Thread Marcus Börger
The good idee is to set a cookie...and if so not to modify anything. What you missed is that you need not get any cookie if you did not write one yourself (but that does not affect your idea). We could simply leave an old session-cookie and reread it - that shouldn't be a security problem.

Re: [PHP-DEV] Suggest: Have PHP Session cookies-enabled check use any cookie

2002-03-10 Thread Matt Richardson
This is an interesting idea -- simply having the old session cookie stay around longer. On the server side, you'd probably want to keep track of the time the session was created and if it's an old session then change the session id (I don't know if that's easy or hard). I think for security it is