Re: [prometheus-developers] Feature request: Setting a custom lookback delta for a query

2021-11-22 Thread Darshan Chaudhary
(slightly tangential) > We want richer metadata anyway, +1, richer metadata about the data in tsdb will be required for the query optimizer too. IMO without the metadata, the optimizer cannot choose the best query plan (order of evaluating the query). On Monday, 22 November 2021 at 17:28:36

Re: [prometheus-developers] Is this alerting architecture crazy?

2021-11-22 Thread Tony Di Nucci
> Honestly, most of what you want is stuff we could support in Alertmanager without a lot of trouble. And are things that other users would want as well. Rather than build a whole new system, why not contribute improvements directly to the Alertmanager. That's a very good point and something I

Re: [prometheus-developers] Is this alerting architecture crazy?

2021-11-22 Thread Ben Kochie
On Mon, Nov 22, 2021 at 4:03 PM Tony Di Nucci wrote: > Thanks for the feedback Stuart, I really appreciate you taking the time > and you've given me reason to pause and reconsider my options. > > I fully understand your concerns over having a new data store. I'm not > sure that AlertManager and

Re: [prometheus-developers] Is this alerting architecture crazy?

2021-11-22 Thread Tony Di Nucci
Thanks for the feedback Stuart, I really appreciate you taking the time and you've given me reason to pause and reconsider my options. I fully understand your concerns over having a new data store. I'm not sure that AlertManager and Prometheus contain the state I need though and I'm not sure

[prometheus-developers] É PEDOFILO ASSASSINO: #SILVIOBERLUSCONI! É FIGLIO, MARITO, PADRE E PAGATORE DI PUTTANE SU PUTTANE: IL SATANISTA NAZISTA, MAFIOSO E STRAGISTA SILVIO BERLUSCONI! NE SCRIVE L'EROE

2021-11-22 Thread EDOARDO LOMBARDI. EX CRIMINALI FININVEST MEDIOLANUM
É PEDOFILO ASSASSINO: #SILVIOBERLUSCONI! É FIGLIO, MARITO, PADRE E PAGATORE DI PUTTANE SU PUTTANE: IL SATANISTA NAZISTA, MAFIOSO E STRAGISTA SILVIO BERLUSCONI! NE SCRIVE L'EROE SVIZZERO ANDREAS NIGG DI BANK J SAFRA SARASIN ZURICH, PREMIATO COMEBANCHIERE ELVETICO DELL'ANNO NEL 2018,

Re: [prometheus-developers] Evolving remote APIs

2021-11-22 Thread Bjoern Rabenstein
On 18.11.21 16:36, 'Fabian Reinartz' via Prometheus Developers wrote: > > A central issue is that the remote APIs expose the Prometheus storage data > model. It is notably different from the Prometheus/OpenMetrics > instrumentation model and discards most of the structure known at scrape > time.

Re: [prometheus-developers] Feature request: Setting a custom lookback delta for a query

2021-11-22 Thread Bjoern Rabenstein
As a short- to mid-term remedy, I like the idea of a lookback-delta per query. Long-term, I would prefer if we could get rid of the lookback delta altogether. We want richer metadata anyway, and part of it could be when a series starts and ends and what the configured scrape interval was. Once we

Re: [prometheus-developers] Enable auto merge

2021-11-22 Thread Bjoern Rabenstein
On 16.11.21 14:17, Levi Harrison wrote: > > Recently, I've come across a few instances where auto-merge would have been > helpful and was wondering if consensus had been reached here. My impression was that the discussion dwindled because it became increasingly unclear what we are even