Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Cami Sardinha
Nigel Kukard wrote: >> Bleh. This is what the OP's problem is. He was doing >> recipient throttling at the end_of_data phase. I'm >> simply stating that it won't work regardless of what >> version of Policyd is being used as Postfix does not >> provide that information to Policyd at that stage. >

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Nigel Kukard
> > v2 overcomes this and tracks the recipients for each smtpd instance. To > > track quotas precisely v2 can be used in smtpd_recipient_restrictions > > and smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. v2 knows about the various > > restrictions. > False. You will not be able to use Reci

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Cami Sardinha
Nigel Kukard wrote: > v2 overcomes this and tracks the recipients for each smtpd instance. To > track quotas precisely v2 can be used in smtpd_recipient_restrictions > and smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. v2 knows about the various > restrictions. False. You will not be able to

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Nigel Kukard
> >>> v2 overcomes this and tracks the recipients for each smtpd instance. To > >>> track quotas precisely v2 can be used in smtpd_recipient_restrictions > >>> and smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. v2 knows about the various > >>> restrictions. > >> False. You will not be able to use Recipient throt

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Cami Sardinha
Nigel Kukard wrote: >>> v2 overcomes this and tracks the recipients for each smtpd instance. To >>> track quotas precisely v2 can be used in smtpd_recipient_restrictions >>> and smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. v2 knows about the various >>> restrictions. >> False. You will not be able to use Recipi

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Nigel Kukard
> > v2 overcomes this and tracks the recipients for each smtpd instance. To > > track quotas precisely v2 can be used in smtpd_recipient_restrictions > > and smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. v2 knows about the various > > restrictions. > > False. You will not be able to use Recipient throttling at

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-06 Thread Cami Sardinha
Nigel Kukard wrote: >>> Recipient Throttling can not work at smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. >>> What happens when 1 message has multiple recipients? >>> >>> Cami >>> >> Yes, the problem arises as soon as there is a message with more than one >> recipient. As far as I know, Postfix does not pas

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-05 Thread Nigel Kukard
> > Recipient Throttling can not work at smtpd_end_of_data_restrictions. > > What happens when 1 message has multiple recipients? > > > > Cami > > > Yes, the problem arises as soon as there is a message with more than one > recipient. As far as I know, Postfix does not pass multiple recipient

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-05 Thread Edi Füllemann
Cami Sardinha schrieb: > Edi Füllemann wrote: > >> invalid triplet_array[8][2]: (recipient throttle): >> >> As I have turned off everything except throttling, I do not expect policyd >> to care about triplets. >> >> The server is debian etch with policyd version 1.80 >> >> This is from main.cf

Re: [policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-04 Thread Cami Sardinha
Edi Füllemann wrote: > invalid triplet_array[8][2]: (recipient throttle): > > As I have turned off everything except throttling, I do not expect policyd to > care about triplets. > > The server is debian etch with policyd version 1.80 > > This is from main.cf > smtpd_recipient_restrictions = >

[policyd-users] two instances of policyd: greylisting and throttling

2008-04-03 Thread Edi Füllemann
Hi all, i'm trying to set up a solution where one instance of policyd is invoked at smtpd_recipient_restrictions to do the greylisting and a second instance at smtpd_end_of _data_restrictions for the throttling part. Everythink works fine except messages with more than one recipient. Then the seco